In the summer of ‘22, two men were found dead in an apparent murder/suicide. One rich, one poor, both desperately clinging to a long doomed love. The police tied it up and neatly closed the case, but 3 years later new evidence and old feelings were stirred up that broke it wide open again.
This is the story of what happens when you scratch away a gold façade and find the truth underneath.
This is all that glitters.
The knot unties.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Jack Baziuk, Andrew Solis, Sibonelo Shezi, Mike Crugnola, Lindsay M. Palinsky, and Pablo Munoz-Evers
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
10 Feb 2026
Episode 9: Falling Action
Klipspringer recounts everything he remembers from the day of the murders. An arrest is made. A confession follows.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Aleena Azhar, Sibonelo Shezi, Mike Crugnola, Savanah Martinez, Darwin Ragsdale, Jack Baziuk, and Andrew Solis
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
3 Feb 2026
Episode 8: Climax
Tom's lawyer is called in to mediate between Tom and the officers. Jordan Baker is also re-interviewed, but is interrupted by the case making front page news. Nick convinces Jenny that Jay was worth the toll this case is taking. Someone walks in claiming to know who committed the murder.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Sibonelo Shezi, Andrew Solis, Brian Hensley, Mike Crugnola, Lindsay Palinsky, Darwin Ragsdale, Pablo Munoz Evers, and Aleena Azhar.
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
27 Jan 2026
Episode 7: Rising Action 4
Detective Amory officially (but quietly) agrees to reopen the case based on the new evidence Nick and Jenny found. Nick has second thoughts. Detective Barban appears, unhappy with Jenny, but in need of her assistance. Tom is called in as the first witness to be re-interviewed.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Mike Crugnola, Sibonelo Shezi, and Brian Hensley
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
20 Jan 2026
Episode 6: Rising Action 3
Nick insists they take a break from the case. Jordan Baker crosses their paths and Jenny takes on an assignment.
New evidence appears at the mansion.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers and Lindsay M. Palinsky
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
13 Jan 2026
Episode 5: Rising Action 2
William Fay stomps in, and Jenny gets some time to hear Daisy's side of the summer. A threat is issued.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Giulia Garbani, Kaprecia Pridgen, Savannah Martinez, Jack Baziuk
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
6 Jan 2026
Episode 4: Rising Action
Tom explains why Daisy left him. Jenny and Nick travel to Louisville to try and get Daisy's side of the story, where they meet her mom, Clara.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Giulia Garbani, Kaprecia Pridgen, Savannah Martinez, Brian Hensley
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
30 Dec 2025
Episode 3: Conflict
Jenny finds new evidence before listening to the old interviews of Michaelis and Catherine to learn more about George. She has big feelings about how Detective Amory handled the case and makes them clear. Nick and Jenny pay a visit to Tom and Daisy's house.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Mike Crugnola, Tony P. Henderson, Giulia Garbani, Chris Casey, Brian Hensley
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
23 Dec 2025
Episode 2: Exposition 2
Jenny and Nick meet with Detective Amory to get the case files. They meet at the station to listen to two of the original interviews before Jenny takes the evidence to her hotel to look through more closely.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Mike Crugnola, Lindsay M. Palinsky, Savanah Martinez, Brian Hensley
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
16 Dec 2025
Episode 1: Exposition
We meet Nick, hear his story, and see the evidence that could crack open a years'-old closed case.
___
Written, Produced, Edited by Steph Crugnola
Featuring: Pablo Muñoz-Evers, Mike Crugnola
Music: Josh Kavanaugh
15 Dec 2025
TRAILER: All That Glitters
This is the story of what happens when you scratch away a gold façade and find the truth underneath.
This is all that glitters.
Releases weekly on Tuesdays.
Produced by Steph Crugnola
Music by Josh Kavanaugh
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
4 ratings
Contact All That Glitters
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of All That Glitters?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
