What happens when one person loves true crime and the other one doesn’t? A podcast, of course. Join them each week as real life couple Charlie and Sarah discuss serial killer after serial killer, all to Charlie’s dismay. He hates this stuff.
The chilling, final deep digging into the life of Thomas Donald Bruce McArthur... a name almost as long as his killing spree. Charlie isn't really into this Santa's slaying, but most of it takes place in a van down by the river, so he's torn. Will the Canadian police arrest Saint McArthur? Will the little old lady do her own gardening? Are Canadian serial killer at least polite about it? Find out all this, and all that stuff from the first part, and still more yet on the conclusion of Bruce McArthur: Naughty (not nice!).
27 Jan 2023
Stay Out of the Naughty House - Part 1
Thomas Donald Bruce McArthur…. And that’s only one person. This is the long tale matching a long name of a killer with a jolly red hat and dirty green thumb. Charlie is none too pleased by what Sarah describes. Why do Santa’s break bad? Why is landscaping so hard? Are all the best killers Canadian? Find out all this and more as Sarah and Charlie return to the airwaves with new equipment and a new crime spree. Happy Belated Holidays!!
2 Oct 2022
Que Surratt Surratt - Edward Surratt
Well, they're back, just in time to get ready for Spooky Season. Sarah brings up the disturbed and chilling material on Edward Surratt, an American murderer, rapist and suspected serial killer. That's tough for Charlie, since he hates all three of those. The tale winds them through Ohio, South Carolina, and some familiar old haunts in Pennsylvania. Buckle up, because this road trip is making no bathroom stops.
Like/rate/review/subscribe and suggest a topic at killerpillowtalk@gmail.com.
Facebook: www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk
21 Jul 2022
Monsieur Garçon - Thierry Paulin
Hey, right off the bat, sorry about the audio issues. They don’t run through the whole thing, only about half, and we are working on getting better recording equipment. :) Bear with us!
In this one, a tired Charlie and Sarah discuss a truly gruesome French spree killer named Thierry Paulin. He robbed, he killed, and he had a help from another Thierry! This one got old quick because Thierry only kills older women. Charlie is not a fan, not just because he loves old women, but also because murder makes him squirm. Plus, to make things even worse, they very nearly spoil the dark comedy movie Heathers (1989) (40:05 - 41:55). Skip ahead if that's your thing.
Write/share/review/rate/subscribe/listen! Also, suggest us new killers!
Email: killerpillowtalk@gmail.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk
2 Jun 2022
The Angel of Death - Nursachusetts
They just couldn't let Memorial Day pass by without stopping to reflect... on one of the most deadly nurses to ever grace the New England area. Kristen Gilbert was not a good woman, and she targeted patients in Veteran's Hospital, a real scumbagess. Charlie hated it. There's romance, poison, murder, and a lifetime(s) behind bars in this tale of what happens when a good nurse.. well, she was always a bad nurse... when a bad nurse stays bad. Come for the serial killer in a hospital, stay for the Glenn Martin, DDS reference.
Like/subscribe/rate/review/comment/recommend to everyone!
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk
Email KillerPillowTalk@gmail.com for suggestions and more info.
Happy Memorial Day!
30 Apr 2022
Sunday, Bloody “Easter” Sunday; Rabbit Hatchet
Happy Easter! This one should come with a trigger warning, in more ways than one. Charlie hears the story of a one James Ruppert. He's famous in Ohio because that's where this gruesome tale happened. A quiet Easter gathering gets way more out of hand than your drunk uncle bringing up conspiracy theories. Sarah tells the whole "tail." There's some levity when they discuss the Bunnyman as a bonus. Harvey, is that you? Have a listen to lucky episode 13; don't forget your rabbit's foot.
Like/rate/review/subscribe. Email killerpillowtalk@gmail.com. Follow them on Facebook at - https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk.
25 Mar 2022
Riffin' on Rifkin: Part 2 - Speeding the 5th
Charlie is so scared still/again that he contemplates changing the podcast's name. Sarah shuts that down but continues the gruesome tale of Long Island native Joel Rifkin, a notorious serial killer of prostitutes in the early 90s. Buckle up, cause the murders and Rifkin come pretty fast in this one, and that might be triple entendre. Give it a listen/like/rate/review/subscribe/share. Tell your friends and building doormen!
19 Feb 2022
Riffin’ on Rifkin: Part 1 - Frenzy Fanatic
Well, they’re back! It’s time for personal stuff and Part 1 of the story of Joel the Ripper A.K.A Mr. Rifkin, if you’re nasty. And he’s pretty nasty, which does not please Charlie. This one has him cowering under the covers. Sarah did enough research to shoot a short documentary, so it’ll be coming at you in two parts; a background and a killing spree, and then hopefully, a capture. Like/listen/rate/review/subscribe! Tell your friends and baristas!
3 Jan 2022
Is That You, Santa Claus?
Twas' the night before Christmas... actually a week and 2 days after, but nevermind that. Sarah is back to tell scary ghost stories and tales of the glories of Christmases long, long ago... well, more specifically, the 1970's. It's the Santa Claus Strangler, and no, we're not referring to Scott Calvin. No visions of sugar plums can save Charlie from certain un-comfortability. Adolph Laudenberg wasn't the holly, jolly type. Find out just how naughty he's been. Spoiler alert: He's getting coal for Christmas. Like/rate/review/subscribe!
Follow us here: https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk (https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk)
Email us here: killerpillowtalk@gmail.com
30 Nov 2021
Only Murders in the Boarding House
Thanksgiving already? Charlie and Sarah take a break from stuffing themselves with... stuffing... and shine a light on Dorothea Puente, a woman who's boarding house business is very lively... or should we say... deadly? Charlie doesn't want to know where the bodies are buried, but that doesn't stop Sarah from telling him in excruciating detail. This is one of the reasons why Charlie would never survive in boarding house. Tune in to find out the may others. Like, rate, review, subscribe, enjoy!
31 Oct 2021
The Sacramento Vampire Diaries
Sarah and Charlie make their triumphant return on Halloween, although Charlie hoped these cases would just stay dead! To him, true crime = rude time. But alas, he was outvoted by the only other person in the room, so here they are. They discuss the chilling story of Richard Chase, a man so horrifying that it takes them both a bit by surprise. Oh, and it was the perfect night to be telling scary tales, what with the rain and all. Mwah, ha ha ha.... Give it a like, a listen, and a subscribe... at your own risk! Happy Halloween!
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/killerpillowtalk
Email: KillerPillowTalk@gmail.com
6 Apr 2021
Kibbe & Bits
Sarah takes us on a metaphorical drive down the I5 Strangler’s scenic route of murders, but Charlie keeps begging to pull over. Join them as backseat drivers and buckle up! Use Anchor to publish your podcast for free and hassle free today!
27 Dec 2020
Killing Them Kindly: Part 2 - Cranleigh Gardens
Charlie and Sarah are back to finally finish the story of Dennis Nilsen, a man who Charlie does not like. This time, we catch up with him on the last leg of his killing journey, in Cranleigh Gardens, UK.
22 Jul 2020
Killing Them Kindly: Part 1 - Rating Nilsen
Sarah and Charlie, who’s hiding under the covers, are back to discuss Dennis Nilsen’s reign of terror in London, England. That’s so like a Scot; kill all the British people.
15 Jun 2020
Enjoy Your Stay at the Murder Castle: Night 2
Sarah and Charlie return to finish the grizzly tale of just what H. H. Holmes was up to. Spoiler alert: nothing good. And rosebud, but that’s an unrelated spoiler, more for Citizen Kane. Charlie is itching to check out of the murder castle, of course.
17 May 2020
Enjoy Your Stay at the Murder Castle: Night 1
Sarah is back, with a truly chilling tale about H. H. Holmes and his murder castle. That freaks Charlie the f&$@ out. It’s part one of their exploration and stay in some truly scary material. Check in if you dare!!
1 May 2020
Mischief, Murder, Soap
Here we find Sarah and Charlie in the middle of quarantine 2020, with nothing better to do than wash their damn hands. Enter: Italian soap! It’s the Soap-maker of Correggio. Charlie is none too pleased.
5 Apr 2020
Skipper Gets the Boot - The Barbie and Ken Killers
What happens when one person likes true crime and the other person doesn’t? Charlie and Sarah gather to discuss the first of many, many murders perpetrated by different serial killers. The problem: Charlie hates this stuff. Listen as they navigate the True Crime waters. Did we mention Charlie hates this stuff?
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
4 ratings
Contact Killer Pillow Talk
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Killer Pillow Talk?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
