Welcome to Wolf Bluff. Kindly remember that the woods are theirs, and the town is ours.
Somewhere deep in the southeast, as the town of Wolf Bluff locks its doors and dampens its fireplaces, radio host Rex McHattie and his producer Kit Greenville are sound-checking their nightly call-in show, The Witching Hour. Between midnight and three AM, callers from all over the Wolf Bluff tell their best, most harrowing tales of mystery, murder, and malevolence. But the scariest stories might just be happening off the air...
When a mysterious entity begins to plague Rex and disrupt his nightly show, he's more frustrated than curious. Newly sober after an accident that almost took his life the previous year, he's a staunch skeptic of the supernatural despite his line of work. But with the uptick in missing person cases, the unexplained glow from The Woods, and a ghostly presence that won't seem to leave him alone, Rex is thrown into a mystery that may just unravel the entire town.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com
Hosted on Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy for more information.
Motel owner Dave Peele shares a terrifying haunted night with host Alena Hex, revealing Wolf Bluff's dark history.
29 Jun 2026
0. Spooky Boogie: Wampus Cat
Folklore expert Alena Hex interviews an individual about a life-altering encounter with a Wampus Cat, exploring a chilling new darkness in Wolf Bluff.
31 May 2026TRANSCRIPT
Season 2 of Longtime, First Time is Coming SOON!
This episode announces the upcoming return of the narrative podcast "Longtime, First Time" for its second season, teasing new secrets in a spooky small town.
23 Feb 2026TRANSCRIPT
The Nightmare Shift: Don't Go to Bodacious Burger
Curtis, a broke college student, takes a job at Bodacious Burger and discovers the terrifying secrets lurking beneath the surface during the night shift.
21 Dec 2025TRANSCRIPT
Better Watch Out (Holiday Special)
Sheriff Ted Bullock recounts a harrowing tale of a 1985 holiday season serial killer in Wolf Bluff, offering a scary story for a Yuletide celebration in this episode.
6 Oct 2025
6. Requiem for a Dead Girl
This episode presents the conclusion of a narrative podcast season, where a murdered woman haunts a radio host, leading to answers and the start of a new mystery.
16 Sept 2025
13 months ago...
Rex McHattie meets his sponsor, Ralphie, for the first time in a church basement, exploring themes of belonging and initial connections.
7 Sept 2025
5. The Archive
Host Ausha interviews Lucky Cunningham about the final days of Wolf Bluff's video store, The Archive, while Lieutenant Greenville investigates a murder.
26 Aug 2025
DECLINED: Meeting with Shep Matthews
Host Ausha interviews Shep Matthews about navigating the challenges of a late-night radio show, offering insights into managing unexpected disruptions.
9 Aug 2025
4. Snowstorm in a Bottle
WBAR staff members Mike, Ryan, and Fiona search for supplies during a snowstorm, while Rex reveals his troubled upbringing to Kit, leading to an unsettling discovery.
10 Jul 2025
3. The Curse of Wolf Bluff
Local historian Cliff Billings unveils Wolf Bluff's blood-soaked origin story through Winston Wolf's diary, revealing secrets of exile and rituals in this interview episode.
11 Jun 2025
2. There's Something in The Woods
Wolf Bluff local Tina recounts a terrifying scavenger hunt in The Woods with friends on The Witching Hour, where few innocent things survive, revealing the dark side of seemingly harmless adventures.
12 May 2025
1. You're Gonna Be Fine
Rex McHattie is no stranger to the paranormal; after all, his show, The Witching Hour, gets calls from listeners 5 nights a week detailing their scariest stories of mystery, murder, and malevolence. But this time, things are getting personal.
Fresh off a ghostly encounter, Rex is back in the studio with his long-suffering producer, Kit Greenville, and the rest of the WBAR crew, including assistant producer Fiona Nistwenger, station manager Mike Bullock, and his eager assistant, Ryan.
On the line tonight is Laura Carpenter –– a young mother with a harrowing tale of her run-in with a now suspiciously missing self-help guru and his biggest fan… or something that was pretending to be them.
Will Rex make it through the show without losing his mind? Is Laura’s story true? Tune in and decide on this month’s episode of Longtime, First Time.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
30 Apr 2025
Our First Caller Is...
Hear Laura's harrowing tale, and catch up with the whole crew at WBAR on Episode 1 of Longtime, First Time –– releasing May 12th at midnight.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
23 Apr 2025
HELP WANTED!
Though WBAR has its charm, it's not the hippest place to work in town (or anywhere within 100 miles). Finding an intern who can handle a curmudgeon like Rex McHattie and the ever-present smell of burnt coffee and 40-year-old cigarettes hasn't always been the easiest task for Kit Greenville –– until she met Fiona.
Episode 1 of Longtime, First Time premieres on May 12th, with new episodes released every full moon.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
12 Apr 2025
0. Tuning In (Prologue)
It’s a normal Tuesday night –– the crew of The Witching Hour are heading out as you’re heading in and ready to tantalize you with tales of murder, mystery, and malevolence.
But, of course, this is Wolf Bluff. There is no such thing as a normal night.
About Longtime, First Time:
Welcome to Wolf Bluff. Kindly remember that the woods are theirs, and the town is ours.
Somewhere deep in the Southeast, as the town of Wolf Bluff locks its doors and dampens its fireplaces, radio host Rex McHattie and his producer Kit Greenville are sound-checking their nightly call-in show, The Witching Hour. Between midnight and three AM, callers from all over the Wolf Bluff tell their best, most harrowing tales of mystery, murder, and malevolence. But the scariest stories might just be happening off the air...
When a mysterious entity begins to plague Rex and disrupt his nightly show, he's more frustrated than curious. Newly sober after an accident that almost took his life the previous year, he's a staunch skeptic of the supernatural despite his line of work. But with the uptick in missing person cases, the unexplained glow from The Woods, and a ghostly presence that won't seem to leave him alone, Rex is thrown into a mystery that may just unravel the entire town.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Cast:
Dan Gallun as Rex McHattie
Kristen Fields as Kit Greenville
Dustin LaFleur as Hank LeVent
Noah Litton as Tom Greenville
Taryn Pray as Suzanne O’Connor
Deiondre Teagle as Ralphie
Krystyn Ryder as Fiona Nitswenger
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
9 Apr 2025
Special Announcement from the Wolf Bluff P.D.
Tom Greenville is an honest cop in the sleepy town of Wolf Bluff. With missing person cases on the rise, the people of Wolf Bluff are at a fever pitch. What secrets do the woods on the edge of town hold? And what can Tom do to protect his fellow citizens from not only the things lurking in the woods...but from themselves?
Episode 0 drops on Saturday, April 12th at midnight.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
2 Apr 2025
NEW VOICEMAIL: Suzanne O'Connor
Strange things are afoot in the town of Wolf Bluff, and there are few people more acutely aware of it than Kit's aunt, Suzanne O'Connor. Former psychic and current town oddball, Kit is used to getting cryptic messages from the woman who raised her. But what happens when the warnings start coming true, and the supernatural finds itself on her doorstep?
Episode 0 of Longtime, First Time premieres April 12th at midnight. Make sure to subscribe for more windows into Wolf Bluff between episodes.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
30 Mar 2025
Welcome to Wolf Bluff
PREMIERES APRIL 12TH. NEW EPISODES EVERY FULL MOON.
Welcome to Wolf Bluff. Kindly remember that the woods are theirs, and the town is ours.
Somewhere deep in the Southeast, as the town of Wolf Bluff locks its doors and dampens its fireplaces, radio host Rex McHattie and his producer Kit Greenville are sound-checking their nightly call-in show, The Witching Hour. Between midnight and three AM, callers from all over the Wolf Bluff tell their best, most harrowing tales of mystery, murder, and malevolence. But the scariest stories might just be happening off the air...
When a mysterious entity begins to plague Rex and disrupt his nightly show, he's more frustrated than curious. Newly sober after an accident that almost took his life the previous year, he's a staunch skeptic of the supernatural despite his line of work. But with the uptick in missing person cases, the unexplained glow from The Woods, and a ghostly presence that won't seem to leave him alone, Rex is thrown into a mystery that may just unravel the entire town.
Longtime, First Time is an original narrative podcast produced by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/ (https://www.instagram.com/ltftpod/)
Follow KNUCKLEDRAGGER on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/ (https://www.instagram.com/knuckledraggerstudios/)
Learn more about KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS: https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com (https://www.knuckledraggerstudios.com)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy (https://ausha.co/privacy-policy) for more information.
Who has been a guest on Longtime, First Time
Names identified in recent episode analyses. Showing up to five guests.
Sheriff Ted Bullock
Lucky Cunningham
Shep Matthews
Cliff Billings
Tina
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
4.8 / 5
52 ratings
Spotify
4.7 / 5
28 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 48 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
44
Social presence
91
YouTube
0
Engagement
85
Contact Longtime, First Time
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Questions about Longtime, First Time
Who hosts Longtime, First Time?
Ausha host the show. Published by KNUCKLEDRAGGER STUDIOS.
How often do new episodes come out?
The show publishes bi-weekly, based on its RSS feed.
Does Longtime, First Time take guests?
The show does not typically feature guests, based on episode analyses.
Where can I read transcripts?
4 of 19 episodes have a transcript on Pod Engine. Full transcripts are available with a Pod Engine plan.
Host of Longtime, First Time?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
