Hosted by two industry insiders, Bethany Yamawaki & Danny Love- Casting Stories Untold features weekly guests and dives into the untold and unfiltered stories from reality TV stars and casting professionals. From off-camera moments to personal secrets that never made it to air, we bring you the stories you haven’t heard...straight from the people who lived them.
From Motor City to the Highlands of Scotland, the legendary Tiffany Mitchell is here! This week, we are sitting down with the Big Brother icon and The Traitors US star to talk about her rise from a fan with a journaled dream to a reality TV powerhouse. In this episode, we’re diving into how a missed DM almost cost her a spot on The Traitors, and the moment she thought the official offer was actually a fan prank. We discuss why she recorded 35 takes of her audition video and how her "doing it anyway" mentality changed her life forever. We take an inside look at her new “empty nester” life of freedom, her "poker-face" dating questions, and why she’s looking to trade the Detroit snow for the L.A. sun! Whether you know her as the architect of “The Cookout” or as one who refuses to be a "punk" in a challenge- this episode is about authenticity, resilience, and style. Get ready, because Tiffany is bringing the heat (and turning off the fireplace)!
2 Apr 2026
Jeremy Simon & Bailey Brown
From the beaches of Costa Rica to the snowstorms of Brooklyn, Paradise’s favorite couple is in the house! This week, we are joined by Jeremy (The Bachelorette S21) and Bailey (The Bachelor S29) to talk about falling in love on camera and navigating a long-distance-ish relationship.
The couple gives us an unfiltered look at life after the final rose…how they survived months of hiding from the public with hats, glasses, and a very suspicious wig- plus the story of the American fan who caught them red-handed at a restaurant in Portugal. They tell the truth about the "Task Rabbit" project required to fit Bailey’s massive wardrobe into Jeremy’s Brooklyn loft. Bailey dives into her life as the world’s pickiest eater, her "no sauce" rule, and why she’s an open book when it comes to her IBS struggles. We hear the story of Jeremy’s mom crashing his zoom audition to give producers a pitch on why her son is a catch. They reveal why they both went into Paradise with "no thoughts, all vibes," and which competition shows they’d be willing to join next- as long as there are no cockroaches involved.
Whether you’re a Bachelor Nation fan or just here for the talk on manifesting a relationship that lasts, this episode shows their connection is stronger than ever!
7 Mar 2026
William Hung
This week, we are joined by the man who redefined resilience and authenticity on the national stage- William Hung. From his viral American Idol audition to topping the billboard charts, William is here to prove he is anything but one-note! We go beyond the audition room to explore what it was like to release three albums (including “Hung for the Holidays”), tour the world from Iceland to Singapore, and eventually fulfill a bucket-list dream by performing in Vegas with Ricky Martin himself! William shares how he transitioned from a shy civil engineering student to a data whiz with an MBA and a Master’s, now serving as a Data Analytics Manager for LA County. He gets real about surviving death rumors, paparazzi following him in Hong Kong, and his honest journey through (and recovery from) gambling addiction. We discuss behind-the-scenes moments from the sets of Arrested Development (where he played "Hung Jury"), The Goat, and his favorite talk shows. Get ready for an inspiring conversation about the power of taking risks. Whether you know William as the guy who stood up to Simon Cowell or the researcher fighting for environmental justice, this episode is about living with no regrets!
20 Feb 2026
Paul Abrahamian
This week, we sit down with Paul Abrahamian- the two time Big Brother runner-up who is officially back to embrace the chaos on the new season of House of Villains!
In this episode, Paul takes us inside his personal home museum, where history meets the macabre. We dive deep into Paul giving us the tea on living with icons like Tiffany Pollard aka New York, and surviving the savage roasts of Joel McHale, how Paul rescued the lost "El Cairo" collection from a swap meet floor, featuring death masks, signed occult books, and a secret Hollywood script that reveals a historical beef with Mark Twain. We learn the surprising reason Paul walked away from a career in law and his experiences providing humanitarian aid on the front lines in Armenia. He tells us why he’s ditching new merch to focus on rehoming relics and artifacts that tell a story, all while maintaining a minimal physical footprint. Come hang with us as Paul shares the anxiety-inducing reality of being back on TV in a new social media age!
7 Feb 2026
Perla Figuereo
The Bronx’s newest millionaire has entered the chat! This week, we are joined by the one and only Perla, the winner of Squid Game: The Challenge, to talk about her wild journey from a "bad modeling job" to a $4.56 million windfall. In this episode, Perla breaks down what it’s really like to survive the dorms and why she’s embracing the "crybaby" label as a superpower. We dive into how she managed to keep her massive win a secret from the world for an entire year.
We debate the game being 90% luck and 10% skill, and how her "social capital" actually paved her way to the finish line. She discusses the ritual she used to make sure she represented her identity and we get the tea on her rivalry with Player 183 and their "enemies to love" TikToks.
Whether you’re here for the behind-the-scenes drama of Slides and Ladders or Perla’s tips on "manifesting through your hair," this episode is a lesson in staying authentically yourself while winning big. Come hang with us and Perla Figuereo!
31 Jan 2026
Alyssa Edwards
We’re kicking off our Season 2 premiere with the legendary Alyssa Edwards (aka Justin Johnson), the first winner of RuPaul’s Drag Race Global All-Stars and the star of Netflix’s Dancing Queen! Join us as Justin dives into the transition from a shy kid in Mesquite, Texas, to a global drag superstar. He shares about his Beyond Belief Dance Company and an inside look at the “get ready” room…filled with show-stopping ensembles! Justin discusses his journey of becoming unapologetically himself, including the journey of his relationship with his father. We also reflect on the evolution of drag from underground nightclubs to mainstream success, and about his experience competing on The GOAT. We hear why he chose to stay in Texas to be a mentor and leader for "little Justins" who need a safe place to stand out. Don't miss this episode, as we start our new season with a true icon!
Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
15 Aug 2025
Ep. 12 - Robyn Kass
Join us for an exciting deep dive into the world of reality TV casting with Robyn Kass, owner of Kassting, inc and a true pioneer in unscripted television! Robyn spills the tea on her incredible career, starting with her own experience as an 18-year-old dating show contestant. She shares starting the first all-service reality casting company, and the initial fear of working outside traditional production offices. We remember the "good old days" of casting- recruiting at fraternities and sororities, going to bars with a clipboard & Polaroid, and receiving VHS submissions by mail. Hear about casting challenges like the "exes" twist on Big Brother and anecdotes from a "reality show movie" (including running from cops at a party). Robyn shares about the "tall guy wall" in her office, and we discuss the finals process for some of our favorite shows! Robyn is the Season Finale guest you don’t want to miss!
Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
1 Aug 2025
Ep. 11 - Ray Gantt
Get ready for a wild ride (literally) with reality TV veteran Ray Gantt! From his breakout casting on “Love Island USA” Season 1, to Covid interrupting “The Amazing Race” (where he got stuck for hours trying to drive a stick shift) and navigating the emotional rollercoaster of “Love Island Games” with his real-life friends, even though it led to him being sent crying memes of himself from his buddies. Now, he's back and ready to find a vibe on “Perfect Match”, premiering this Friday, August 1st on Netflix! He'll tell us about being a "bombshell" on the show, and teach one host how the term is used (hint- it’s not a Frank Sinatra throwback). Tune in to hear all about his incredible journey, what he's learned, and how he keeps creating amazing opportunities for himself! Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
25 Jul 2025
Ep. 10 - Nick Morgan
In this episode of "Casting Stories Untold," Bethany and Danny host Nick Morgan- the winner of CBS’s The Summit! The conversation covers Nick's journey from a Louisiana warehouse worker to now serving as an Executive Vice President! They discuss how he used his prize money, and how his engagement was a surprise. He shares his long-standing desire to compete, his casting experience, and his time on The Summit, which he admits was a terrifying experience (given his fear of heights and claustrophobia)! Nick describes how he leveraged his sales skills for gameplay, and how much of his strategic work was not fully shown on television. They touch on the evolution of the casting process and the focus on finding good personalities for compelling television rather than just winners!
Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
17 Jul 2025
Ep. 9 - Andrew Miller
Get ready for a candid conversation with Andrew Miller, the unforgettable presence from Big Brother Canada Season 6! Despite an early exit, Andrew made a statement, discussing the tough realities of being an early target due to his "Heaven and Hell" power, and facing micro-aggressions in the game. Hear about his casting journey, including how he applied more than once! Andrew opens up about how his Big Brother experience (coupled with the profound personal challenge of his wife's medical journey) redirected his life goals- making him a better person. Discover how he's become a true force for good, spearheading the One More Wear Foundation to provide school supplies, shoes, and support. Andrew reveals how he's built a life that's "more than Big Brother," constantly proving doubters wrong and showing that resilience pays off!
Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
10 Jul 2025
Ep. 8 Derrick Levasseur
This episode of Casting Stories Untold features Derrick Levasseur, the winner of Big Brother 16 and a seasoned host of various shows and podcasts, including Crime Weekly! Derek pulls back the curtain on his past as an undercover detective, sharing how he applied those unique skills to win Big Brother (and why he strategically lied about his profession!) He offers chilling insights into the Bryan Kohberger case, discussing the suspected motive and the intricacies of the crime scene. Get ready for some real-world safety advice as Derek reveals tips for deterring criminals! Plus, he candidly discusses his experience on 'The Traitors', why he didn’t want to be a traitor, and how the immense toll of police work has shaped his parenting and life perspective! Don't miss this deep dive into his career, family, and the realities of true crime.
Like, share and follow us on Instagram: @CastingStoriesUntold
26 Jun 2025
Ep 7- Cara Maria
Cara Maria, reality TV icon, recounts her journey from underdog to champion on The Challenge, revealing her fears, motivations, and unique path to stardom in an interview.
18 Jun 2025
Ep. 6 Adam Pike
Adam Pike recounts his transformative journey from oil field welder to reality TV contestant and content creator, including a life-altering ayahuasca experience and near-drowning on Canada's Ultimate Challenge, in an interview with Bethany and Danny.
11 Jun 2025
Ep. 5- Michelle Burgos & Luis Colon
Michelle Burgos and Luis Colon share their experiences on The Amazing Race, Michelle's time as a Pitbull dancer, and Luis's appearance on The Challenge in an interview with Bethany and Danny.
4 Jun 2025
Ep. 4 - Victoria "Spicy Vee" Woghiren
Victoria "Spicy Vee" Woghiren discusses her journey from foster care to Big Brother Canada and becoming a school social worker in this interview with Danny and Bethany.
25 May 2025
Ep. 3 - Dom Gabriel
Reality TV star Dom Gabriel discusses his experiences on reality shows like *The Mole* and *Perfect Match*, including navigating public perception and staying true to himself in an interview with Danny and Bethany.
18 May 2025
Ep. 2 - Rachel Reilly
Join Casting Stories Untold as Bethany and Danny chat with the legendary Rachel Reilly- Big Brother champ, Amazing Race icon, and reality TV queen! Get the details of Rachel's experience with the intense Big Brother casting (confidentiality rules and bikini tops), hear the story that helped her stand out, and find out how she embraced being a competitive "shit starter" and the reality TV "villain". From navigating social media pressures to her own journey into a casting career (earning her a "PhD in reality TV"!) , Rachel holds nothing back. Don't miss this deep dive with one of reality television's most enduring personalities!
Follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
10 May 2025
Ep 1 - Josh Martinez
From Big Brother blowups to Challenge battles, Josh Martinez has seen it all! In this episode we hear the story of how this reality star used his prize money (it’s smarter than you think!) He also gets real with Danny & Bethany about the shocking side of fame, battling online hate, and the deep family values that kept him grounded. Listen for an unfiltered look at the man behind the reality TV persona! From porta potties to pigeons join us as we hear the untold stories of Josh Martinez.
Follow us on Instagram: @castingstoriesuntold
3 May 2025
Introducing Casting Stories Untold
Hosted by two industry insiders, Bethany Yamawaki & Danny Love- Casting Stories Untold features weekly guests and dives into the untold and unfiltered stories from reality TV stars and casting professionals. From off-camera moments to personal secrets that never made it to air, we bring you the stories you haven’t heard...straight from the people who lived them.
Who has been a guest on Casting Stories Untold
Names identified in recent episode analyses. Showing up to five guests.
Cara Maria
Adam Pike
Michelle Burgos
Luis Colon
Victoria "Spicy Vee" Woghiren
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
9 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 27 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
42
Social presence
0
YouTube
0
Engagement
32
Host of Casting Stories Untold?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
