Searching for truth in the paranormal & otherworldly realms? Love a podcast with a unique blend of skepticism & intuition? Join host Colleen as she shares her own behind-the-scenes experiences from her investigations & chilling personal encounters ~blending humor, intrigue, & thought-provoking discussions, to her audience. Often including listener-submitted stories & interviews of special guests! Each episode delves into strange phenomena, from urban legends to cryptid sightings, with a mixture of history, storytelling & analysis. Get ready to question reality & explore the unexplained! Whether you're a believer or a curious skeptic, this podcast offers a fresh, perspective on the world of the unexplained! Don't miss out - HIT that subscribe button & tune in for laughter, chills, & a community of like-minded enthusiasts!
Find me:
https://www.instagram.com/women_of_unearthly?igsh=b2ZzbGh3bHBuZjZk&utm_source=qr (https://www.instagram.com/women_of_unearthly?igsh=b2ZzbGh3bHBuZjZk&utm_source=qr)
#ItsUNEARTHLY
#WomenofUnearthly
#PodcastCommunity
#OtherworldlyEncounters
Join me in episode as I go over the History of St. Valentine & everything I can find on the Interwebs! I'll go over what I know vs what I find{& pronounce the best of what I can} I know. Please be kind at least I tried! LOLS! Email: itsunearthlypodcast@gmail.com Call or text at: 407.216.4343 Send a text
27 Nov 2025
Episode 17 Thanksgiving & The Ghost of Plymouth Rock
Hosts discuss the Mayflower's voyage in 1620, the Pilgrims and Strangers seeking freedom, and their initial interactions with the Wampanoag people during the history of Thanksgiving.
31 Oct 2025
Episode 16 Spook Hill
Sara and the host explore the strange history and possible explanations behind Spook Hill, a Florida site where cars appear to roll uphill, leaving listeners to decide if it's an illusion or something supernatural.
9 Sept 2025
Episode 15 OUR 1 YEAR RECAP!
Host Sara and her co-host reflect on a year of paranormal investigations and insightful interviews, sharing favorite moments and behind-the-scenes stories.
15 Jun 2025
EPISODE 14 Hans Holzer the Father of Paranormal
Sara and an unnamed co-host explore the life and work of Hans Holzer, the "Father of Paranormal," who investigated haunted locations and authored over 120 books.
6 Jun 2025
EPISODE 13 Are Cops Psychic? Our Interview with a Private Investigator & Spiritual Talk
Undercover Investigator reveals her experiences navigating danger and deception, while Sara and host discuss her deep spiritual awareness and psychic sensitivity in an interview.
11 May 2025
Episode 11 Ma Barker & Who Was She Really?
She was called the criminal mastermind of the 30's -a woman who raised her sons not to follow the law, but to break it. Ma Barker the matriarch of the infamous Barker-Karpis Gang, has gone down in history as the mother of all mobsters. However was she really the brains behind a deadly string of bank robberies, kidnappings, & murders? How much of her legend is fact, & how much was the FBI myth-making? In this episode we unravel one of the most controversial figures in American criminal...
3 May 2025
Introducing: Our Ghost Story Time Unearthly Whispers From Beyond
This is our less then a minute Introduction to our Ghost Story Time from our listeners. If you or someone you know has a ghost story or experienced something paranormal send it to us at: itsunearthlypodcast@gmail.com or if you would like to speak to us call us at: 407-216-4343 Send us a text
12 Apr 2025
Episode 11 Pet Cemetery Investigation at The Garden of Love & our pets
In a quiet corner of Florida lies a cemetery not meant for people, but for our most loyal companions. Rows of tiny headstones with pictures & names of pets buried with love. Where chew toys rest beside faded flowers. A peaceful resting grounds for pets who were more like family because they were. Garden of Love whispers this. It breathed & remembered. As the sun dipped behind the tall trees, Sara & I felt the shift. In a place meant for love & remembrance, we found shado...
4 Apr 2025
Episode 10 Part 3 St. Augustine's Lighthouse Interview with Lighthouse Manager Sammy
In this episode of It's UNEARTHLY Podcast Sara & I sit down with one of the managers from St. Augustine's Lighthouse for an exclusive interview. Where we talk of some history, ghosts, & her own paranormal experiences while working there. Not only does she oversee the preservation of this iconic landmark she also leads ghost tours where she shares the eerie, spine-chilling ghost stories from the Lighthouse's haunted past plus the mysteries that still linger today. Whether you are a ske...
2 Apr 2025
Episode 9 Part 2 St. Augustine Lighthouse Our Timeline
In this episode of Part 2 of St. Augustine Lighthouse Sara & I break it down to the KNOWN facts after finding our research & discussing our timeline. From it's early days as a watchtower for sailors navigating the dangerous waters off the Florida coast to it's role in guiding ships safely through the years. We delve deep into the historical events, tragedies, & mysteries surrounding the lighthouse, Whether you're a history buff, a fan of maritime legends, or just curious about St....
16 Mar 2025
Episode 8 St. Patrick & our interviews at the Celtic Music Festival of encounters of Leprechaun, Fairy, or Fae
Sara & I go over our timeline of St. Patrick & why we celebrate St. Patrick's Day on this day. Then we take to the streets of St. Augustine, Florida & attended their Celtic Music Festival with mic in hand we ask about individuals of their own encounters of Leprechauns, Fairy, or Fae. This was something very out of our norm for us & was quite the experience for all of us! Send us a text
16 Feb 2025
Episode 7 Our Investigation with Distorted Realities at the Suwannee Springs/Graffiti Bridge{The Bridge to Nowhere}
Join Sara & I as we sit down with JRock, Frank Walls, & Mr. Valentine ~the guys from Distorted Realities & chat about our own experiences that we encountered on this investigation. We joined up at the Graffiti Bridge over the Suwannee River & instantly felt the energy shift. A step back in time. Was someone trying to tell JRock something dreadful while Frank felt the heaviness on the bridge? Explored the Springs ~which is also known as The old "Seminole Bath Houses" where each...
8 Jan 2025
BONUS EPISODE: Mysterious Drones & an Anonymous Caller
Sara & I needed to do this episode!!! Just a little "Bonus Episode" on these "drones" & I guess we got a little political{not much}how can you not when your own government doesn't address the visitation of these MYSTERIOUS DRONES! We reached out for our own facts. Do our own investigating. Watched numerous videos & clip after clip reached out to certain people on the internet where I found our Anonymous Interviewer who claims she{& her daughter}communicated with these "drones"...
2 Dec 2024
Episode 5 Our investigation of St. Augustine Lighthouse Part 1
Sara & I got to do the after hours Investigation of the St. Augustine Lighthouse Dark of the Moon Tour offered by the Lighthouse. It was amazing there. Join Sara & I in this Part 1 series as we discuss our findings & experiences. From strange noises, strange occurences & EVPs{Electronic Voice Phenomenon}we attempted to communicate with the spirits with our own equipment. Plus bringing you our own footage unedited! Let us know what you think & stay tuned for more on the Lig...
16 Oct 2024
Episode 4 Interview with Psychic Medium Sandra Ruggles & Cassadaga Spiritualist Camp Part 2
In this episode Sara & I go over the 2nd 1/2 of Cassadaga, Florida Spiritualist Camp & talk about our own experiences. We also got the pleasure to sit down & interview Psychic Medium, Astrologer, & Author Ms. Sandra Ruggles! What an amazing woman. What an amazing time & experience this was for us. From readings, EVPs, & pictures of orbs galore this place is definitely a place to visit again & again! Please give a listen & leave us a comment, let us know what yo...
1 Sept 2024
Episode 3 Cassadaga Spiritualists Camp Part 1
Join us on our 3rd Episode{Part 1}while we talk of Cassadaga & about the co-founder George P. Colby. Plus a little of our own experiences while visiting Cassadaga The Spiritualists Camp. Stay tuned for Part 2! Send us a text
1 Aug 2024
EPISODE 2 Our Investigation of Scott Springs Park
Welcome to our 2nd Episode where Sara & I discuss our findings on our investigation at Scott Springs Park in Ocala, Florida. Sit back & take a listen. Let us know what you think. Is this hidden spring hiding ancient secrets? Does the playground at night still linger of past children still playing? What is peeking in the woods slowly? Go check it out for yourself & find your own experiences. Contact us at itsunearthlypodcast@gmail.com & we so thank you for listening! Send us a...
14 Jul 2024
EPISODE 1 INTRO
INTRO to us! Send us a text
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
2,692
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 30 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
34
Social presence
0
YouTube
68
Engagement
0
Host of itsunearthlypodcast's Podcast?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
