Little House, Big Opinions

About Little House, Big Opinions

Welcome to Little House, Big Opinions — a cozy-chaotic rewatch podcast for emotionally complicated people 😌 Join two former Little House kids as we revisit Little House on the Prairie through the lens of nostalgia, homeschool living room memories, religious culture, deconstruction, prairie chaos, and way too many modern opinions. Think cozy emotional damage, whimsical Americana chaos, and Anthropologie energy dropped into Walnut Grove. We’re here to overanalyze bonnets, frontier trauma, Charles Ingalls’ financial decisions, and the emotional impact of “comfort TV.”

Publisher

Amanda and Riley

Category

tv & film

Language

en

Explicit

Yes

First episode

13 May 2026

Latest episode

2 Jul 2026

Latest episodes

11 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   2 Jul 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E11- Trauma Scale- Rabid Raccoon

   In this episode of Little House, Big Opinions — the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast for people unpacking their childhood in real time — Riley and Amanda revisit "The Raccoon," an episode that somehow turns an adorable baby raccoon into one of the most emotionally devastating episodes of Season 1. After Mary accidentally destroys Laura's beloved doll, she brings home an orphaned baby raccoon to cheer her up. Laura instantly falls in love with Jasper, teaches him tricks, sneaks him into school, and becomes Walnut Grove's first unofficial raccoon mom. Unfortunately... Jasper is still a raccoon. This week on the podcast: Charles Ingalls attempts porcelain doll reconstruction, Caroline quietly enables Laura's questionable wildlife decisions, Jack gets completely replaced as Laura's favorite animal, and everyone repeatedly ignores the very obvious warning signs that wild animals belong in the wild. Then a second raccoon enters the picture, one bite changes everything, and suddenly the entire Ingalls family is convinced Laura is going to die from rabies. Riley and Amanda also dive into the real science behind rabies, why the disease was so terrifying before vaccines existed, what rabies actually looks like in humans, and why watching Jack for symptoms somehow became the entire treatment plan. They also swap their own dog bite stories, discuss childhood stuffed animal trauma, debate whether Charles was right to take Jasper away, and question why absolutely no one thought to simply keep the dog away from the raccoon. The emotional damage doesn't stop there. Charles nearly shoots Jack. Laura spends most of the episode believing she might die. Mary has one of Melissa Sue Anderson's strongest acting performances yet. And Michael Landon somehow manages to squeeze an extended shirtless suspense sequence into an episode about rabies. Trauma Meter: 8/10 — Animal peril, childhood illness fears, crying children, and enough emotional manipulation to qualify as psychological warfare. Survivability Rating: 6/10 — Everyone lives, but your nervous system definitely takes a beating. Charles Shirtless Count: 1 — Extended shirtless barn sequence. Somehow both fan service and a horror movie. Big Opinion: Maybe... just maybe... don't let your child keep a wild raccoon as a pet and then allow it to interact with the family dog. Little House, Big Opinions is a Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast hosted by two former church kids processing their childhood in real time. Every week, Riley and Amanda revisit another episode of the beloved series, breaking down the nostalgia, history, trauma, humor, and completely unhinged moments that somehow made it into family television. New episodes every week wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @littlehousebigopinions.

2. 

   1 Jul 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch SPECIAL- Which Came First, Tradwife or the Prairie?

   Yesteryear Deep Dive + Little House Reboot Predictions (Special Episode) | Little House, Big Opinions Podcast In this special episode of Little House, Big Opinions — the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast for people unpacking their childhood in real time — Riley and Amanda take a break from their Season 1 rewatch to discuss one of the year's most talked-about literary fiction releases: Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke. Spoiler warning: We discuss the entire novel, including the ending, major twists, and character arcs. Yesteryear follows Natalie, a wildly successful trad-wife influencer who suddenly wakes up believing she's living as a pioneer woman in 1855. As reality begins unraveling, the novel explores social media, evangelical culture, motherhood, mental illness, performative perfection, and the unsettling gap between the life we sell online and the one we're actually living. This week on the podcast: Riley and Amanda unpack why Natalie is one of the most fascinating unlikeable protagonists they've read in years, debate whether she's a victim, a villain, or both, discuss religious trauma, influencer culture, parasocial relationships, and why the book's biggest twist completely caught them off guard. They also compare Yesteryear to Little House on the Prairie, examining how both stories romanticize prairie life while revealing the realities beneath the nostalgia. Then things take a turn. The girls imagine what every major Little House on the Prairie character would be doing if they lived in 2026. Charles Ingalls accidentally ends up with an OnlyFans. Caroline becomes either the world's most wholesome teacher or a trad-wife influencer who actually tells the truth. Laura grows up to be a romance author, nature activist, or horse therapist. Mary launches an unbearably judgmental trad-wife course. Nellie Oleson reinvents herself as either a Manhattan socialite or a surprisingly lovable beige mom. Miss Beadle quietly works from home doing the absolute bare minimum. Finally, Riley and Amanda dive into their hopes (and concerns) for the upcoming Little House on the Prairie reboot. Will it stay family-friendly? Will side characters finally get full story arcs? Why is Carrie missing? How closely will it follow the books? And why they think people calling the reboot "too woke" may have forgotten that the original series was already pushing social boundaries decades ago. Book Discussion Topics: Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke Trad-wife influencers and social media culture Religious trauma and evangelicalism Mental illness and unreliable narrators Prairie life vs. the fantasy of simple living Character analysis and literary themes Little House Discussion Topics: Modern careers for Charles, Caroline, Laura, Mary, Nellie, and Miss Beadle Predictions for the new Little House on the Prairie adaptation Why the original series was more progressive than many people remember What we're most excited (and nervous) to see in the reboot Little House, Big Opinions is a Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast hosted by two former church kids processing their childhood in real time. Each week, Riley and Amanda revisit the beloved series one episode at a time, unpacking the nostalgia, trauma, history, humor, and wildly unhinged moments they somehow missed as kids. New episodes every week wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow along on Instagram and TikTok @littlehousebigopinions.

3. 

   17 Jun 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E10- Abel to Learn

   In this episode of the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast, Riley and Amanda are back in Walnut Grove for Season 1, Episode 9 — School Mom — and it might just be the most chaotic substitute teacher situation in prairie history. Miss Beadle is conveniently off her feet, which means Carolyn steps up to take over the classroom. Harriet Olson also attempts to step up — emphasis on attempts, because the kids find out and simply do not show up. Willie Olson's explanation? "That's the trouble." We are not taking further questions. This week: Carolyn writes "understanding and compassion" on the board and delivers the most devastating burn in Walnut Grove history directed squarely at Mrs. Olson. Abel — a student who looks suspiciously like a 22-year-old man — struggles to keep up while the other kids are kind of terrible about it. Miss Beadle receives a standing ovation and responds by immediately walking away. Charles is reading a book about painting despite nothing in their house being painted. And Harriet appears to have made some very 2026 dietary decisions. Trauma meter: 0. Survivability: high. Charles count: 1. Most bizarre moment: Pa's mysterious interest in home improvement he will absolutely never pursue. Little House, Big Opinions is the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast where two best friends revisit Walnut Grove, one episode and one opinion at a time. New episodes every Wednesday and Thursday. 🎧 Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Audible Podcasts, Amazon Podcasts, and PocketCasts📱 Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @littlehousebigopinions Watch each podcast episode on YouTube @littlehousebigopinionspod Share your Big Opinions with us @littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com #LittleHouseOnThePrairie #LittleHousePodcast #RewatchPodcast #LauraIngallsWilder #SchoolMom #NostalgiaPodcast #LittleHouseBigOpinions #Prairieheads

4. 

   11 Jun 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E9 — Charles & Carolyn: Trend-Setting Baddies

   In this episode of the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast, Riley and Amanda are back in Walnut Grove for Season 1, Episode 8 — Ma's Holiday — and honestly? Low trauma, high chaos, zero rattlesnake for dinner. Well. Almost. Charles surprises Carolyn with a second honeymoon to Mankato — after bribing her with a bonnet to stop talking about the kids. Grace conveniently comes down with a case of the world's worst fake sick performance, leaving Mr. Edwards in charge of three girls, one dog, a rattlesnake, a hole in the roof, and his entire dignity. He does not survive with all of them intact. This week: Mr. Edwards invents the child harness, nails Carrie's dress to the roof, can't read but won't admit it, and eats rattlesnake for dinner with genuine enthusiasm while the girls desperately try to feed it to Jack. Meanwhile in Mankato, Carolyn has a nightmare about the kids, misses the funniest play in Walnut Grove history, and Charles just wants ONE evening. One. The man deserves a bonnet of his own at this point. We also make the case that Michael Landon invented the duck lip, Carolyn Ingalls invented the "same word different emotions" trend, and Mr. Edwards is the unhinged babysitter we all deserved. Trauma meter: 1. Survivability: high. Charles count: 1 Charles shirtless scene: 1 Little House, Big Opinions is the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast where two best friends revisit Walnut Grove, one episode and one opinion at a time. New episodes every Wednesday and Thursday @ 5 AM CST. 📱 @littlehousebigopinions #LittleHouseOnThePrairie #LittleHousePodcast #RewatchPodcast #LauraIngallsWilder #MasHoliday #NostalgiaPodcast #LittleHouseBigOpinions #Prairieheads

5. 

   10 Jun 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E8 - Cinderella: Walnut Grove Edition

   In this episode of Little House, Big Opinions — the Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast for people unpacking their childhood in real time — Riley and Amanda cover "Town Party, Country Party," and it might be the most deceptively wholesome episode of the whole series. A girl named Olga is born with one leg shorter than the other. She gets excluded from a relay race, accidentally befriended at a birthday party, and fitted with a custom prosthetic shoe by Charles Ingalls that lets her run for the first time. It's genuinely sweet. It's one of the good Little House episodes. And it is completely surrounded by unhinged behavior on all sides. This week on the podcast: Nellie Oleson throws herself a birthday party and immediately throws your handmade gift in the trash. Laura Ingalls sprains her ankle from a gentle shove while sitting on the floor (convenient for the plot!). Charles Ingalls forges a custom orthopedic shoe mid-Season 1 because apparently that's just something he does now. And there is a lobster — a bright red, price-tagged, grocery store lobster — sitting in a creek in Walnut Grove, Minnesota. We have questions. Olga's dad spends this episode comparing his disabled daughter to a chicken getting pecked to death, attacking Charles in his own barn with zero preamble, and then standing around eating party cake like nothing happened. Olga herself, however, is an icon — emotionally intelligent beyond her years, deeply quotable, and tragically never seen again after this episode. Classic Little House on the Prairie side character treatment. Riley and Amanda also get into the real history of Mary Ingalls going blind, what Michael Landon invented for drama vs. what actually happened, and why the show never bothered to write out the characters it spent whole episodes developing. Trauma Meter: 1/10 — Happy ending, zero deaths, wholesome core. Olga's dad is unsettling but redeemable. Survivability Rating: 7–8/10 — Olga's going to be okay. The shoe works. The gumption is real. The dad-related PTSD, however, may linger. Charles Shirtless Count: 0 — but Caroline got that look. She was not going to Mankato. She was going to Pound Town. Little House, Big Opinions is a Little House on the Prairie rewatch podcast hosted by two former church kids processing their childhood in real time. New episodes wherever you listen to podcasts. Find us on Instagram and TikTok @littlehousebigopinions.

6. 

   29 May 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E7 - A Diva's Dramatic "Death"

   Riley and Amanda are back, and this week someone fakes their own death on the prairie. Honestly, respect. In episode six, your Little House guides tackle Season 1, Episode 7 — If I Should Die Before I Wake — in which a delightfully dramatic old woman named Amy decides the best way to get her estranged children to visit is to pretend she has died. It works. Charles gets fully swept up in the scheme, Caroline says "Charles" in that specific tone at least twice, and everyone ends up at an impromptu party eating cake by the handful. Before all that, Mattie — Amy's best friend and housemate — actually does die on screen while sitting in a rocking chair. Nobody was expecting that, including Riley and Amanda. Also Doc Baker and Nels have a completely unprompted conversation about inflation that is related to nothing happening in this episode. Favorite line of the episode goes to Mary, delivered from bed during a late night conversation about death: "We don't have wakes at our church because they're fun, and if they're fun, they're sinful." Theological consistency, at least. Trauma Meter: 2/10 (as adults, fine — as children, the black veil was a lot) Survivability Rating: 10/10 (Riley and Amanda are confident they would be excellent at faking their own deaths) Charles Count: 1 solid Charles, 1 borderline Big Opinions: treasure the people around you before it's too late. Also be as dramatic as possible every single day. Amy understood the assignment. Next time: one of both Riley and Amanda's all-time favorite episodes — a wholesome, classic prairie story with a lot of good moments and low trauma. The traumatizing ones are coming. But not yet. 🌾 Find them on Instagram, TikTok & email: @littlehousebigopinions | littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com (mailto:littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com)

7. 

   27 May 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E6 - Laura's First Crush(ed Heart)

   Riley and Amanda are back, and Laura Ingalls has discovered boys. This is not going well for anyone. In episode five, your Little House guides tackle Season 1, Episode 6 — The Love of Johnny Johnson — in which a new student arrives at the Walnut Grove schoolhouse and Laura immediately loses her entire mind over him. Johnny is listed as 15 in the show. The actor is 18. He looks 27. Laura is 10. Nobody on the prairie seems particularly concerned about any of this, and Riley and Amanda have thoughts. Johnny also does not wear shoes. Not once. The entire episode. It all comes to a head when Johnny asks Laura to meet him at the sweetheart tree — which she takes as a very promising sign — only for her to discover he's carved his initials there with Mary's. Not Laura's. Mary's. Mary, who has been loudly calling the sweetheart tree stupid since the opening scene. It ends with Caroline delivering Ma's timeless wisdom: young love is like a heat rash, quickly come and quickly gone. Laura appears to recover. She is already looking for the next fella. Also in this episode: Michael Landon had an affair with the makeup artist on set, which shattered his relationship with Melissa Gilbert for years. Sometimes it really is better not to know. Trauma Meter: 0/10 (just vibes and a bruised heart) Survivability Rating: 7/10 (unrequited love is genuinely all-consuming, and Riley got away easy because apparently all the predators were really into her) Charles Count: unconfirmed, we were too distracted by Johnny's bare feet Big Opinions: somebody should have been concerned about that age gap considerably sooner. Also Johnny should have been wearing shoes. One or the other. Those were both gross. Next time: Episode 7, If I Should Die Before I Wake. The title is misleading. The trauma is low. Charles gets wrapped up in the hijinks of an old lady in town and it's actually kind of fun. See you there. 🌾 Find them on Instagram, TikTok & email: @littlehousebigopinions | littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com (mailto:littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com)

8. 

   21 May 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E5- Prairie Short: Love Schemes

   Welcome to the very first Prairie Short — a shorter, lighter episode for a lighter Little House story. No explosions. No broken bones. Just vibes, mild matchmaking, and one man singing Old Dan Tucker an unreasonable number of times. In this Prairie Short, Riley and Amanda cover Season 1, Episode 4 — Mr. Edwards' Homecoming — in which Pa finds Mr. Edwards drunk in a saloon, dunks his head in water until he is immediately sober (apparently that's all it takes), and brings him back to Walnut Grove. Caroline promptly decides he needs a wife and sets her sights on Grace Snyder — though she insists on calling her the Widow Snyder, because your marital status does define you, ladies. Mr. Edwards sends a love letter to himself to impress her. The mill owner watches Grace dance and is very into it. And when a theological difference threatens the whole romance, Caroline personally intervenes — because of course she does. Trauma Meter: not applicable (this is a Prairie Short, and we are safe here)Survivability Rating: very high (the biggest threat is catching feelings)Charles Shirtless Count: unconfirmed, but the chaos was minimal Big Opinion: stop calling her the Widow Snyder. Her name is Grace. We are not referring to Caroline as Wife of Charles and we will not be starting now. Next time: Laura gets her first crush. Ma describes young love as a heat rash — quickly come and quickly gone. We'll see you there. 🌾 Find them on Instagram, TikTok & email: @littlehousebigopinions | littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com (mailto:littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com)

9. 

   16 May 2026

   Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E4- Better Hold on Tight Powder Monkey

   Riley and Amanda are back, and things just got significantly less wholesome. In episode three, your Little House guides tackle Season 1, Episode 3 — The 100 Mile Walk — and this is the one where Little House finally shows its true colors. Pa's crops are looking great, the family is thriving, and then — as is tradition — everything immediately falls apart. There's a hailstorm, a 100-mile walk for work, some extremely intense double jacking, and one man who does not make it out in one piece. A dude literally explodes. We are not being dramatic. Also in this episode: Karen Grassle (Ma!) asked for a raise and apparently didn't get one. Riley and Amanda stand with Karen. Always. Trauma Meter: 6-7/10 (comparatively mild for what's coming, but the explosion alone earns it) Survivability Rating: 0/10 (they would absolutely blow themselves up accidentally — this was discussed at length and they stand by it) Big Opinions: Charles was hasty, Caroline was right, and honestly when is she not. Some things never change on the prairie. Grab your bonnet. It only gets wilder from here. 🌾 Find them on Instagram, TikTok & email: @littlehousebigopinions | littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com (mailto:littlehousebigopinions@gmail.com)

10. 

    13 May 2026

    Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E2 & E3- Broken Bones & Frontier Frenemies

    Riley and Amanda are back, and this time things are comparatively… fine? Don't worry, it won't last. In episode two, your Little House guides tackle what are technically Season 1 episodes one and two — Harvest of Friends and Country Girls — as they follow the Ingalls family to their new life in Walnut Grove (Plum Creek is the farmstead, Walnut Grove is the town — they figured it out, you're welcome). Pa falls out of a tree, breaks some ribs, and then immediately tries to stack hay anyway because apparently rest is for quitters. Nellie Oleson makes her debut — complete with a wig, which apparently caused its wearer to pass out from heat exhaustion during filming. Michael Landon is shirtless more than medically necessary. And Laura delivers a speech about Ma that has everyone crying. Trauma Meter: 1/10 (genuinely, these are some of the most wholesome episodes they've seen yet) Survivability Rating: 8-9/10 (the broken ribs are a concern, the frontier bullying less so — kids are arguably worse now) Big Opinions: Pa working on Sunday is apparently a greater sin than missing church entirely, and Laura Ingalls continues to be the most emotionally intelligent person on the prairie. Some things are just consistent. Grab your bonnets, and let’s go. 🌾 Find them on Instagram & TikTok: @littlehousebigopinions

11. 

    13 May 2026

    Little House on the Prairie Rewatch S1E1- Wolves, Indians, and Fires, Oh my!

    Riley and Amanda are here, and the Ingalls family did not think this through — packing up and moving to the middle of Indian Territory with zero forethought will do that to you. In their very first episode, your new favorite Little House guides introduce themselves, explain how a summer of communal prairie watching turned into a full-blown podcast, and break down Season 1, Episode 1. There are wolves, a house fire, and one dog in peril — oh, and the Ingalls family somehow seemed surprised to find Native people already living on Native land. Trauma Meter: 3/10 (which will make a lot more sense once you hear what's coming) Survivability Rating: 6.5/10 Big Opinions: the Ingalls family was wildly unprepared, and Laura was the only one with emotional intelligence. They stand by both of these takes. If you grew up watching Little House and thinking wait… was this actually appropriate for children? — welcome home. Grab your bonnet. Let's go. A note from Riley and Amanda: they apologize for the variation in sound quality throughout this episode. After recording for the first time, they decided to add in a bit more to better introduce themselves and the podcast. Don't worry, they will hopefully get better at this as they go on! 🌾 Find them on Instagram & TikTok: @littlehousebigopinions

Contact Little House, Big Opinions

Guest appearances

Does not typically book guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.