In this completely legitimate movie podcast, join Makaila and her husband Nick, two Midwestern Millennials who recap and review movies so you can know if it's worth the two hours of your time to watch it yourself! One host is an enthusiastic movie buff and the other is watching most of these movies for the first time. From the Oscar winners to the low-budget schlock, we'll tackle just about anything (with plenty of sarcasm and jest in between).
Makaila and Nick give their thoughts on the 2008 stoner comedy... with some technical difficulties.
25 Dec 2025
A Christmas Story!
Hosts Makaila and Nick celebrate the holiday season by diving into the classic film "A Christmas Story" and discussing favorite Christmas movies and family traditions.
12 Dec 2025
Season 2 Premiere: Wicked
Hosts Makaila and Nick review the movie adaptation of the hit musical Wicked, offering their analysis of the film in this episode.
22 Aug 2025
Season 1 Finale: Slumdog Millionaire!
Hosts Nick and Makaila review the Oscar-winning film Slumdog Millionaire in this Season 1 finale episode.
8 Aug 2025
Episode 10: Broken Lizard's Club Dread
Chelsea joins Nick and Makaila to dissect the comedic horror film *Club Dread* by Broken Lizard in this interview episode.
25 Jul 2025
Episode 9: Joker
Makaila and Nick review DC's Elseworlds film, Joker, analyzing the character's origin story and its impact on the superhero genre in this episode.
11 Jul 2025
Episode 8: The Perks of Being a Wallflower!
Hosts Makaila and Nick analyze the film *The Perks of Being a Wallflower* and attempt to define the advantages of being a wallflower.
27 Jun 2025
Episode 7: Rent!
Makaila defends the musical Rent against Nick's criticisms, exploring why it resonates with audiences in this interview episode.
13 Jun 2025
Episode 6: Pootie Tang!
Makaila, Nick, and Jake discuss the movie Pootie Tang, exploring its humor and cultural impact in this interview episode.
30 May 2025
Episode 5 - Anora
Hosts Makaila and Nick discuss the Oscar-winning movie *Anora*, offering their fresh perspectives as they experience the film without prior knowledge in this episode.
16 May 2025
Episode 4 - Face/Off
Nick and Makaila review the movie Face/Off. You know, that movie where Nicolas Cage takes his face off.
9 May 2025
Bonus Episode 2! Nick's Birthday
We celebrate Nick's birthday by going over his top five movies of all time!
2 May 2025
Episode 3: Pretty Woman
Listen as Nick and Makaila review the classic movie (which Nick had never seen!) Pretty Woman.
18 Apr 2025
Episode 2: Will & Harper
Nick and Makaila review Netflix Documentary Will & Harper, with some laughs along the way, and Makaila's passionate defense of Kristen Wiig.
11 Apr 2025
Bonus Episode: Makaila's Top Five
In celebration of Makaila's birthday, she lists her top five movies of all time.
4 Apr 2025
Episode 1: Emilia Perez
On our premiere episode, Makaila and Nick tackle Netflix's Emilia Perez and it's tone-deaf musical numbers.
** Please note, we discuss a new potential Selena Gomez album. I said I love You First, her fourth studio album, has since been released.
28 Mar 2025
Trailer
Join Makaila and Nick for commentary, banter, and yes, expletives, as they break down their movie of choice. New episodes will be posted every other Friday.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
5,532
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Podcast Authority Score: 25 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
23
Social presence
0
YouTube
65
Engagement
0
Contact Completely Legitimate Movie Podcast
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Completely Legitimate Movie Podcast?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
