Crosstown Nine Podcast

About Crosstown Nine Podcast

The Crosstown Nine Podcast is the ultimate New York baseball podcast covering everything happening with the New York Yankees and the New York Mets. Hosted by Chris Schnabel, Jhon Guarin, and Dave Puglisi, the show brings together passionate fans from both sides of the city to break down the biggest stories across MLB, Yankees baseball, Mets baseball, and the New York sports scene. With Chris and Jhon representing the Yankees perspective and Dave bringing the Mets fan viewpoint, The Crosstown Nine Podcast delivers balanced discussion, debate, and analysis throughout the entire baseball season. From MLB news, game reactions, player performances, trades, prospects, free agency, and playoff races, this podcast covers it all through the lens of the greatest rivalry in baseball — Yankees vs Mets. Each episode dives into the biggest topics in New York baseball, including: New York Yankees news, analysis, and roster updates New York Mets news, breakdowns, and season outlook MLB trade rumors and free agency Top Yankees and Mets prospects Game recaps and series reactions Subway Series matchups and rivalry moments MLB storylines across the league Whether you're a die-hard Yankees fan, loyal Mets supporter, or just a baseball fan who loves the energy of New York sports, The Crosstown Nine Podcast brings you insightful conversation, passionate debates, and everything happening in the Bronx and Queens. ⚾ Subscribe for weekly episodes covering the New York Yankees, New York Mets, MLB news, and the entire New York baseball season.

Publisher

Schnabel Studios

Category

sports

Language

en

Explicit

No

First episode

25 Mar 2026

Latest episode

1 Oct 2026

Latest episodes

22 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   1 Oct 2026

   Yankees Crush Boston, Move On to the Rays | Wild Card Reaction

   Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) The New York Yankees are moving on to the ALDS after sweeping the Boston Red Sox in the Wild Card Series—and suddenly this Yankees offense looks completely different. Chris Schnabel and Jhon Guarin react immediately after the Yankees eliminate Boston and break down what may be the most encouraging development of the postseason so far: the Yankees aren't relying solely on home runs anymore. New York scored 18 runs in two games, using singles, bunts, sacrifice flies, stolen bases, two-strike hitting and aggressive baserunning alongside the long ball. After years of watching Yankees teams live and die by the home run, Chris and Jhon discuss why this version of the offense may actually be built to survive October. Max Fried followed Cam Schlittler's dominant Game 1 performance with another strong outing, while the Yankees pitching staff allowed Boston to score only two runs across the entire series. New York was so far ahead that Aaron Boone was able to use bullpen arms simply to get them work rather than burning his best relievers in high-leverage situations. Subscribe to Crosstown Nine for Yankees playoff reactions, MLB Postseason coverage, Yankees news, analysis and weekly conversations about everything happening in the Bronx. Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast) TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast) Chapters 00:00 – Yankees Sweep the Red Sox! 00:30 – The Yankees Are Finally Playing Small Ball 02:35 – Max Fried & Yankees Pitching Dominate Boston 02:51 – Another Rough National Broadcast 04:36 – Yankees vs. Rays ALDS Preview 05:59 – Breaking Down the American League Playoff Field 07:00 – Yankees Officially Advance to the ALDS 07:09 – Why the Red Sox Series Was Easier Than Expected 08:16 – Boston's Manager Had a Rough Series 09:09 – Yankees Have to Keep Putting the Ball in Play 10:12 – Rays Preview: What Tampa Bay Does Well 11:55 – Can the Rays Keep Up With the Yankees Offense? 13:39 – Yankees Defense Could Decide the ALDS 14:27 – How Should the Yankees Build Their ALDS Roster? 16:11 – Gerrit Cole in Game 1? 17:06 – Biggest Yankees Surprises From the Wild Card 17:33 – George Lombard Jr. Looks Ready for October 18:04 – The Chris Taylor Award 19:05 – Austin Wells Is Becoming a Postseason Hero 20:41 – Who Needs to Step Up Against Tampa Bay? 21:46 – Yankees Outfield Questions 23:02 – Can Giancarlo Stanton Make an Impact? 24:02 – Yankees-Rays Begins Saturday 24:12 – Yankees Are Moving On to the ALDS

2. 

   30 Sept 2026

   Yankees DOMINATE the Red Sox 9-0 | Wild Card Game 1 Reaction

   Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) The New York Yankees opened the MLB Wild Card Series with a statement, dominating the Boston Red Sox 9-0 in Game 1 behind an incredible performance from Cam Schlittler and a massive night from Ben Rice. Chris Schnabel and Jhon Guarin went live as the final outs were being recorded to give their immediate Yankees vs. Red Sox Game 1 reaction and break down everything that went right for New York. It starts with Cam Schlittler. The Yankees' young ace delivered another dominant postseason performance against Boston, going 6.1 innings with 10 strikeouts, only one walk and two hits allowed. Chris and Jhon discuss Schlittler's development, his Cy Young-caliber season and why he continues to look like the next great homegrown Yankees starting pitcher. Then there's Ben Rice, who delivered one of the biggest swings of the night with a grand slam that put the game completely out of reach. Rice finished with two home runs as the Yankees' young core took center stage in Game 1. Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) Follow Crosstown Nine: Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast) TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast) Chapters 00:00 – Yankees vs. Red Sox Game 1 Instant Reaction 01:17 – Cam Schlittler Dominates Boston 03:24 – Schlittler's Cy Young Season & Yankees Young Core 03:56 – Ben Rice's HUGE Night & Grand Slam 04:05 – Homegrown Yankees Take Over Game 1 04:48 – Yankees Game 1 Positives & Lineup Breakdown 07:10 – Yankees Bullpen Strategy After the Blowout 09:04 – How New York Should Handle Game 2 10:38 – What Happens If Gerrit Cole Starts Game 3? 11:37 – Breaking Down the National Playoff Broadcast 15:53 – What Went Wrong With the Broadcast 19:35 – Red Sox Lineup & Roman Anthony Injury 20:01 – How Weak Is the American League? 22:08 – Yankees Playoff Outlook & Potential Matchups 24:02 – Looking Around the Rest of the MLB Playoffs 27:47 – Is the MLB Wild Card Format Working? 30:11 – Yankees Game 2 & Potential Rays Series 30:36 – Final Thoughts: Yankees Win 9-0

3. 

   14 Sept 2026

   Can This Team Actually Win in October?

   Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) The New York Yankees postseason push is officially here, but despite sitting 20 games over .500, this team somehow doesn't feel like a team that's 20 games over .500. In this episode of Crosstown Nine, Chris Schnabel and Jhon Guarin break down the state of the Yankees as the MLB Playoffs approach and ask the biggest question facing New York: Can this Yankees roster actually win a World Series? The Yankees have continued to win series, but their losses have exposed the same problems that have haunted the organization for years. The starting pitching can dominate while the offense disappears. The bats can finally come alive only for the bullpen to struggle. And with October approaching, Chris and Jhon debate whether this team is built to avoid another postseason defined by great pitching and an offense that can't deliver when it matters most. Do you trust this Yankees team in October? Let us know in the comments. Subscribe to Crosstown Nine for Yankees news, Yankees analysis, MLB Playoff coverage, baseball debates and weekly conversations about everything happening in the Bronx and around Major League Baseball. Join the Discord: https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb (https://discord.com/invite/dYhnmwQANb) Follow Crosstown Nine: Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.instagram.com/crosstownninepodcast) TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast (http://www.tiktok.com/crosstownninepodcast) Chapters 00:07 – Yankees Postseason Push Begins 00:52 – How Do We Feel About the Yankees Right Now? 02:01 – Can the Yankees Actually Win the World Series? 03:02 – Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton & the Postseason Offense 03:40 – The Bottom of the Yankees Lineup Is a Problem 04:19 – Spencer Jones vs. Trent Grisham 05:12 – Breaking Down the Yankees Offensive Numbers 06:00 – The Yankees Can't Hit for Average 07:30 – MLB's Home Run Obsession & Yankees Hitting Philosophy 08:01 – Ryan McMahon's Struggles Since the Trade Deadline 11:31 – Anthony Volpe's Triple-A Performance & Potential Return 14:30 – Yankees vs. Rays: Can New York Still Win the AL East? 15:25 – When Should Aaron Judge Return? 16:24 – Breaking Down the Yankees Remaining Schedule 16:56 – Why the Rays Series Could Decide the Season 18:32 – Colorado, Mets & the Yankees Upcoming Opponents 20:50 – Orioles, Rays & the American League Playoff Race 22:02 – The Yankees HAVE to Capitalize on a Weak American League 23:41 – MLB Lockout & Salary Cap Discussion 26:11 – Why MLB Needs a Salary Floor 27:41 – MLB Prospects, Team Control & Why the Draft Is Different 30:41 – The Yankees Don't Know How to Develop Players 31:41 – Who Can You Actually Trust in the Yankees Lineup? 33:03 – Why the Yankees Feel Like a .500 Team 35:03 – Final Thoughts & The Postseason Push Continues

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

Apple Podcasts (US)

5.0 / 5

1 ratings

Contact Crosstown Nine Podcast

Guest appearances

Does not typically book guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.