It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

About It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

Welcome to "It Wasn't Me: A True Crime Podcast" where your hosts Cindy and Mercedes will dive head first into the gruesome and grizzly details of obscure and even well-known murders. So, put your kids away and join us for a murder. Oh, and don't forget to subscribe! See ya soon.

Publisher

Cindy and Mercedes

Category

true crime

Language

en

Explicit

Yes

First episode

11 Oct 2019

Latest episode

17 Apr 2026

Latest episodes

4 of 108 episodes have a transcript.

1. 

   17 Apr 2026TRANSCRIPT

   The Houston Hills (part 1) - EP102

   This episode explores the intriguing and dark story of Joan Robinson Hill, her marriage to John Hill, and the mysterious circumstances surrounding her death. We delve into the family dynamics, the high-stakes world of Houston's elite, and the shocking autopsy revelations that led to a murder investigation.

2. 

   27 Mar 2026TRANSCRIPT

   Competency vs. Insanity Explained - EP101

   This episode clarifies the complex legal concepts of competency and insanity in criminal law, explaining how they differ, their historical origins, and their implications in court cases. Perfect for anyone interested in understanding mental health's role in the justice system. This episode explores the complexities of the insanity defense in criminal law, including legal standards, mental health diagnoses, and how courts evaluate mental illness in criminal cases. Experts discuss real cases, myths, and the impact of weaponizing mental health in the justice system.

3. 

   13 Mar 2026

   Belle Gunness: The Belle of Hell - EP100

   In this episode, the hosts celebrate their 100th episode by delving into the chilling story of Belle Gunness, one of America's first female serial killers. They explore her early life, marriages, and the mysterious deaths surrounding her, including her children and suitors. The investigation into her crimes reveals a pattern of deceit, insurance fraud, and murder, captivating the public's attention and leaving a lasting legacy in true crime history. This conversation delves into the chilling story of Belle Gunness, a notorious female serial killer from La Porte, Indiana. The hosts explore the mysterious circumstances surrounding her life, the murders she committed, and the theories about her possible escape after a fire that supposedly claimed her life. They discuss the evidence, the involvement of local authorities, and the legacy of her crimes, which continue to fascinate and horrify to this day.

Inside a recent episode

The Houston Hills (part 1) - EP102

Published 17 Apr 2026 · Transcript excerpt

[…] After honeymooning on the Gulf Coast, the couple moved into the upstairs wing of the Robinson Mansion, where they lived on Daddy's dime for the next six years of their marriage. They had a cook, a housekeeper, all to themselves on their own wing, and they did not have to worry about household chores. she traveled a lot with her horse shows. And then John was home, busy studying and interning. But during the party season, they partied. John was home. They went out every night. John was living the dream. In the daytime, he was pursuing his medical degree. And at night, he was living a life of luxury on the party scene on someone else's tab. […]

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

Apple Podcasts (US)

4.1 / 5

66 ratings

Contact It Wasn’t Me: A True Crime Podcast

Guest appearances

Does not typically book guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.