'Knife in the Dark,' where Justin and Joey slice into the horror genre with the precision of a killer's blade. Each episode, we dive into the gory, the scary, and the downright bizarre, covering everything from classic slashers to the latest in horror cinema. Expect unfiltered, adult-themed discussions, peppered with laughs, swears, and insights that only true horror fans can appreciate. Whether it's dissecting iconic films, exploring horror tropes, or sharing our own spooky experiences, we're here to entertain and enlighten. https://horrorfacts.com
Jay recounts a lifetime of paranormal experiences, including encounters with a railroad worker's ghost and potential familial spirits, while Joey interviews Jay about relentless hauntings and a possible curse.
16 Jun 2025
When the Dead Don't Want Company
Joey investigates a haunted hotel room, debunking staged scares before encountering real terror, while the podcast shares a listener's chilling experience with a spectral woman.
8 Jun 2025
Peggy The Doll
Hosts Justin and Joey investigate Peggy, the infamous haunted doll from Baggins Haunted Museum, uncovering terrifying truths and chilling encounters in this paranormal exploration.
25 May 2025
FINAL DESTINATION: BLOODLINES
Hosts Justin and Joey dissect the creative carnage of "Final Destination: Bloodlines," exploring if this sequel honors the franchise's legacy or succumbs to gory ambition in this episode.
9 May 2025
Monkey See, Monkey Regret
🔪 Knife in the Dark | 🐒 Regrettably Watch The Monkey – Leaving us to wonder why the hell people are still making Stephen King-inspired movies. 😩
In this episode, Joey, Murph, and guest Aaron attempt to sift through the monkey shit 💩 and struggle to figure out the plot of this film—is it a story about family 👨👩👧👦, revenge 🔥, a slapstick comedy 🤡, or did director Osgood Perkins make another movie about his daddy issues?
The only thing we know for certain is we made Murph rent this movie for $20 💸—and that’s about the funniest thing about this movie that fails at being a horror-comedy in every sense of the word. 😒
So, get ready to watch people explode 💥, a monkey bang on the drum all day 🥁🐒, and a bunch of other useless crap they had to throw into this film just to stretch a 34-page story into a full-length snoozefest. A film that Stephen King himself endorsed—because that guy will put his name on everything. 📛
#KnifeInTheDark #TheMonkey #StephenKing #HorrorMovieFail #PodcastLife #BadMovies #WhyDidWeWatchThis #RIPMurphs20Bucks #MonkeyBusiness 🎬🔥
https://horrorfacts.com - https://knifeinthedark.com
6 May 2025
Five Nights of Suck
🎬 Knife in the Dark | FNAF Movie Roast: Joey, Bobby & Horror Geek Dungeon Rip Apart Five Nights at Freddy’s 🔪🤖
THEY WENT IN EXPECTING HORROR… THEY LEFT WITH RAGE.
This week, Joey and Bobby team up with special guest Horror Geek Dungeon to eviscerate the Five Nights at Freddy’s movie—a film so bafflingly bad, it made them question if the animatronics were the only soulless things on screen.
🔥 The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly: Okay, mostly just The Bad & The Ugly. They break down the film’s catastrophic pacing, wasted lore, and jump scares that couldn’t frighten a toddler.
🔥 "This Script Was Written by a Haunted Word Randomizer": The gang roasts the nonsensical plot twists, cringe dialogue, and that bizarre third act.
🔥 Horror Geek Dungeon Drops the Hammer: As a diehard FNAF fan, their disappointment is palpable—prepare for rants about wasted potential and studio cowardice.
🔥 Joey’s Unhinged Theory: What if this movie was actually a secret experiment in audience suffering?
🔥 Bobby’s Final Verdict: "This isn’t a horror movie… it’s a corporate tax write-off."
What They WISHED the Movie Did (Spoiler: Literally anything else.)
The One Redeeming Scene (And why it wasn’t enough.)
Would They Survive Five Nights? (Joey: "I’d let Freddy kill me to escape this film.")
🎧 Listen If You Can Stomach the Cringe.
#FNAFMovie #FiveNightsAtFreddys #HorrorMovieRoast #BadHorror #KnifeInTheDark #PodcastHateWatch #BlumhouseBlunder #WastedPotential #AnimatronicNightmare #WorstAdaptation #HorrorGeekDungeon #RageReview #SoBadItsSad #KillTheCameraMan 🎥🔪
16 Apr 2025
Knife X Knife
🔥 Knife in the Dark | SPECIAL EPISODE: Justin Interviews Sammy (of Knife in the Dark) – Descending into the Sonic Abyss 🖤
This isn’t just an interview—it’s a ritual. In this very special episode of Knife in the Dark, host Justin sits down with Sammy, the enigmatic force behind the band Knife in the Dark, whose music is as haunting as the podcast’s namesake. Together, they carve open the raw, emotional underbelly of the band’s sound—a swirling abyss of despair, rage, and eerie beauty.
Sammy pulls back the curtain on the band’s creative hellscape, from lyrical obsessions with the void to the recording process that feels more like an exorcism. Plus, they reveal an exclusive collaboration between the podcast and the band—a fusion of audio horror and sonic devastation that will bind them together forever.
Expect uncensored confessions, existential dread, and the kind of stories that cling to your bones long after the music stops. This is more than an episode—it’s a covenant.
⚡ Listen… if you dare.
#KnifeInTheDark #BandInterview #DarkMusic #PostPunk #DoomGaze #HorrorPodcast #MusicAndMadness #SonicVoid #NewEpisode #Collaboration #DespairCore #NoEscape #SoundtrackToTheAbyss 🎤🔪
https://horrorfacts.com - https://knifeinthedark.com
7 Apr 2025
The Substance
🔪 Knife in the Dark | The Substance: Body Horror, Beauty, & the Monstrous Feminine 🩸
This week, we dissect The Substance—Coralie Fargeat’s vicious new body horror masterpiece starring Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley. Equal parts grotesque, satirical, and deeply unsettling, the film claws at Hollywood’s obsession with youth, the cost of "perfection," and the terrifying lengths one woman goes to reclaim her identity.
We’ll break down its jaw-dropping practical effects, feminist rage, and how it stacks up against classics like The Fly and Possession. Love it or hate it, this movie will leave a mark.
⚠️ Content Warning: Spoilers + discussions of graphic body horror, violence, and mature themes. Not for the squeamish!
🎧 Listen now wherever you get your podcasts.
#TheSubstance #BodyHorror #HorrorPodcast #KnifeInTheDark #DemiMoore #MargaretQualley #CoralieFargeat #FilmAnalysis #HorrorMovies #FeministHorror #HollywoodSatire #PodcastersOfInstagram #SeeItWithTheLightsOn 🔪🎥
https://horrorfacts.com https://knifeinthedark.com
24 Mar 2025
Enter Longlegs
Host Justin and co-host Joey sink their blades into Longlegs, the 2024 horror gem where the devil pulls strings and birthdays bleed red.
Joined by horror maestros Murphy Lawless and Nightmare Nerd, they dissect Dale Cobble’s descent—from a glam-rock ghost with fuzzy amps and feather boas to a Satanic puppet smashing his skull in front of Agent Lee Harker.
Ninth birthdays turn to slaughter, dolls rattle with infernal orbs, and a nursery rhyme hums through the carnage.
Recorded live on March 2, 2025, this deep dive is raw, dark, and unhinged—probing the devil’s shadow in every frame and the panic that birthed it.
For fans of the sinister, it’s a twisted treat. Don’t hum that tune alone—the devil’s got ears.
https://horrorfacts.com (https://horrorfacts.com)
#HorrorPodcast #LonglegsMovie #SatanicPanic #GlamRockHorror #OccultVibes #NightmareFuel #HorrorFacts #HorrorFacts
10 Mar 2025
It's Alive! Frankenhooker
Get ready to dig up a cult classic! We're exhuming another cinematic oddity: the 1990 sexploitation sensation, Frankenhooker.Join Joey and Murph as they dissect the film's outrageously sexy plot and the surprisingly dark motivations of its protagonist.
Just how far will he go for love? We also dive into a truly bizarre theory: did director Frank Henenlotter predict the future?
We explore the eerie parallels between the film's Jeffrey and notorious serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer.Is Frankenhooker a hilariously twisted take on the Frankenstein myth, or a strangely prescient commentary on the serial killer obsession of the era?
Tune in to find out!
https://horrorfacts.com (https://horrorfacts.com) - https://knifeinthedark.com (https://knifeinthedark.com)
#Frankenhooker #CultClassic #90sMovies #HorrorComedy #Sexploitation #SerialKillers #MoviePodcast #FrankHenenlotter #CultFilm
24 Feb 2025
Heart Eyes - Roses Are Red, Knives Are Blue
Does "Heart Eyes" deliver a fresh and terrifying take on the Valentine's Day slasher, or does it fall flat, leaving us with a bloody mess?
Justin, Joey, Astrid, and Bobby explore the film's attempt to blend romantic tropes with brutal kills, analyzing its plot, characters, and mind-blowing twists. Was the "Heart Eyes" killer a memorable villain, or just another masked menace?
We unpack the themes of obsession, vulnerability, and the dark side of romance. Tune in to hear our candid verdict and join the conversation!
https://horrorfacts.com (https://horrorfacts.com) -- https://knifeinthedark.com (https://knifeinthedark.com)
#HeartEyesMovie #HorrorPodcast #SlasherFilm #MovieDiscussion #PodcastLife #HorrorFans #FilmAnalysis #ValentineThriller #ScaryMovies #HorrorReview
18 Feb 2025
Scream 5 Surprise
Join us on Knife in the Dark for what was supposed to be a deep dive into the original Scream 1996 movie, but turns out to be something unexpectedly twisted.
With hosts Justin and Joey, horror expert Bobby, and guest Alvin, we embark on a journey into the Scream franchise that's full of laughs, scares, and meta-commentary.
Alvin brings a fresh perspective, but it's not quite what you'd expect from a first-time viewer. We discuss the iconic opening scenes, the playful subversion of horror tropes, the memorable characters, and the lasting impact of Scream on the genre.
But are we talking about the Scream you think we are? There's a twist here, and it's as surprising as any Ghostface reveal. Tune in to catch all the laughs, the debates, and the moment where Joey tries to keep us on track, only to realize we might be discussing a different Scream than intended.
Like, subscribe, and share your own Scream memories or theories in the comments, and don't forget to visit horrorfacts.com (horrorfacts.com) and knifeinthedark.com (knifeinthedark.com) for more horror insights.
#Scream #HorrorMovies #HorrorPodcast #SlasherFilms #MetaHorror #HorrorTropes #Ghostface #HorrorLegacy #ScreamTwist
2 Feb 2025
Knife in the Dark Episode 03 - SICK (2022)
Join Justin and Joey as they lock down with the 2022 slasher 'Sick,' where quarantine becomes the ultimate horror setting.
In this episode, we dive deep into the movie's twists, turns, and how it turns the concept of safety at home into a nightmare.
We're dissecting the kills, the chills, and everything we missed the first time around.
Like, subscribe, and visit horrorfacts.com (https://horrorfacts.com) and knifeinthedark.com for more horror goodness. Don't miss out on this bloody good discussion!
30 Dec 2024
Knife in the Dark Episode 02 - Street Trash
Join us as we talk about the new Street Trash 2024 remake!
30 Dec 2024
Knife in the Dark Episode 01
Episode 01.
15 Dec 2024
Amityville
The DeFeo Family murders remain one of the most infamous crimes in American history—not just for their brutality, but for what followed.
This episode unpacks the chilling events that took place on that November night in 1974, when Ronald “Butch” DeFeo Jr. took the lives of his entire family as they slept.
These murders would later become the dark foundation of the Amityville haunting legend, but what really happened inside that house on Ocean Avenue?
The facts of the crime are disturbing enough, but the aftermath is just as haunting. From shifting alibis to bizarre claims of demonic influence, this episode digs into the tangled web of lies and contradictions spun by Butch DeFeo in his desperate attempts to escape responsibility.
It’s a story of violence, deception, and the lingering question: was there something more sinister at play, or was it all just a human monster in the dark?
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Spotify
4.0 / 5
8 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 23 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
33
Social presence
0
YouTube
0
Engagement
31
Host of Knife in the Dark?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
