We (Luke and Amber) are a long term married couple who are passionate when it comes to laughing and arguing. We have spent endless hours in these bantering loops. We are not experts in anything but our own relationship, though we think we are. The topics that have sent us spiralling range from completely unimportant to deep issues. Like most people we have no real facts to back up our opinions and you may catch us slyly googling and only sharing our findings if it suits our side. The real question in the end always is, who is right? Join us as we debate and then you get to vote for the winner!
From Peter Stumpp to Pop Culture: Real Werewolf History & Best Fictional Beasts S2 E13
Are werewolves pure movie magic, or is there a terrifying historical reality behind the beast? 🐺🌕In this episode of Arguing Ever After, we unpack the dark lore and real history of the werewolf! We share harrowing stories from historical records—including the 16th-century trial of Peter Stumpp and the mysterious Beast of Gévaudan—and break down how real medical conditions like rabies and porphyria fueled the panic. Plus, we go head-to-head debating our favorite fictional werewolves of all time across cinema, TV, and literature!📊 WE WANT YOUR VOTE: Use the Spotify poll below to vote right now—who is the ultimate fictional werewolf?🎧 ENJOYING THE SHOW?• Hit the FOLLOW button so you never miss a new debate!• Leave us a 5-STAR RATING on Spotify to help new listeners find the show!• SHARE this episode on your social stories and tag us to join the conversation!
13 Oct 2026
The Mummy’s Curse: Real Ancient Revenge or Historical Myth? S2 E12
Is the Mummy’s Curse a real ancient warning or history’s greatest media hoax? 🧟♂️🏺✨In this episode, we unpack the terrifying legend behind King Tutankhamun’s tomb and the series of mysterious deaths that shocked the world in the 1920s. Did Lord Carnarvon and the excavation team succumb to a dark pharaoh's curse, or was it toxic mold (Aspergillus flavus), ancient bacteria, and a sensationalized press campaign?We break down the historical evidence, the science behind ancient tomb mold, popular culture's obsession with Egyptian lore, and whether any truth remains behind the legend of King Tut’s revenge.👇 WE WANT YOUR TAKE!Is the Mummy’s Curse pure media sensationalism, or do some tomb deaths remain unexplained? Drop your thoughts in the comments!🔔 ENJOYING THE SHOW?• LIKE this video if you love ancient mysteries and history debates!• SUBSCRIBE to the channel for weekly deep dives, historical breakdowns, and pop culture discussions.• SHARE this episode with a friend who loves Egyptian history or horror lore!#MummysCurse #KingTut #AncientEgypt #Archaeology #HistoryDebate #Podcast #UnexplainedMysteries #PharaohsCurse
6 Oct 2026
The Lore of Bloody Mary: Who Was She Really? | Spooky Season Debate
Who was Bloody Mary, and why are we still terrified of saying her name three times in the dark? 🪞🩸It’s Spooky Season on Arguing Ever After, and we’re dissecting the lore behind the ultimate sleepover urban legend! In this episode, we debate the real-world inspirations behind Bloody Mary—from Queen Mary I of England and Elizabeth Báthory to pure folklore and mirror-induced brain tricks. Who makes the stronger case for who she really was? Tune in for the history, the science, and our signature couple's banter!📊 CAST YOUR VOTE: Use the Spotify poll below to vote right now! Would you try the Bloody Mary mirror ritual?🎧 ENJOYING THE SHOW?• Hit the FOLLOW button so you never miss a Spooky Season episode!• Leave us a 5-STAR RATING on Spotify to help new listeners find the debate!• SHARE this episode on your Instagram Stories and tag us to let us know who won today's debate!
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
4.3 / 5
6 ratings
Spotify
5.0 / 5
13 ratings
Contact Arguing Ever After
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Arguing Ever After?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
