Caught Looking is the premier destination for softball fans who want more than just highlights.
Hosted by Olympic Silver Medalist and 3x World Champion Haylie McCleney and pro softball standout and LMU Hall of Famer Sam Fischer, the show offers an unfiltered, insider perspective on the college and professional game.
From in-depth conversations with the sport’s top players and coaches to detailed game breakdowns and real insight into what it takes to succeed on and off the field, Caught Looking sits at the intersection of performance, personality, and culture.
Built for players, coaches, and fans who want to understand the game at a deeper level — this is where softball’s next era is being shaped.
Subscribe Now and don’t miss a pitch.
This episode features a lively discussion on recent softball regionals, including strike zone issues, baserunning blunders, notable moments, surprising results, outstanding performances, controversies, home run distances, and super regional predictions. Sam & Halo cover predictions and analysis of various super regional matchups, including Oklahoma vs. Mississippi State, Oklahoma State vs. Nebraska, Florida vs. Texas Tech, UCLA vs. UCF, and Tennessee vs. Georgia. The hosts discuss key players, team strengths, and their expectations for each series. The conversation also includes personal reflections, humorous anecdotes, and expressions of excitement for the upcoming games. Don't get caught looking!
13 May 2026
Episode 4 - The Bracket is Here!
This episode begins with a discussion about the excitement of postseason softball and the hosts catching up after a busy week. The conversation then shifts to controversies in youth softball, emphasizing the importance of respecting the game and avoiding unsportsmanlike behavior. The episode concludes with a focus on Oklahoma's loss and the parity in the NCAA tournament, highlighting the competitive landscape of college softball. The conversation delves into the changing landscape of softball, highlighting the shift away from the separation of power four and mid-major programs. It also explores the importance of well-roundedness in teams and its impact on making it to the World Series. The discussion then moves on to regional and super regional predictions and analysis, providing insights into the teams and their potential paths to success. The conversation covers exciting regional predictions and expectations for various softball teams, including Arizona, Oregon, Texas A&M, and Virginia Tech. It also delves into the AUSL and pro softball, highlighting the excitement and anticipation for the upcoming season.
23 Apr 2026
Episode 3 - Midweek Madness
The conversation covers a range of topics including the impact of Halo's crazy week, the mental approach to mid-major upsets, Maya Johnson's pitching dominance, and the advantage of mid-major players in the pro league. Additionally, the discussion delves into the impact of resources on player development and the trend in youth softball development. The conversation delves into the importance of attention to detail in softball, emphasizing the impact of small adjustments and precision in gameplay. It also covers recent softball series, player assessments, Kendall Wells' record-breaking home runs, predictions for the softball world series, and the impact of NIL on college softball.
16 Apr 2026
Episode 2 - Are Bat Flips Allowed?!
The first official episode of 'Caught Looking' introduces the hosts and dives into the drama of the Oklahoma Texas series, sparking a debate on the appropriateness of bat flips in softball after Katie Stewart's Walk Off Bat Spike. The conversation then explores the role of emotions and role modeling in softball, concluding with a discussion on controlling emotions and learning from failure. Sam & Halo highlight the importance of learning from failure, managing emotions, building confidence, and understanding the diverse ways in which players express their investment in the game.
What do you think? Bat flips or no bat flips?
15 Apr 2026
Episode 1 - Welcome to Caught Looking!
Haylie McCleney and Sam Fischer introduce their new podcast venture, 'Caught Looking,' focusing on softball and baseball. They discuss their transition to the new podcast, upcoming topics and events, an inside look at their lives, the experience of being a softball player, and their social media and sponsorship plans.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
3.0 / 5
2 ratings
Host of CAUGHT LOOKING?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
