Every episode, two Andys revisit a classic football match, watch it in full and then get together for a good old natter!
Discussing the games of yesteryear like they were yesterday.
From World Cup classics and title deciders to forgotten thrillers, we relive footballs greatest moments with fresh eyes and modern analysis.
Part post match reaction, part historical deep dive into the best matches you ever saw (and some you didn't) and part pub chat, Do They Think it's All over? explores how the game has changed, what still holds up and why some matches are immortal.
A huge 135,000 people cram into Hampden Park as Real Madrid face Eintracht Frankfurt in the 1960 European Cup final. This week on They Think It’s All Over?, the two Andys ask: is this the greatest European club side of all time?
Who were Di Stéfano and Puskás? How did they play for so many different countries —and just how good were they really? We explore the clash of tactical styles and look at the foundations of that famous Real Madrid DNA.
With superstar signings and managerial changes already part of the story, were the seeds of the Galácticos planted from the very beginning?
30 Sept 2026
Tottenham Hotspur vs Atheltico Madrid 1963
What happens when you watch one of football’s great teams more than 60 years later?
Two Andys revisit classic matches from football history – watching the full game and discovering what still surprises us today.
This time, we’re heading to Rotterdam in 1963, where Bill Nicholson’s brilliant Tottenham side face holders Atlético Madrid in the European Cup Winners’ Cup Final, looking to become the first British club to win a European trophy.
We watch a 37-year-old Danny Blanchflower command the game, Jimmy Greaves at his devastating best and the remarkable movement of a Spurs attack that looks startlingly modern. There’s brutal tackling, an awful pitch, a dramatic Atlético fightback, an extraordinary goalkeeping error – and an unlikely hero in Terry Dyson.
Was this the last great performance of Nicholson’s greatest Spurs side? And just how good were they?
17 Sept 2026
England v Brazil 1956
England v Brazil, 1956: Duncan Edwards and a Glimpse of What Might Have Been
Wembley, May 1956. England face Brazil in a remarkable match featuring some of the greatest names of the era — Stanley Matthews, Roger Byrne, Tommy Taylor and, at the heart of it all, the extraordinary Duncan Edwards.
Two years before Munich, and two years before Brazil would become world champions, this is a fascinating snapshot of two footballing nations on the brink of change.
We revisit a match of missed penalties, controversial decisions and six goals, while exploring the players behind it: the brilliance of Matthews, the leadership of Byrne, the goals of Taylor — and the immense talent of Edwards, whose story remains one of English football’s greatest “what ifs?”
2 Sept 2026
Liverpool vs Newcastle 95/96
Was this the greatest football game ever?
We’re heading back to Anfield, 1996, for one of the most extraordinary nights in Premier League history: Liverpool 4–3 Newcastle.
Seven goals. Two title-chasing teams. Kevin Keegan’s entertainers. Robbie Fowler at his outrageous best. Stan Collymore’s last-gasp winner. And, of course, that image of Keegan slumped over the advertising hoardings.
But this episode goes beyond the football.
We explore Robbie Fowler’s alter ego, pay tribute to the brilliant and complicated legacy of Kevin Keegan, and ask the big question: can football ever be this good again?
And then it’s time for The 90s Premier League Draft — Andy vs Andy, picking our ultimate Premier League team of the 1990s.
Nostalgia and outrageous football galore.
19 Aug 2026
Leicester City vs Arsenal 97/98
We're heading back to 97/98 for another Premier League Legends rewatch - and this time we've headed to Filbert Street, where Leicester City welcomed Arsenal.
But really this episode belongs to one man: Dennis Bergkamp. The non-flying Dutchman. And, quite possibly the greatest game of his career.
Bergkamp produces one of the most outrageous hat-tricks in Premier League history - three incredible goals, two of which are masterpieces.
We revisit the match and talk about what made Bergkamp so extraordinary. And take time to give Heskey, O'Neill and Cottee the praise they deserve.
5 Aug 2026
Liverpool vs Blackburn 94/95
The house that Jack built.
The final day of the 94/95 season. The title is in Blackburns hands as Kenny Dalglish returns to Anfield.
The greatest day of Alan Shearer’s career?
How good was the premier leagues all time rob goal scorer?
Episode 2 of our 90s Premier League Legends series
22 Jul 2026
Man City vs Man Utd 93/94
The start of our Premier League Legends episodes as we go "Looking for Eric"
It's the second Premier League season - United have crashed out of The Champions League in midweek and now they have to visit their noisy neighbours.
Will it be Ce magnifique.. ou catastrophique?
8 Jul 2026
Brazil v Italy 1970
The Greatest team of all time? Brazil take on Italy in the Azteca.
Pele's final World Cup match brings our World Cup episodes to a close.
And what a match it was - though something strange is going on with the free kicks!
24 Jun 2026
England v Argentina 1998
France 98 - it's all Nike Adverts and Cool Britannia.
Another contest between England and Argentina - but now there is no Maradonna and we are witnessing the start of The Golden Generation.
Was it as good as we remembered?
And who are we blaming now we watch it with modern eyes, Seaman, Beckham, Hoddle?.... Scholes?!!!
10 Jun 2026
Brazil v Sweden 1958
The first televised World Cup Final.
The game that turned Pele into an icon but how good was football in the 1950s? What were the tactics and how does it compare to other World Cup Finals?
Was football in the 50s as different to today as we think?
9 Jun 2026
Argentina v England 1986
Travel back to Mexico 86.
Have you ever seen 90 minutes of Maradonna? The Andys watch the legend in his most famous match but the game throws up some over talking points - why was Robson in charge having not qualified for Euro 84? Whats going on with Englands midfield? - is Hoddle taking free kicks with both feet and why Argentina were actually a two man team?!
Contact Do they think it's all over?
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Do they think it's all over??
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
