Welcome to "Horror First-Timers," the chilling podcast where every scream, every gasp, and every heart-pounding moment is fresh and unfiltered. Join us as we delve into the dark depths of the horror genre with guests who are stepping into the shadows for the very first time.
Here, fear takes center stage as we explore the eerie corridors of classic horrors, unearth hidden gems, and brave the latest bone-chilling releases. Our guests, unsuspecting souls, watch these spine-tingling tales for the first time, and their raw, immediate reactions become our guide.
Join us on this macabre journey, where the thrill of the unknown meets the joy of discovering horror's most horrifying treasures. Dare to tune in but be warned: Once you step into the realm of "Horror First-Timers," there's no turning back.
Send us a text The wait is over! Back in January, Maddie and I sat down to watch Wolf Man (2025) for the very first time, and now we're sharing our unfiltered thoughts. Did this modern take on the classic monster live up to the hype? Was the horror, gore, and transformation everything we hoped for? And how does it compare to other werewolf movies? Join us as we break it all down our favorite moments, the biggest surprises, and whether Wolf Man earns its place in horror history. Watch now, an...
11 Oct 2024
Mother! w/ Bailey Sullivan
Send us a textIn this intense sixth episode of "Horror First-Timers," I'm joined by one of my best friends, Bailey Sullivan from Careful Gaze, as we dive headfirst into Darren Aronofsky’s psychological thriller mother! This controversial film takes us on a wild ride through symbolism, chaos, and jaw-dropping moments—and it’s Bailey’s first time experiencing it all!From the film’s unsettling tension to its shocking twists, we dissect what makes mother! such a polarizing and unforgettable piece...
19 Aug 2024
Bad Moon w/ Maddie Franz
Send us a Text Message.DISCLAIMER: My hard drive did not like me when I went to finally finish editing this video so for the most part this is just an audio friendly podcast with little to no video content.Welcome back to "Horror First-Timers"! In this thrilling fifth episode, Maddie Franz and I sink our teeth into the 90s werewolf classic, Bad Moon. Join us as Maddie experiences this cult horror film for the very first time, taking in all the fur-raising scares and campy 90s vibes.Bad Moon b...
3 Jun 2024
The Descent w/ Elliot Vickers
Welcome to another gripping episode of "Horror First-Timers"! In our fourth episode, we dive deep into the claustrophobic and terrifying world of "The Descent" (2005). Join us as our guest experiences the spine-chilling journey of six women who venture into an uncharted cave system, only to encounter unimaginable horrors lurking in the dark.
Witness our guest's first-time reactions to the intense claustrophobia, relentless tension, and horrifying creatures that make "The Descent" a modern horror classic. We'll explore the film's masterful use of confined spaces, its impact on the characters' relationships, and the psychological terror that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.
Tune in as we dissect each scare, relive the heart-pounding moments, and discuss the film's themes of survival and inner demons. Don't forget to subscribe to "Horror First-Timers" for more thrilling episodes, and join us as we journey into the depths of horror, one film at a time.
Catch new episodes of the podcast anywhere you listen to them!
Horror First-Timers is hosted by Nate Martin (Tugboat)
Follow Tugboat's Salon of Stuff for movie reviews and exploiting all things physical media from his personal collection.
Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers
Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS
#horrormoviepodcast #firsttimewatching #thedescent #neilmarshall #horror
Support the Show. (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2353100/support)
21 May 2024
The Ritual w/ Maddie Franz
Welcome back to "Horror First-Timers"! In this spine-chilling third episode, we venture into the eerie forests of Sweden as our guest watches "The Ritual" for the first time. Join us as we unravel the mystery and dread of this modern horror gem, directed by David Bruckner.
As our familiar guest experiences the unsettling journey of four friends facing an ancient evil, their raw reactions guide us through the film's psychological horror and supernatural elements. From the atmospheric tension to the disturbing creature design, "The Ritual" offers a unique blend of fear and folklore.
Tune in as we dissect the film's themes of guilt, friendship, and survival, and uncover the secrets hidden within the dark woods. Don't forget to subscribe to "Horror First-Timers" for more thrilling episodes, and join us on our quest to explore the most terrifying tales the horror genre has to offer, one film at a time.
Catch new episodes of the podcast anywhere you listen to them!
Horror First-Timers is hosted by Nate Martin (Tugboat)
Follow Tugboat's Salon of Stuff for movie reviews and exploiting all things physical media from his personal collection.
Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers
Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS
#firsttimewatching (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/firsttimewatching) #filmtok (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/filmtok) #podcast (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/podcast) #horrormoviepodcast (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/horrormoviepodcast) #moviereview (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/moviereview) #movie (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/movie) #netflix (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/netflix) #davidbruckner (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/davidbruckner) #theritual (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/theritual) #horror (https://www.youtube.com/hashtag/horror)
Support the Show. (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2353100/support)
6 May 2024
The Lighthouse w/ Eli Canfield
In the sequel episode of "Horror First-Timers," we set sail into uncharted waters as our guest experiences the haunting and surreal world of "The Lighthouse" for the very first time. Join us as we dive deep into the psychological horror and gripping performances that have made this film a modern classic.
As the eerie tale unfolds on a remote New England island in the 1890s, our guest this week, Eli Canfield gives us raw reactions that guide us through the isolation, madness, and supernatural elements that define this mesmerizing film. From the stark black-and-white cinematography to the gripping narrative, "The Lighthouse" is a cinematic journey unlike any other.
Join us as we dissect each frame, relive each chilling moment, and uncover the hidden depths of this dark and atmospheric masterpiece. Subscribe to "Horror First-Timers" for more spine-tingling episodes and join us as we explore the darkest corners of the horror genre, one film at a time.
Catch new episodes of the podcast anywhere you listen to them!
Horror First-Timers is hosted by Nate Martin (Tugboat)
Follow Tugboat's Salon of Stuff for movie reviews and exploiting all things physical media from his personal collection.
Horror First-Timers:
Podcast: www.buzzsprout.com/2353100
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers
Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS
#horrormoviepodcast #firsttimewatching #moviereview #roberteggers #thelighthouse #a24 #horror
Support the Show. (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2353100/support)
15 Apr 2024
Hereditary w/ Maddie Franz
In the premiere episode of "Horror First-Timers," join us as my fiancé, Maddie Franz, experiences the bone-chilling horror of "Hereditary" for the very first time! Watch as she delves into the world of Ari Aster, navigating through grief, loss, and sinister forces that will leave you on the edge of your seat.
As we dissect each scare, relive each terror, and uncover the secrets that haunt this modern horror masterpiece, Maddie's raw and immediate reactions become our guide, but will "Hereditary" leave a lasting impact on both Maddie and all of us watching?
Don't miss this gripping episode where fear takes center stage and the joy of discovering horror's most horrifying treasures is embraced. Subscribe to "Horror First-Timers" for more chilling episodes and join us as we journey into the darkness of the horror genre, one film at a time.
Catch new episodes of the podcast anywhere you listen to them!
Horror First-Timers is hosted by Nate Martin (Tugboat)
Follow Tugboat's Salon of Stuff for movie reviews and exploiting all things physical media from his personal collection.
Horror First-Timers:
Instagram: @horrorfirsttimers
Tugboat's Salon of Stuff:
Instagram: @tugboats_sos
Letterboxd: Tugboats_SOS
Support the Show. (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2353100/support)
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
1,384
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Spotify
5.0 / 5
4 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 27 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
14
Social presence
0
YouTube
68
Engagement
32
Contact Horror First-Timers
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Horror First-Timers?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
