Welcome to the It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast with hosts Matt Capps and Josh Reavis, where you’ll hear unforgettable, awkward, and hilarious stories that could truly only happen to a pastor. Think mic mishaps, baptism bloopers, and kids saying the worst possible thing mid-sermon. So, if you need a laugh or just a little encouragement along the way from pastors just like you, listen in today!
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a countdown of their Top 5 “Pastor Hacks.”
6 Apr 2026
I'll Get Saved This Week If You'll Get Saved Next Week
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments.
30 Mar 2026
Are Those Seats Taken?
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments.
23 Mar 2026
Being a Good Neighbor Goes a Long Way
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of hilariously chaotic ministry moments.
16 Mar 2026
I Had a Whole Year of Training
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share a couple of painfully funny ministry moments.
9 Mar 2026
Interpretive Dance Ninja Turtle Style
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share two painfully relatable church moments—from a worship service that suddenly paused while everyone wondered, “Has anyone seen Bob?” to Josh’s awkward realization that he introduced himself to someone who had already been attending the church for months.
2 Mar 2026
You Should Not be Faint of Heart or Slow of Reflex
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps share two unforgettable ministry moments—one involving a frantic pastoral check-in and another featuring a hot mic.
23 Feb 2026
The Hospital is Where You Get Trained for the Ministry
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps swap stories that prove ministry is often holier—and messier—than anyone expects.
16 Feb 2026
I'm Drawing the Line at Fingernails
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Josh Reavis and Matt Capps share a cringe-worthy early-ministry moment.
16 Feb 2026
Let Nature Take Its Course
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share an unforgettable preaching experience in a passionate church.
9 Feb 2026
The Double Whammy
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis share another round of unforgettable ministry moments, plenty of laughs, and a reminder that you never know what might happen next.
9 Feb 2026
A Sea of Elvii
In this episode of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor, Matt Capps and Josh Reavis swap unbelievable (but totally real) ministry stories.
8 Jan 2026
Trailer
Welcome to the It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast with hosts Matt Capps and Josh Reavis, where you’ll hear unforgettable, awkward, and hilarious stories that could truly only happen to a pastor. Think mic mishaps, baptism bloopers, and kids saying the worst possible thing mid-sermon. So, if you need a laugh or just a little encouragement along the way from pastors just like you, listen in today!
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
21 ratings
Host of It Could Only Happen to a Pastor Podcast?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
