Beyond the Unknown with Toby is a mystery podcast exploring unsolved disappearances, true crime cases, historical enigmas, and unexplained events from around the world. Join Toby as we investigate stories that challenge belief and search for answers hidden beyond the unknown.
The Truth Begins to Surface: What Really Happened to Nolan Wells?
The search for Nolan Xavier Wells has come to a heartbreaking end, but the investigation is far from over. In Part 2 of this episode, Crime Vault International by Toby examines what happened after search teams made a devastating discovery near Horn Island, Mississippi. We explore the recovery operation, the theories investigators considered, the dangers of the Gulf Coast waters, and the many unanswered questions surrounding Nolan's final hours. As authorities continue searching for the truth, Nolan's family and friends are left hoping that the investigation will provide the answers they deserve. Was this simply a tragic accident, or will new evidence reveal more about what happened that July afternoon? Join us as we continue this emotional true crime investigation with respect for the victim, his loved ones and the facts established by the investigation. If you enjoy well-researched true crime documentaries, follow Crime Vault International by Toby for more real crime cases, missing person investigations and untold stories from around the world. #TrueCrime #CrimeVaultInternational #NolanWells #MissingPerson #CrimeDocumentary #UnsolvedMysteries #TrueCrimePodcast
This episode includes AI-generated content.
8 Jul 2026
He Stayed Behind on the Island… Then He Vanished | The Nolan Wells Mystery
The Last Boat Ride: The Mystery of Nolan Wells’ Disappearance on Horn Island A summer holiday. A peaceful island. A young man who never made it home. In this episode of Crime Vault International by Toby, we investigate the heartbreaking case of Nolan Xavier Wells, an 18-year-old college athlete whose July 4th boat trip with friends ended in tragedy. Nolan travelled to Horn Island, Mississippi, expecting a day of fun, friendship and celebration. But after his friends left the island, Nolan stayed behind, and what happened next became a mystery that brought together law enforcement, rescue teams and volunteer search groups. This episode explores the timeline of Nolan’s disappearance, the desperate search across the Gulf Coast waters, the discovery that shocked his family and the unanswered questions that investigators continue to examine. What happened during those missing hours?
Was this a tragic accident caused by the dangers of the water?
Or are there details still waiting to be uncovered? Join Crime Vault International by Toby as we explore real cases, hidden truths and the stories behind the headlines. Follow the channel for more deeply researched true crime investigations, missing person cases and mysteries from around the world. #TrueCrime
7 Jul 2026
The True Crime Archive: Exploring the World’s Most Shocking Criminal Cases
Welcome to The True Crime Archive Podcast, a journey into the world’s most fascinating and unsettling criminal cases. Each episode explores real events from the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Germany and across Europe, bringing you the stories behind the headlines. We examine shocking crimes, mysterious disappearances, complex investigations, courtroom battles and cases that continue to raise questions years later. Through detailed storytelling and careful research, we explore the people, evidence and events that shaped each case while remembering the victims and the impact these stories had on families and communities. Tune in to The True Crime Archive Podcast as we open the files, follow the evidence and uncover the truth behind some of the most compelling cases from around the world. Subscribe and join us for stories of mystery, investigation and the search for answers.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
29 Jun 2026
How an Online Lie Turned Into Attempted Murder | A True Crime Story (Part 2)
Episode Description Welcome to Episode 2 of Beyond the Unknown with Toby. The mystery deepens as we continue exploring one of the most disturbing true crime cases ever investigated—the Goose Green stabbing. In this episode, we uncover the elaborate web of deception created by a teenager who built an entire fictional world online using multiple fake identities. What began as innocent online conversations slowly evolved into a chilling psychological manipulation involving a fake romance, an imaginary British intelligence agent, and a dangerous mission that would change two lives forever. As investigators piece together thousands of chat messages, an unsettling question emerges: How far can manipulation go before fantasy becomes reality? Was one teenager completely deceived, or were both boys trapped in a deadly game neither knew how to escape? Join Beyond the Unknown with Toby as we examine the extraordinary evidence, the psychological tactics behind the deception, and the shocking events that led to one of the most unusual criminal cases in modern history. The story is far from over. In Part 3, we leave Goose Green behind and investigate the horrifying Eastburn family murders—a case that stunned investigators, challenged the justice system, and took more than two decades to reveal its final, astonishing twist. 🎙️ Beyond the Unknown with Toby brings you professionally narrated true crime stories, unsolved mysteries, and extraordinary real-life cases that reveal just how strange reality can be.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
28 Jun 2026
The Boy Who Planned His Own Murder | A True Crime Story Beyond Belief
Episode Description Welcome to Episode 1 of Beyond the Unknown with Toby. In this gripping first installment of our four-part true crime series, we explore one of the most bizarre criminal cases ever recorded—the shocking Goose Green stabbing. What initially appeared to be a random knife attack in a quiet English town soon unraveled into an astonishing web of online deception, psychological manipulation, and a friendship unlike any investigators had ever encountered. As detectives dug deeper, they uncovered a disturbing digital world filled with fake identities, fabricated conspiracies, and a plan so unbelievable that it challenged everything they thought they knew about victim and offender. This extraordinary case raises unsettling questions about trust, manipulation, and the hidden dangers that can exist behind a computer screen. Join Beyond the Unknown with Toby as we examine the facts, the investigation, and the chilling twists that turned this case into one of the most unusual true crime stories in modern history. This is only the beginning. Part 2 reveals the fake secret agent, the shocking online conversations, and the unimaginable plan that convinced one teenager to do the unthinkable. 🎙️ New episodes of Beyond the Unknown with Toby uncover the world's most mysterious true crimes, unexplained events, and unbelievable real-life stories.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
26 Jun 2026
The Most Bizarre Criminal Cases Ever Solved | True Crime Stories 🎯 Professional, engaging, and ideal
Episode 4: The Most Bizarre Criminal Cases Ever Solved | True Crime Stories Some criminal cases are so unbelievable that they sound like fiction—but every story in this episode is completely real. In this episode of Beyond the Unknown with Toby, we uncover three of the most bizarre and shocking true crime cases ever investigated. From a teenager who manipulated his own friend into attempting to murder him through an elaborate online deception, to a convicted killer who escaped justice for years before DNA evidence finally exposed the truth, and a seemingly ordinary man whose horrifying double life stunned investigators. These cases reveal the dark side of human psychology, deception, manipulation, and the relentless determination of law enforcement to uncover the truth. Every twist is backed by real events, making these stories as disturbing as they are fascinating. If you're passionate about true crime, unsolved mysteries, and unbelievable real-life investigations, this is an episode you won't want to miss. 🎙️ Beyond the Unknown with Toby brings you compelling true crime stories, mysterious disappearances, and extraordinary cases from around the world. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to follow the podcast, leave a review, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts. Thank you for listening, and always stay tuned for more interesting stories like this.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
24 Jun 2026
The Christmas Murder Checklist: How One Note Exposed a Killer 🔥
Just days before Christmas 2012, 76-year-old Patricia Goodband vanished without a trace. Her longtime friend and business partner claimed he had dropped her off at a train station so she could visit a friend for the holidays. But as detectives began investigating, they discovered a disturbing web of lies, fake text messages, forged evidence, and a carefully constructed alibi.
What started as a missing person case soon became a chilling murder investigation. Hidden beneath acres of countryside, investigators uncovered a dark secret that would expose a killer's deadly plan. The breakthrough came from an unexpected piece of evidence—a handwritten note that detectives later described as a "murder checklist."
In this episode, we examine the shocking disappearance of Patricia Goodband, the painstaking police investigation, and how a killer's own words ultimately led to his downfall.
🔎 A true story of greed, deception, betrayal, and justice.
Watch until the end to discover how one small mistake unraveled a carefully planned murder.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
23 Jun 2026
🚨 She Walked Into His Apartment... Then Vanished Forever | The Kelly Dwyer Mystery
In October 2013, 27-year-old Kelly Dwyer spent an evening with a man she trusted. Security cameras captured her entering his apartment building, smiling and unaware that her life was about to change forever.
But there was one chilling problem.
The cameras never captured her leaving.
As investigators searched for answers, they uncovered disturbing evidence, suspicious behavior, a missing golf travel bag, and a trail of clues that would eventually lead to a shocking courtroom battle years later.
What really happened inside that apartment? How did a vibrant young woman disappear without a trace? And how did investigators finally piece together the truth?
Join us as we explore one of Wisconsin's most haunting true-crime mysteries.
🎙️ Beyond the Unknown with Toby
Stay tuned for more interesting stories like this.
20 Jun 2026
🌲 The Haunted Forest Mystery: The Explorer Who Followed the Footprints and Never Forgot What He Found
Welcome to Episode 2 of Beyond the Unknown with Toby.
Deep within an ancient forest shrouded in fog and fear lies a mystery that has haunted generations. When a curious explorer follows a trail of footprints into the woods, he discovers an abandoned cabin, a forgotten journal, mysterious symbols, and a terrifying presence lurking among the trees.
As darkness falls, strange lights appear, shadowy figures emerge from the fog, and an ancient stone circle reveals secrets long buried by time. But the deeper he ventures into the forest, the more he realizes that some mysteries were never meant to be uncovered.
Join us as we explore one of the most chilling tales ever told and uncover the secrets hidden deep within the Haunted Forest.
Stay tuned for more mysteries, unexplained events, horror stories, and cinematic adventures on Beyond the Unknown with Toby.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
18 Jun 2026
The Maple Creek Mystery: One Morning, One Disappearance, and Years of Unanswered Questions
Welcome to Episode 1 of Beyond the Unknown with Toby.
Today's mystery takes us to the quiet town of Maple Creek, where an ordinary morning became the beginning of a years-long investigation. What started as a missing person report quickly evolved into a complex mystery involving witness statements, forensic evidence, suspicious sightings, and countless unanswered questions.
Join us as we follow the investigation from the first moments of concern through the major breakthroughs, dead ends, and courtroom proceedings that kept an entire community searching for the truth.
If you enjoy mystery stories, unsolved cases, disappearances, investigations, and suspenseful storytelling, this episode is for you.
🎧 Subscribe and follow Beyond the Unknown with Toby for more fascinating mysteries, unexplained events, and captivating stories from around the world.
This episode includes AI-generated content.
Contact Crime Vault International (toby)
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Crime Vault International (toby)?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
