27 Jul 2026
Don't Know Why The Media Loved Hitler
Last episode, we looked at how much of the Western media practically rolled out the red carpet for Benito Mussolini. This week, we move on to Adolf Hitler, and somehow, the reporting gets even stranger.
Unlike Mussolini, Hitler wasn't treated like a visionary. He was treated like a joke. Major American newspapers described him as a loudmouth, a political clown, and a man whose moustache and mannerisms "suggest Charlie Chaplin." Journalists mocked his appearance, dismissed his supporters as gullible, and confidently predicted that once he entered government, the responsibilities of leadership would force him to become more moderate. The problem? Hitler himself had been very clear about what he wanted to do all along. People just refused to believe him.
In this episode, we explore how the American and British press covered Hitler's rise to power, why so many influential publications underestimated him, and how the pursuit of "balanced" reporting often became an excuse to sanitise authoritarianism. We revisit Dorothy Thompson's famous interview with Hitler, examine The New York Times' attempts to present the "good" alongside the horrifying, and discuss why "both-sides journalism" can become dangerously misleading when one side is openly dismantling democracy.
As always, this episode combines comedy commentary, offbeat learning, and quirky insights into one of those seemingly random topics that turns out to be alarmingly relevant today. It's lighthearted education about journalism, propaganda, political bias, and why dictators rarely succeed by hiding who they are. More often than not, they tell you exactly who they are. The real question is whether anyone chooses to listen.
Important links:
1. How Journalists Covered the Rise of Mussolini and Hitler - https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-journalists-covered-rise-mussolini-hitler-180961407/
2. American Journalist Dorothy Thompson Underestimates Hitler - https://historynet.com/encounter-dorothy-thompson-underestimates-hitler/?f
3. Unrecognized Potential: Media Framing of Hitler's Rise to Power, 1930-1933 - http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1363/unrecognized-potential-media-framing-of-hitlers-rise-to-power-1930-1933
4. Prewar Nazi Germany and the Beginnings of the Holocaust - https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/timeline-group/holocaust/1933-1938
5. HITLER SEEKS JOBS FOR ALL GERMANS - https://www.nytimes.com/1933/07/10/archives/hitler-seeks-jobs-for-all-germans-does-anything-else-matter-he-asks.html?utm_source=perplexity
6. HERR HITLER AT HOME IN THE CLOUDS - https://www.nytimes.com/1939/08/20/archives/herr-hitler-at-home-in-the-clouds-high-up-on-his-favorite-mountain.html
7. A political history of the Daily Mail - https://theweek.com/88935/a-political-history-of-the-daily-mail?utm_source=perplexity
8. The British Press and Nazi Germany: Reporting from the Reich, 1933–39 - https://dokumen.pub/the-british-press-and-nazi-germany-reporting-from-the-reich-19339-9781350102095-9781350102125-9781350102101.html
9. Printing the Truth - https://www.digitalexhibitions.manchester.ac.uk/s/manchester-guardian/page/printing-the-truth
10. Recommendation of the week - https://youtu.be/uomLlydZpNU?si=VQxgv7HVeOsI0x1L
Don't Know, Do Care is the brainchild of Ashmita, Sandy, and Prakhar, three friends from different backgrounds and interests. Ashmita works in sustainability, Sandy's an entrepreneur (puke) who'd rather not be, and Prakhar works with Sandy and is just trying to make sense of it all.
Three mildly confused friends, one weirdly specific topic each week. We don't know much, but we care just enough to talk about it for up to an hour each week.
Don't Know, Do Care is produced by "Ghar Pe Productions", edited by Prakhar and Sandy, critiqued (thoroughly) by Ashmita, and enjoyed mostly by our friends. Thanks for giving us a listen!