Crafting the Case

About Crafting the Case

Where true crime meets creativity - stitching together the stories that keep you up at night. Three women dive deep into chilling true crime cases, eerie mysteries, and spooky tales - all while crafting and creating. Join us as we weave together suspense, storytelling, and a touch of creativity in every episode of ”Crafting the Case”.

Publisher

craftingthecase

Category

true crime

Language

en

Explicit

No

First episode

21 Mar 2025

Latest episode

29 Oct 2026

Latest episodes

51 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   29 Oct 2026

   SEASON 2: Episode 51 - Hiatus and Homicide

   🎙️ Episode 51: New Season, Same Shenanigans! 🎃🔪 WE'RE BACKKKKK! After a little hiatus, we're officially calling this SEASON TWO of Crafting the Case! 💀✂️ This week, we're getting spooky and crafty with some stained glass Halloween art while Tara takes us back to 1950s California for the chilling Trick or Treat Murder of Peter Fabiano. Let's just say this Halloween night was anything but sweet. 🍬🔪 Plus, we've got lots of catching up to do, an aftershow, and of course, our usual chaos! New season, same questionable crafting skills and true crime obsession. 🖤 🎧 Episode 51 is out now! #CraftingTheCase #SeasonTwo #TrueCrimePodcast #TrickOrTreatMurder #HalloweenTrueCrime #CraftingAndCrime

2. 

   24 Sept 2026

   Episode 50 - Witchcraft and Wishes

   🎉 EPISODE 50: Witchcraft and Wishes WITCH, PLEASE! 🧙♀️✨ We made it to 50 episodes, and obviously we had to celebrate Crafting the Case style — by dressing up as witches, making Wish Boxes, and getting a little spooky. 🔮 This week, all three of us bring a witchy tale to the table! Sandi takes us into the legend of Moll Dyer, Tara shares some witch spells, and Ashley digs up a wonderfully bizarre 1904 newspaper story titled “Witchcraft Near Halifax.” 👀 Plus, we’ve got What in the World, all three of us actually doing the craft together, plenty of chaos, and of course, the After Show! Fifty episodes of cases, crafts, questionable decisions, snacks, tangents, and a whole lot of laughs. 🖤 Thank you SO much for listening, watching, sharing, and hanging out with us for the last 50 episodes. We seriously can’t believe we’re here! Grab your broom, make a wish, and come celebrate Episode 50 with us! 🧹✨

3. 

   17 Sept 2026

   Episode 49 - Diamonds and Deadlocked

   This week on Crafting the Case, we're diving into the heartbreaking and complicated Lindsay Clancy case. Sandi takes us through Lindsay's mental-health journey, the deaths of her three children, the competing arguments at trial, and the shocking 2026 mistrial. Devin joins us as our special legal analyst to break down criminal responsibility, reasonable doubt, the reported 11–1 jury split, and what could happen next. Meanwhile, Ashley and Tara tackle a diamond art piece, we fuel up with Starbucks, sample chocolate from around the world courtesy of Devin, and catch up in the After Show. 💎☕🍫⚖️ ⚠️ This episode discusses the deaths of young children, suicide, severe mental illness, and postpartum mental health.

Who has been a guest on Crafting the Case

Names identified in recent episode analyses. Showing up to five guests.

• Ashley Norman
• [Guest Name]
• Devin
• Freya

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

Spotify

5.0 / 5

10 ratings

Podcast Authority Score: 14 / 100

A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.

Quality

15

Social presence

0

YouTube

0

Engagement

32

Shows with a similar audience

• 

  Nighttime

• 

  Crime Junkie

• 

  Morbid

• 

  SmartLess

• 

  Betrayal

• 

  Good Hang with Amy Poehler