A podcast about all of those cult documentaries you love to binge watch. We are two religious studies professors that are curious about our current cult documentary streaming era. What stories do these shows tell and what do they tell us about ourselves?
Hosted by Merinda Simmons and Mike Altman
Can there be a cult without a camera pointed at it? Mike and Merinda have asked this question a lot and it is central to this week's documentary. The Cult of the Soulful Journey tells the story of a new age group based in Minnetonka, Minnesota organized around new age teacher and channeler Soulaire Allerai. The documentary depicts Soulaire as a controlling and charismatic "cult leader." But why? Along the way we hear from former members Rik and Bil, who found themselves in the group while helping Soulaire produce a video game. We also hear the story of Rachel Raines who joined as a psychic medium along with her son David. Along with this cast of characters, the documentary gives the audience all the usual cult tropes from brainwashing to interesting beliefs to communal living and weird sex stuff.
Follow us on the socials at @cultfavoritepod.
Special thanks to the REL Digital Lab in the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Alabama for production assistance.
The views expressed in this episode are our own as experts and researchers in religious studies and do not represent the University of Alabama.
Theme music produced with Udio.
24 Sept 2026
Bring Me the Beauties (HBOMax, 2026)
Merinda and Mike dive into the documentary chronicling Eternal Values, the New York new age group built around self-styled guru Frederick von Mierers — and the model, Hoyt Richards, who spent years inside it. It starts on a Nantucket beach in 1978, with talk of alien walk-ins, past lives on the star Arcturus, and a coming tribulation only Frederick's followers are prepared for. It ends with a mercy killing, a mutiny, and a group scattered in the late '90s.
Along the way: a modeling career that seems to prove Frederick's teachings are working, a compound in Lake Lure, NC built to house alien spacecraft, an "antichrist" scandal, a Richard Bey talk show appearance gone sideways, and a Vanity Fair exposé that blew the whole thing open.
Merinda and Mike break down whether this one hits all the "cult doc" genre's usual beats (charismatic leader, mind control, communal living, aliens, guns, deprogramming) and ask a bigger question: how many more stories like this one are still waiting to be told?
Plus, this week's Cult Favorites: Merinda recommends The Waterless Sea: A Curious History of Mirages by Christopher Pinney and Mike makes the case for Love Is Blind UK Season 3.
Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @cultfavoritepod, and be sure to subscribe and leave a rating and review.
Special thanks to the REL Digital Lab in the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Alabama for production assistance and our production intern Sierra Ruden.
The views expressed in this episode are our own as experts and researchers in religious studies and do not represent the University of Alabama.
Theme music produced with Udio.
9 Sept 2026
Trust Me: The False Prophet (Netflix, 2026) 🚨RELAUNCH WEEK!🚨
It's relaunch week here at Cult Favorite! You might notice some changes and some new things as we roll into the fall. So keep checking in!
On this episode we discuss the summer's biggest "cult documentary," Trust Me: The False Prophet from Netflix. This story of an abusive FLDS leader who emerges in the wake of Warren Jeff's incarceration and the woman who gains his trust in order to bring him down raises a lot of important questions. Why is the word "cult" used so little in this documentary compared to others? What does it mean when someone says they are "called" to something? What is the role of trust in this story?
Join us as Merinda and Mike try to answer some of those questions and ask a lot more.
Follow us on the socials at @cultfavoritepod.
Special thanks to the REL Digital Lab in the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Alabama for production assistance.
The views expressed in this episode are our own as experts and researchers in religious studies and do not represent the University of Alabama.
Theme music produced with Udio. Special thanks to Julianne Losacco for help with our logo.
Our production intern is Sierra Ruden
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
7,327
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Apple Podcasts (US)
4.9 / 5
18 ratings
Spotify
4.8 / 5
21 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 65 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
82
Social presence
0
YouTube
68
Engagement
51
Contact Cult Favorite
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Cult Favorite?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
