In a hobby often dominated by hype and hyperbole, Love of the Game Auctions Podcast offers a scholarly insider’s look at the history of sports memorabilia and the legends who made it significant. Hosted by Al Crisafulli, Founder and President of Love of the Game Auctions, this show goes beyond the auction block to explore the artifacts that define the game we love.
Established in 2012 with the goal of being a trustworthy resource for avid hobbyists and novices alike to buy and sell quality material, Love of the Game Auctions is one of the most widely respected auction houses in the industry. We understand that while each collector has taken a different path in the hobby, every approach originates from the same place: a love of the game.
During our episodes, we dig into the stories behind the items we’re lucky enough to handle alongside people keeping history alive. If you value the lore as much as the score, you’re in the right place. Let’s go!
Al Crisafulli shares the story behind the only known Pete Hill signature available in private hands, a rare piece of Negro Leagues history that ultimately sold for more than $100,000. He traces the artifact’s journey from the estate of Hill’s former teammate Percy Wilson to the auction block and explores what its discovery says about the growing collector interest in Black baseball history. Al is then joined by Bob Kendrick, President of the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, for a conversation about the players and personalities who shaped the Negro Leagues and why there is still more work to be done to ensure this history remains an essential part of the story of baseball.
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/
Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: http://www.stoley.com/
https://www.nlbm.com/ (https://www.nlbm.com/)
Episode highlights:
(0:57) The remarkable Pete Hill autograph and its discovery
(3:43) Authentication and the $104,400 auction result
(5:19) Bob Kendrick joins the conversation
(8:09) How Bob fell in love with Negro Leagues history
(11:47) What visitors misunderstand about the Negro Leagues
(17:53) The incredible story of Martín Dihigo
(22:42) Preserving rare Negro Leagues artifacts
(28:18) Historic treasures inside the museum
(31:26) The Negro Leagues as a major Black-owned business
(32:25) The economic cost of baseball integration
(39:10) Integrating Negro League statistics into MLB records
(43:43) The life lessons Bob wants young people to learn
(46:06) Buck O’Neill’s unforgettable Satchel Paige story
(50:25) MLB The Show introduces Negro Leagues history to millions
(54:45) Bob’s lifelong love of baseball and Henry Aaron
(57:39) Plans for the new Negro Leagues Baseball Museum
10 Sept 2026
EP 6: The Origin of Scrapps Tobacco + Guest Andy Broome
Al Crisafulli revisits the origins of the first gum cards, settling the long-misunderstood label of Scrapps Tobacco. He’s joined by Andy Broome, the Vice President of CGC Cards, who shares how a childhood discovery sparked his passion for the hobby. Andy also offers a behind-the-scenes look at CGC’s approach to grading, including a high-stakes moment that helped save a collector’s home, and discusses the company’s ongoing commitment to research, accuracy, and innovation in card preservation.
https://www.cgccards.com/ (https://www.cgccards.com/)
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/ (https://loveofthegameauctions.com/)
Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: www.stoley.com (http://www.stoley.com/)
Episode highlights:
(0:54) The mystery behind the 1888 Scraps Tobacco cards
(3:08) The H.D.S. & Co. clue that changed the story
(5:35) Why Scraps Tobacco was actually a gum card issue
(6:02) Introducing CGC Cards Vice President Andy Broome
(8:13) How Andy began grading pre-war baseball cards
(10:58) The incredible T206 Honus Wagner discovery
(15:10) How the Wagner helped save its owner’s home
(20:08) Collecting vintage Japanese baseball and Victor Starfin
(23:46) CGC’s approach to vintage and obscure card grading
(34:32) The baseball moment that started Andy’s lifelong passion
7 Jul 2026
EP 5: Jackie Robinson's First At Bat + Guest Andrew Aronstein
Al Crisafulli explores the story of a Jackie Robinson stadium photo that captured Robinson’s first major league at-bat in 1947. Joining Al is Love of the Game's Andrew Aronstein, who dives into the world of vintage baseball photography, from ensuring authenticity to navigating the challenges of altered or digitally enhanced images. From historic photos to the people who preserve them, this episode provides an inside look at the hobby and the stories that keep baseball history alive.
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/
(https://loveofthegameauctions.com/)Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: www.stoley.com (http://www.stoley.com/)
Episode highlights:
(0:55) Jackie Robinson’s first MLB at-bat photo
(5:22) Meet Andrew Aronstein and his hobby roots
(9:01) TCMA, minor league cards, and rookie card history
(13:00) Photofile archives and early sports photography
(18:32) What collectors often miss in original photos
(22:50) Authenticity, condition, and altered vintage images
(35:10) How to spot trimming and photo changes
(36:52) How grading, the internet, and eBay changed collecting
(40:18) The most special item Andrew ever handled
(44:03) Was Paul Thompson really a photographer?
(45:31) Andrew’s “love of the game” moment
9 Jun 2026
EP 4: John White's Autograph Book + Guest Tanith Harley
Al Crisafulli tells the story of John White, a fan who created his own piece of history by collecting autographs at Cleveland’s League Park. He’s joined by Tanith Harley, an Australian baseball history enthusiast, writer, and collector whose work focuses on uncovering and preserving the history of women in baseball through memorabilia. Drawing on her own lifelong connection to the game, Tanith discusses her research and collection centered on women’s baseball and her efforts to highlight overlooked stories.
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/ (https://loveofthegameauctions.com/)
Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: http://www.stoley.com/ (http://www.stoley.com/)
Episode highlights:
(0:55) John White’s 1920s autograph book
(3:57) Meet Tanith Harley
(5:27) Growing up as a girl playing baseball in Australia
(10:17) Tanith’s start in card collecting
(15:02) Why women’s baseball became her focus
(16:32) Australian women’s baseball history
(20:30) Where to start learning about women in baseball
(24:19) Authenticating and dating historic items
(27:27) Growing hobby interest in women’s baseball
(29:47) Tanith’s most meaningful collection pieces
(35:20) Thoughts on the WPBL
(40:19) Leona and Nellie Kearns’ baseball story
(45:02) The moment Tanith fell in love with the game
12 May 2026
EP 3: Babe Ruth Ball + Guest Jason Schwartz
Al Crisafulli tells the story of a Babe Ruth ball personalized to Kenneth Caselnova, sharing its unique provenance and Ruth’s 1946 stay with the family. Baseball card expert and SABR co-chair Jason Schwartz joins to discuss his collecting journey, Hank Aaron cards, and how SABR could revive the Standard Catalog. From legendary artifacts to the evolving world of baseball card research, this episode uncovers the stories that make the hobby timeless.
https://sabr.org/
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/
(https://loveofthegameauctions.com/)Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: www.stoley.com
Episode highlights:
(0:54) Babe Ruth and the Caselnova family story
(5:03) Jason Schwartz introduction
(6:12) Jason’s start in collecting
(11:18) Why Hank Aaron matters
(18:12) Vintage card myths and 1949 Leaf
(23:55) SABR Baseball Cards Research Committee
(30:04) Preserving hobby knowledge
(50:30) Jason’s dream card
(53:52) The Steve Garvey card that changed everything
16 Apr 2026
EP 2: The Discovery of Billy Miller + Guest Rick Cerrone
Al Crisafulli uncovers the compelling history of a rare 1903 calendar out of Honesdale, Pennsylvania, an artifact that led to the discovery of local hero Billy Miller. Al then sits down with Rick Cerrone, the Editor-in-Chief of Baseball Digest and a veteran of the sports and media industries. Rick shares insights from his time leading public relations for the New York Yankees and working in magazine publishing, offering insider memories while reflecting on the lasting importance of storytelling in baseball.
https://baseballdigest.com/
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/
Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: http://www.stoley.com/
(0:58) Billy Miller’s remarkable story begins
(4:28) Miller’s military service with the Harlem Hellfighters
(5:19) Rick Cerrone joins the show
(8:55) Rick’s early path into sports media
(19:54) Launching Baseball Quarterly
(36:04) Becoming Yankees PR director
(45:26) Behind-the-scenes Yankees stories
(54:06) Rick’s vision for Baseball Digest
(59:48) What made Rick fall in love with baseball
17 Mar 2026
EP 1: The Lou Gehrig Bat + Guest Graig Kreindler
In the first episode of the Love of the Game Auctions Podcast, Al Crisafulli recounts the story of a Lou Gehrig game-used bat that sold for a record-breaking price - a sale he credits with putting Love of the Game on the map. He then talks with artist Graig Kreindler, who brings baseball history to life through meticulously researched oil paintings. From rare collectibles to the stories behind the legends, this episode is a must-listen for fans and collectors alike.
https://www.graigkreindler.com/
https://loveofthegameauctions.com/
Produced by Brand Groupies - https://brandgroupies.com/
Theme music by Doug Stoley: https://stoley.com (https://stoley.com/)
17 Mar 2026
Welcome to Love of the Game Auctions Podcast
Every collector's path is different. Some of us hunt for the pristine, while others find beauty in the well-loved corners of a century-old card. Some of us collect what we know, others dig deep into the research and the great hobby mysteries. But no matter the path, every journey starts in the same place: a love of the game.
On this show, we're going beyond the auction block to talk about the legends, the rarities, and the long-forgotten stories that make this hobby great. I'll be joined by guests who live and breathe sports - experts who help us see the hobby through a different lens. So if you value the lore as much of the score, you're in the right place. Let's go.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
9 ratings
Contact Love of the Game Auctions
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
