Remember sitting around a campfire with your best friend, holding a flashlight under your chin, trading the wildest, creepiest stories you’ve ever heard? Or texting your friend “OMG, I’ve got something to tell you” and getting back “TELL ME EVERYTHINGGGG”—this podcast is THAT.
Tell US something! Send your stories to igsttystories@gmail.com
The Haunted Archives | Episode 37: Live From Jarrod's: The Amityville Horror
We're digging into The Haunted Archives and bringing back a few of our favorite episodes for spooky season!
First up is Episode 37, recorded LIVE from Jarrod's Coffee, Tea & Gallery for our very first live show back in 2025!
For our first time in front of a live audience, we took on one of the most infamous haunted house stories of all time: The Amityville Horror. From the real-life tragedy that started it all to the paranormal claims that turned a Long Island home into a horror legend, we covered the story that has fascinated (and terrified) people for decades.
Whether you missed it the first time or want to revisit it with us, enjoy this throwback from The Haunted Archives!
25 Sept 2026
Episode 77 | LIVE FROM MESA'S HAUNTED MUSEUM | "Serving T's"
We’re serving T’s this week — Triangles and Tillie. 🔺🔮
Episode 77 was recorded LIVE from Mesa’s Haunted Museum with our friends at East Valley Paranormal!
Tayler kicks us off with the Bridgewater Triangle, an area of Massachusetts packed with ghosts, UFOs, cryptids, strange sightings, disappearances, and enough paranormal WTFery to earn itself a triangle.
Then Colleen brings us Tillie Klimek, the Chicago woman who had an interesting habit of predicting when the men in her life were going to die… only for those predictions to keep coming true. Psychic? Premonitions? Or was Tillie making sure her predictions were always right?
Triangles. Tillie. We’re Serving T’s. ☕️👻
A HUGE thank you to Michelle, Heather, and East Valley Paranormal for inviting us into the museum and making this show happen, and to everyone who came out and spent the night with us!
2 Sept 2026
Episode 76: The Return of Beavis and Butthead
It’s a true crime takeover this week! Tayler and Colleen are both here, but we’re sticking with one story as Colleen closes out the case of Leopold and Loeb.
In Part 2, we’re deep diving into the trial that became a national spectacle, Clarence Darrow’s legendary defense, the media frenzy surrounding the “crime of the century,” and what ultimately happened to Leopold and Loeb. We’re also getting into the massive cultural impact of the case and just how deeply it worked its way into pop culture — from books and plays to movies, television, and beyond.
We covered the crime in Part 1. This week, we’re getting into everything that came after.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
11 ratings
Spotify
4.7 / 5
12 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 43 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
65
Social presence
0
YouTube
0
Engagement
51
Host of I've Got Something To Tell You?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
