Monsters, Magic & Mayhem is the podcast where questionable ideas become table inspiration. Each week, I’ll spotlight a monster, curse an everyday item in the funniest way possible, and toss out encounter, quest, and roleplay ideas you can steal for your own game.
Bring your dice, your chaos, and your questionable decisions.
Have a story from your table? Want to ask a question or send some love?
Email me at wecertainlytried@gmail.com!
I am back! Sorry the MIA lately.
Hope you enjoy the reboot of the show, it's pretty much the same, the name is the biggest change.
Please send me some mail! Any advice, info, suggestions, stories or whatever drives you to email me!
wecertainlytried@gmail.com
17 Apr 2026
Pouty Patrons
This week we cover a Warlock who doesn't believe in it's patron, a gift from that patron and a Goblin, that should be used at least once in a while during those goblin encounters.
Send me your ideas and stories to:
wecertainlytried@gmail.com
And you can follow me on Tiktok under this username!
10 Apr 2026
Bright Eye Grave Digger
This week I talk about a happy little necromancer, beads that might not be as sufficient as you hoped and a baddie that is way more intimidating than it's been credited for.
3 Apr 2026
Goo Bags
Quick correction! Our guest plays on Monday nights @ 6 CST
He runs games Sunday and Tuesday @ 6 CST
Again, go give him a like and follow on Twitch and Tiktok, great games and great content.
This week we talked about anxious bards, cracked sending stones and an ooze monster that is absolutely terror fueled.
If you have suggestions, comments or just want to say hi, you can comment on the episode or send me stories to wecertainlytried@gmail.com
27 Mar 2026
Fantasy TB
This week I cover a cloak going through puberty, a hero who didn't get the memo and a monster that is hilariously brilliant to teach the party a lesson...which we will absolutely not learn.
23 Mar 2026
Rage Recovery
This week we dive into a take on the Hat of Disguise if it was made with flaws. A Barbarian build who focuses on bettering themselves and a monster that has slipped by in opportunity...no longer.
All things are credited to D&D and altered by me.
If you have anything you'd like to share, email me at wecertainlytried@gmail.com to get featured in future episodes.
Hope you enjoy!
13 Mar 2026
Announcment
Due to being new I need to change a few things, at least for now. Here's what you can expect to hear going forward!
13 Mar 2026
It's Not Venom
Thank you ConsumeroftheChipGods for letting me read your story!
Today we talk about polymorph mishaps and Wyvern Venom.
It's a good one
Trigger warning, some sound effects include vomiting later in the episode, so if you have a sensitive stomach, be careful. It's much later towards the end of story 2.
If you have a chaotic, funny fail, or just epic story you'd like me to read you can submit it by emailing me at wecertainlytried@gmail.com
6 Mar 2026
Goose Just Goose
Have you ever been bested by a christmas dinner? Me either, but this submitter has! Thank you for sharing your story! I laughed way too hard at this.
If you have a story you would like to share, you can email us at wecertainlytried@gmail.com
6 Mar 2026
Tik got Tocked
Apparently birds get hit with birds...or something like that...
Thank you Nate for your story!
If you have a funny, chaotic or just a story you want to share you can email it to us at wecertainlytried@gmail.com
6 Mar 2026
Owlbear Harness
Episode of firsts. First day playing, first character, first owlbear and first death.
Thank you DMsCult for letting me read your story!
If you would like to submit a story you can email us at wecertainlytried@gmail.com
24 Feb 2026
Teaser 1 Chicken Lover
Barbarians, pets, and questions.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Host of Monsters, Magic & Mayhem?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
