Love is messy. Dating is chaotic. And sometimes, it’s not you... it’s definitely them. Or is it? Join sibling duo Vanessa and Matthew Castillo (11 years apart but equally chaotic) as they dive into the wild world of relationships, fireside chat style. From ghosting and cringe-worthy situationships to long-term love and red flags we all ignore. Expect real talk, unfiltered laughs, and hard truths. Whether you’re single, cuffed, or somewhere in between, you’ll leave every episode feeling a little less alone, and a lot more entertained. Come for the laughs, stay for the relatable chaos. ♥️ 💔
They keep saying there are plenty of fish in the sea… okay, but WHERE THEY AT THO? 🎣😭
This episode, we’re trying to make sense of yet another mystery of modern dating: why start a conversation, show interest, exchange numbers, talk for days… and then suddenly disappear? Like, what was the assignment here? 😂
We get into whether dating apps are actually helping people find love or if they’ve basically become a marketplace for hookups, situationships, and pen pals who never intend on meeting.
We also talk about something that would solve approximately 87% of dating problems: SAY WHAT YOU ACTUALLY WANT.
Want something casual? Cool. Say that.
Looking for a relationship? Say that.
Not feeling it anymore? SAY THAT TOO.
Instead, everybody’s scared of looking too interested, coming on too strong, getting rejected, or making the first move—so we overthink ourselves into doing absolutely nothing.
There’s a difference between being confident and being creepy. You can shoot your shot without launching the whole damn basketball court. 😂
Maybe the fish aren’t actually missing. Maybe everybody’s just swimming around waiting for somebody else to make the first move.
🎙️ Plenty of Fish in the Sea… But Where They At Tho?
3 Sept 2026
Play to Win: Dating, Self-Love & Finding Your Person
You gotta play to win. 🎙️❤️
This week, we’re joined by Natasha for a conversation that keeps coming back to one thing: the relationship you have with yourself.
Because before you can figure out who you want to date, what you want from a relationship, or whether someone is actually right for you… you probably need to know yourself first.
We get into why knowing and loving yourself can keep you from settling, why sometimes the best relationships start as friendships, and what it really means to find someone who fits into the life you already love.
We talk about ignoring colored flags 🚩, the idea that “there’s somebody for everybody,” why dating is a little bit like playing to win, and whether relationships are really 50/50—or whether both people need to show up with 100% to make something work.
It's another one of those conversations that goes everywhere, gets real, gets funny, and leaves us asking the bigger question:
Are you actually ready for the kind of love you're looking for?
Because maybe it's not about finding the one.
Maybe it's about becoming the version of yourself who knows exactly what—and who—is for you. ❤️
2 Aug 2026
WTF is Modern Dating?
WTF Is Modern Dating? 🤦♂️💘
Seriously... what is going on out here?
In this episode, we're unpacking the chaos that is modern dating. From ghosting and mixed signals to situationships, dating apps, "soft launching," breadcrumbing, and all the unspoken rules nobody asked for, we're trying to make sense of a dating world that somehow gets more confusing every year.
We share our own experiences, laugh at the absurdity of it all, debate whether today's dating culture is helping or hurting us, and ask the question everyone seems to be thinking:
Has dating always been this crazy... or are we just living through the weirdest era of love?
Whether you're single, dating, happily taken, or somewhere in the "it's complicated" category, this one's for you.
Real conversations. Real opinions. Plenty of laughs.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Spotify
5.0 / 5
2 ratings
Contact It's Not Me, It's You
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of It's Not Me, It's You?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
