204: "Poison Kisses & Power Plays: Rinna’s Last Stand and Candace vs Rob Begins" (Feat. Jazmine Henley-Brown & Parish Hassell)
Castmates… After The Murder is back and episode 7 of The Traitors US (Season 4) gave chaos, couture, and cold-blooded gameplay.
Welington is joined by a stellar panel — Jazmine from Channel Surf and Parish (host of Pardon Me TV) — to break down the infamous banquet that kicked off the episode in full “black dinner” madness. From Lisa Rinna’s founding-father-meets-sailor realness to Candiace’s Medusa headpiece, we rank the best looks… then get straight into the mess.
The faithfuls scramble for the antidote as accusations fly, Natalie goes full fight-or-flight, and the cursed victim reveal shakes the whole castle. Then the game flips again with a new twist: a dagger that gives TWO votes — and Rob gets his hands on it… which is terrifying for everyone not named Rob.
At breakfast, the cracks in the turret turn into a full-on Traitors civil war: Rob refuses to protect Rinna, Rinna checks Colton, and Candace makes it clear she’s not going down quietly. By the time we hit the roundtable, it’s Rinna’s last stand, Yam Yam’s dying words become a smoking gun, and Rob goes way too aggressive… forcing Candace into a shocking vote that changes the whole endgame.
We close with predictions: Who wins the Traitor vs Traitor battle — Candiace or Rob? And should Candace target Colton first, or cut the snake off at the head?
Subscribe to After The Murder, follow TRR Radio + The Reality Rundown, and drop your vote in the comments: Team Candace or Team Rob?
20 Jan 2026
203: “Secrets, Shields & Screaming Matches: When Being Loud Gets You Banished” (Feat. Anthony Polanco)
This week on After The Murder, Welington Gomez is joined by Anthony Polanco (By Latin Men) for a very spirited breakdown of The Traitors Episode 5 — and whew… the faithfuls are a MESS.
We unpack Tiffany Mitchell’s shocking banishment and why being too smart is basically a death sentence in the castle, debate whether Michael Rapaport talked his way out of the game, and question why certain players keep skating by while others get thrown under the roundtable — fast.
From Eric’s infamous “laugh” testimony, to Colton’s chaos, to Candice walking a dangerously thin line as a traitor with no one truly riding for her, we get into:
Whether Tiffany was unfairly targeted
If Michael deserved to be banished regardless of being faithful
The power dynamics, biases, and trust issues shaping every vote
Why some faithfuls survive simply by staying quiet
And how one wrong move could flip the entire game next episode
Plus, we break down the shield twist, speculate on who should be murdered next, and predict how long the traitors can keep running the castle before the walls start closing in.
If you love strategy, shade, and unfiltered opinions — this episode is appointment listening.
🩸 Because even when there’s no murder… the mess never stops.
17 Jan 2026
202: “Trust No One at the Roundtable” The Traitors US Season 4, Episode 4 Recap (Feat. Katherine Pfost)
Summary
In this episode of "After the Murder," hosts Welington F. Gomez and Katherine Pfost dive deep into the latest developments of Season Four of "The Traders." They express their excitement about the show's evolving dynamics, particularly the strategic gameplay and the emotional stakes involved. The conversation highlights the tension surrounding the recent banishment of Tiffany, a faithful player, and the implications of Eric's testimony that swayed the round table's decision. The hosts analyze the gameplay strategies of various contestants, including the importance of alliances and the risks of emotional connections in a high-stakes environment. They also discuss the producers' efforts to keep the game fresh and engaging, noting how the challenges are designed to limit the traders' options, thereby increasing the suspense.
Keywords
The Traders, reality TV, podcast, gameplay analysis, episode recap, entertainment law, Catherine Faust, Welington Gomez, reality show dynamics, emotional stakes
Takeaways
'I hope you are watching Traders because it is so good.'
'The producers have really leveled up their game this season.'
'You have to play that line.'
'It's a lot going on and y'all are all coming for me.'
'I believe you believe what you heard.'
'You can't take criticism, football player.'
'You don't have to be a Phaedra Parks to shine.'
'You can tell he thinks he's really giving.'
'You need to adapt now.'
'You might need to get a new career moving forward because you're wrong.'
Titles
The Traders: Emotional Stakes and Strategic Moves
After the Murder: Tiffany's Banishment and Game Dynamics
Sound bites
"It is so good."
"I'm popping your sherry."
"Y'all didn't deserve me."
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and Excitement for The Traders
00:53 Overview of Season Four
01:47 Gameplay Analysis of Episode Four
03:51 Character Dynamics and Strategies
09:45 Producers' Impact on the Show
14:54 Emotional Decisions and Gameplay Conflicts
19:44 Final Thoughts and Predictions
26:29 Introduction and Initial Reactions
26:45 Tiffany vs. Colton: The Round Table Tensions
29:47 Emotional Stakes: Tiffany's Defense
33:43 Eric's Testimony and Its Impact
36:31 Candice's Solidarity and Gameplay
41:46 The Aftermath of Tiffany's Banishment
44:32 Looking Ahead: Strategies and Predictions
17 Jan 2026
201: "Justice For The Housewives"
The Traitors US Sdeason 4 Episodes 1-3
6 Feb 2024
103: The Traitors US Season 2 Episode 6 Recap
Airdate: February 1, 2024
Murdered: Bergie (Blocked by Shield)
Mission Synopsis: Catapult Build
The 13 contestants had to make their way to an incomplete giant catapult, collecting catapult pieces along the way to fully assemble it. Once complete, they then had to fire a golden cannonball and make sure it hit the distant target to win $20,000. They had one hour to complete the Mission. Along the route, Shield cannonballs could also be collected, and each contestant holding these cannonballs would be eligible to fire them at the target as well. The contestant whose Shield cannonball came closest to the target bullseye would then win a Shield.
Prize Earned: $20,000 out of $20,000
Shield: Shereé
Banished: Dan (11-1-1)
31 Jan 2024
102: The Traitors US Season 2 Episode 5 Recap
Airdate: January 25, 2024
Murdered: Tamra
Mission Synopsis: Bird Calls
The group of 14 contestants were split into three pairs of 'runners' who ran about the castle grounds with a marked map, and a group of eight that stayed behind in the castle. Within a time limit of 20 minutes, the runners located various stations, where they heard a bird call after blowing their whistles. They then imitated this call back to the castle group via radios; the castle group then had to search among various stuffed birds to find the one that made the right call, as well as where it could be found (with only one guess per bird call). Each correct bird call identified (with a maximum of 6) netted $2,500, alongside a bird in the Walled Garden that would net the runners that mimicked it Shields if the castle group guessed it correctly.
Shields: Bergie & Trishelle
Intruder: Kate
Prize Earned: $10,000 out of $15,000
Banished: Janelle (9-5)
29 Jan 2024
101: What's the 411 inside the Traitor’s Castle
Traitors Selected: Dan & Phaedra
Mission Synopsis: Beacon Lighting
Together, the 22 contestants worked together to build a giant beacon and set it alight in the middle of a loch, by gathering and rearranging the puzzle pieces for the beacon first. To guide the group, a replica of the puzzle was also hidden among bottles scattered along the loch shore. In order to set it ablaze, all players must have left the water; however, they were first tied up to a pole, and needed to untangle themselves first, and deciding whether to go for a Shield (two in the loch and one on land), start the puzzle or help someone untie themselves first. Completing the Mission within 40 minutes would earn the group $15,000.
Prize Earned: $30,000 out of $30,000
Shields: CT, Deontay & Janelle
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Contact After The Murder
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of After The Murder?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
