Paranormal encounters. True crime. Weird science. And all the things that make you stop and think… what was that?
Join Stathi each episode as he dives down the rabbit hole of hauntings, unexplained mysteries, bizarre crimes and strange science — separating fact from fiction, exploring the theories, and trying to work out what actually happened.
Some stories have a perfectly reasonable explanation. Others… not so much.
But don’t worry.
It’s probably nothing.
The Hinterkaifeck Murders: Who Killed Six People on an Isolated Farm? | It's Probably Nothing EP. 5
Six people were brutally murdered on an isolated German farm in 1922. But what happened before and after their deaths is just as disturbing.
Days before the murders, the family reportedly discovered mysterious footprints leading towards their farmhouse — but none leading away.
Then came reports of footsteps in the attic, a missing house key, and strange activity around the property.
On March 31st, 1922, all six residents of Hinterkaifeck were murdered, including two young children and a maid who had only arrived that day.
Their bodies weren't discovered for another four days.
And during that time, someone may have continued looking after the farm animals.
In Episode 5 of It's Probably Nothing, we investigate the Hinterkaifeck murders, the disturbing events leading up to the killings, the main suspects, and the theories surrounding one of Germany's most infamous unsolved crimes.
Was the killer hiding on the farm before the murders? And did they stay there afterwards?
🎙️ Listen now and decide for yourself.
Yeah… it's probably nothing.
28 Oct 2026
The Black-Eyed Children: What Happens If You Let Them Inside? | It's Probably Nothing EP. 4
Imagine waking up in the middle of the night to someone knocking on your front door.
Standing outside are two children.
They seem normal enough… until they look up.
Their eyes are completely black. 👁️
No whites. No colour. Just darkness.
And they want you to let them inside.
In Episode 4 of It's Probably Nothing, Stathi explores the terrifying urban legend of the Black-Eyed Children.
From journalist Brian Bethel's chilling alleged encounter in Texas to the countless stories that followed, we investigate where this mysterious legend originated and what might explain it.
Are these children demons, supernatural entities, or simply one of the internet's most disturbing urban legends?
And why do they always seem to need permission to enter?
One knock. Two children. One terrifying question.
Would you open the door?
Yeah… it's probably nothing. 👀
21 Oct 2026
The Wendigo: Is the Monster Real or Just a Legend? | It's Probably Nothing EP. 3
Deep in the frozen forests of North America, Indigenous stories tell of something terrifying.
A creature consumed by an endless hunger. A being that can never be satisfied. And in some traditions, a monster that was once human.
But what if the Wendigo is more than just a frightening legend?
In Episode 3 of It's Probably Nothing, Stathi explores the chilling folklore of the Wendigo, its origins in Indigenous North American traditions, the disturbing real-life case of Swift Runner, and the controversial psychological condition once known as Wendigo psychosis.
Could extreme hunger really turn someone into a monster? Are modern sightings evidence of something supernatural? Or is the Wendigo a powerful warning about the darkest side of human nature?
One legend. An insatiable hunger. A terrifying question.
Yeah… it's probably nothing.
14 Oct 2026
The Dyatlov Pass Incident: What Killed 9 Hikers? | It's Probably Nothing EP. 2
In February 1959, nine experienced hikers ventured into the Ural Mountains of Soviet Russia. None of them would return alive.
When rescuers discovered their campsite, their tent had been cut open from the inside, their belongings were left behind, and their bodies were scattered across the frozen wilderness.
Some were found barely dressed in temperatures well below freezing. Others suffered devastating injuries.
What could have frightened nine experienced hikers enough to abandon their only shelter?
An avalanche? A military experiment? Something far more sinister?
In Episode 2 of It's Probably Nothing, Stathi investigates the disturbing Dyatlov Pass Incident, the evidence left behind, and the theories surrounding one of history's most chilling mysteries.
Nine hikers. One frozen mountain. No survivors.
Yeah… it's probably nothing. 🏔️
7 Oct 2026
The Enfield Poltergeist: Was It All a Hoax? | EP. 1
In 1977, a family in Enfield, London claimed something terrifying was happening inside their home.
Furniture moved on its own. Objects flew across rooms. Strange knocking echoed through the house. And eventually, an 11-year-old girl began speaking in the voice of a man who claimed he had died there.
But with admitted hoaxes, sceptical investigators and conflicting accounts, was the Enfield Poltergeist really paranormal — or was everyone being fooled?
In the first episode of It’s Probably Nothing, we look at the evidence, the recordings and the theories before giving Enfield its place on the Probably Nothing Scale.
Because surely there’s a reasonable explanation.
Probably.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Spotify
5.0 / 5
3 ratings
Contact It's Probably Nothing
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of It's Probably Nothing?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
