- 16
- Episodes
- 2025
- First episode
About Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast
Welcome to Must Be Tuesday, the ultimate Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch podcast for Scoobies, Slayers, and anyone who’s ever said “If the apocalypse comes, beep me.” Join hosts Mike & Manny every week as they revisit Sunnydale with equal parts nostalgia, chaos, and camp. Expect witty banter, deep dives into demon drama, and plenty of quotes that prove Buffy still slays decades later. So sharpen your stakes, grab some holy water, and tune in — because on Tuesdays, we watch Buffy. Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and BuffyTuesdays.com
- Publisher
- Buffy Tuesdays with Mike and Manny
- Category
- tv & film
- Language
- en
- Explicit
- No
- First episode
- 14 Oct 2025
- Latest episode
- 1 Jul 2026
Latest episodes
16 episodes in the feed.
1 Jul 2026
Buffy S2E4 “Inca Mummy Girl” REWATCH | Must Be Tuesday
This week we’re diving into Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 2, Episode 4 — Inca Mummy Girl 🏺 A school cultural exchange program sounds harmless enough… until an ancient Incan mummy awakens, steals an exchange student’s identity, and enrolls at Sunnydale High. That’s right, Ampata has arrived. We’re talking ancient curses, forbidden romance, and Xander once again falling for someone who may or may not be trying to kill people. We also get the arrival of Oz, Willow’s iconic Eskimo/Inuit-inspired outfit, and more of Buffy trying to balance normal teenage life with the whole chosen-one-saving-the-world thing. Join us as we revisit one of Season 2’s stranger episodes and break down the romance, horror, comedy, questionable choices, and classic Buffy moments. 🧛 New episodes weekly(ish) as we work through Season 2 🐾 Follow along, share your thoughts, and welcome back to the Hellmouth Until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us. 🧛♀️ Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
19 May 2026
Buffy S2E3 “School Hard” REWATCH | Must Be Tuesday
This week we’re diving into Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 2, Episode 3 — School Hard 🧛♂️ Parent-teacher night is stressful enough without a vampire attack, but Sunnydale High has never been normal. Buffy is stuck trying to keep Principal Snyder, Joyce, and her secret life from colliding, just as a dangerous new vampire rolls into town. That’s right, Spike has arrived. We’re talking Spike, Drusilla, the Anointed One, Buffy’s big school showdown, and one of the most iconic entrances in the entire series. We also get more of Joyce trying to understand Buffy and a major shift in the vampire world of Sunnydale. Join us as we revisit one of Season 2’s most important episodes and break down all the chaos, comedy, horror, and classic Buffy moments. 🧛 New episodes weekly(ish) as we work through Season 2 🐾 Follow along, share your thoughts, and welcome back to the Hellmouth Until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us. 🧛♀️📟 Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
28 Apr 2026
Buffy S2E2 “Some Assembly Required” REWATCH | Must Be Tuesday
This week we’re diving into Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 2, Episode 2 — Some Assembly Required ⚰️ A strange string of grave robbings leads Buffy and the gang into one of Sunnydale’s creepiest cases yet, involving science experiments, obsession, and a seriously disturbing idea of romance. We’re talking Chris, Eric, Daryl, and one unforgettable basement reveal. We also get more of Buffy trying to settle back into normal life after everything with the Master, while still carrying the weight of what happened. Join us as we revisit one of Season 2’s weirdest early monster-of-the-week episodes and break down all the chaos, horror, and classic Buffy moments. 🧛 New episodes weekly(ish) as we work through Season 2 🐾 Follow along, share your thoughts, and welcome back to the Hellmouth Until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us. 🧛♀️📟 Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
21 Apr 2026
When She Was Bad (S2E1) | We're Back! | Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast
We’re back! After a longer break than planned, Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast returns with Season 2, Episode 1 — “When She Was Bad.” Buffy’s not exactly herself after facing The Master… and Sunnydale feels it. This episode kicks off Season 2 with a darker edge, messy emotions, and the first signs that things are about to change in a big way. We’re diving into: Buffy’s post-Master spiralThe tension with Willow Rosenberg, Xander Harris, Giles, and Angel. Why this episode quietly sets the tone for all of Season 2Early signs of the deeper storytelling Buffy becomes known for. Whether you’ve been rewatching along or jumping back in after a break like us — this is the perfect place to return. 🧛 New episodes weekly(ish) as we work through Season 2 🐾 Follow along, share your thoughts, and welcome back to the Hellmouth! Until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us. 🧛♀️ Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
30 Dec 2025
Prophecy Girl (S1E12) | Season 1 Finale | Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast
This week on Must Be Tuesday, we’re closing out Season 1 with the finale — “Prophecy Girl.” Buffy gets hit with a prophecy that says she won’t survive the night, the Master makes his big move, and everything escalates fast. It’s emotional, brutal, and the moment Season 1 finally goes for the throat. We break down Buffy’s choice, the Scoobies stepping up when it counts, Cordelia being peak Cordelia, and why this finale still hits. We’re taking a short break before Season 2 — follow us on socials for updates on our return. Until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us. 🧛♀️📟 Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
23 Dec 2025
Out of Mind, Out of Sight — Sunnydale’s Invisible Problem | Buffy S1E11
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re discussing Season 1, Episode 11 — “Out of Mind, Out of Sight.” Something invisible is moving through Sunnydale High, and the consequences of being ignored start to pile up. We talk unseen threats, what happens when people are overlooked, and memorable Cordelia moments. Join us as we revisit an episode that asks what happens when people disappear — and no one notices. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch the Season 1 finale, Episode 12 — “Prophecy Girl” — before next week… and until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
16 Dec 2025
When Nightmares Become Reality | Buffy S1E10 “Nightmares”
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re facing our fears with Season 1, Episode 10 — “Nightmares.” What starts as a run-of-the-mill Sunnydale day quickly spirals into full-on subconscious horror as everyone’s worst fears start coming true. Homework, clowns, spiders, and deeply buried trauma? Absolutely not. We break down Buffy’s terrifying confrontation with her own doubts, fear of public humiliation (relatable), and how this episode quietly deepens the emotional stakes of Season 1 while still delivering peak monster-of-the-week weirdness. Plus: why this episode hits harder than it has any right to this early in the series. Grab your crucifix, face your inner demons, and maybe avoid the basement — it’s Buffy at its darkest, strangest, and most psychologically revealing yet. Slay along with us every Tuesday!Watch Episode 11: “Out of Mind, Out of Sight” before next week — and until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
9 Dec 2025
The Puppet Show — Talent Shows, Twists & Sunnydale Chaos
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re taking the stage with Season 1, Episode 9 — “The Puppet Show.” Sunnydale High hosts a talent show (already a red flag), Principal Snyder makes his unforgettable debut, and somehow a ventriloquist dummy becomes suspect number one in a string of very real murders. Peak early-Buffy chaos. We break down Buffy’s suspicion of Sid the puppet, Giles’ descent into talent-show-director hell, and why this episode works so well as a classic Season 1 monster-of-the-week entry. Grab your spotlight, your wooden stake, and try not to heckle the performers — it’s Buffy at its creepiest, goofiest, and most surprisingly sincere. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 10: “Nightmares” before next week — and until next Tuesday… if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
2 Dec 2025
I, Robot… You, Jane — Chaos, Catfishing & Demon Tech | Buffy Rewatch Podcast
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re jacking into Season 1’s most chaotic tech adventure — “I, Robot… You, Jane.” From cursed chatrooms to early days internet drama (peak 90s energy!), this episode gives us Buffy’s first true “the internet is evil” storyline… and honestly? Moloch is serving big Reddit-mod-gone-wrong vibes. We break down Willow’s ill-fated digital romance, Jenny Calendar’s unforgettable entrance into the Scooby dynamic, and why this episode is secretly a huge turning point for Giles’ relationships with both tech and Ms. Calendar herself. Plus, we talk monster-of-the-week structure, early-series character building, and what absolutely does not hold up in 2025. Grab your stake, your modem, and maybe don’t talk to strangers online — it's Buffy Season 1 at its most wonderfully weird. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 9: “The Puppet Show” before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
25 Nov 2025
Angel — The Vampire Boyfriend Era Begins
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re diving into “Angel” — the moment Buffy Summers officially enters her vampire-boyfriend era. Between stolen glances, crypt-side confessions, and one very dramatic shirtless reveal, this episode delivers the full 90s supernatural romance starter pack. We get into how the show finally pulls the curtain back on Angel’s curse (yes, that one), why Darla is out here being chaotic and iconic, and how the Buffy/Angel dynamic becomes the emotional backbone of the early series. Plus, we talk stakes (literal and relationship) and that final scene that still punches 25+ years later. Grab your wooden stakes and emotional support crossbow — this one’s a classic! Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 8: “I, Robot... You, Jane” before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
18 Nov 2025
Unpacking The Pack — Why We Love It!
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re sinking our teeth into “The Pack” — the hyena-possession classic that is way better than people give it credit for. Whether this is an unpopular opinion or not… we’re proudly Team Pack. Between the eerie courtyard slow-mo prowl, Xander’s unsettling transformation (and very selective memory afterward), and the episode’s surprisingly dark turns, “The Pack” is early Buffy at its weirdest — and honestly, at its most compelling. We break down why the tone works, how the show uses this episode to test the boundaries of what a Monster-of-the-Week can do, and why this one sticks with you long after season one is over. We also talk Xander’s possession arc (and everything the show does and doesn’t say about it), Willow’s emotional honesty, and Buffy navigating yet another week of “why is my high school like this?” energy. Plus, our thoughts on the episode’s darker moments, its place in early Buffy world-building, and how it sets the stage for the show’s willingness to push boundaries. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 7: “Angel” before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
11 Nov 2025
Never Kill a Boy on the First Date – Buffy’s First Date (and First Red Flag)
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re talking “Never Kill a Boy on the First Date” — where Buffy tries to have one normal night out and, shocker, the Hellmouth says absolutely not. Between crypt-side flirting, a brooding Giles reciting prophecies like a Victorian audiobook, and Owen’s obsession with death (red flag much?), this episode proves dating in Sunnydale is truly killer. We break down how Buffy’s fight for balance — Slaying vs. social life — sets the stage for her whole journey, plus how the episode nails that early Buffy tone: campy, quippy, and a little tragic. Also, why does every “nice guy” in 90s TV have a pocket watch and a morbid hobby? Plus: our takes on Giles’s father-figure guilt, Angel’s professional lurking skills, and a morgue date that somehow gets worse by the minute. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 6: “The Pack” before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Follow us on socials for all things Buffy! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
4 Nov 2025
Teacher’s Pet — Pheromones, Fork Guy, and One Giant She-Mantis
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re heading back to biology class for Teacher’s Pet, where Buffy loses a genuinely wonderful teacher, Cordelia finds a head in the fridge (Sunnydale High cafeteria vibes), and a mysterious substitute shows up with big “extra credit after class” energy. Spoiler: she’s a literal She-Mantis, because in this town even faculty recruitment is cursed. We break down how the show tries to throw us off with “Fork Guy” — a clawed vampire who is very much not the threat — and how even he’s scared of our seductive substitute. We also get into the chef’s kiss levels of cringe high-school-boy behavior, from braggy locker-room fantasies to Xander’s “I swear I’m cool” meltdown, proving teenage hormones are almost as dangerous as giant mantis talons. Plus: Buffy’s bat-sonar science moment and that egg-cluster stinger ending that absolutely says “this isn’t over”… even though thankfully, it kind of is. Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 5: Never Kill a Boy on the First Date before next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
28 Oct 2025
Witch — Buffy’s First Real Monster (Kinda)
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re stirring up trouble with Witch, where Buffy faces her first taste of magic, mother–daughter drama, and a truly cursed cheer squad. We break down the episode scene by scene, unpack Sunnydale High’s new brand of chaos, and ask the important questions—like how far would you go to make varsity? It’s our spellbound play-by-play of Buffy’s first real monster (kinda) and one seriously overbearing mom with a talent for possession. Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 4: Teacher’s Pet to get ready for next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
21 Oct 2025
The Harvest… and the Last We Hear of Jesse
This week on Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast, we’re diving fang-first into The Harvest, where Buffy faces her first big test as Sunnydale’s resident Slayer. We break down the episode scene by scene, relive the Bronze’s worst night ever, and ask the important questions—like how everyone just forgot about Jesse. It’s our slightly chaotic play-by-play of Buffy’s first real showdown and the mysterious vanishing act of one very unlucky friend. Watch the video version on YouTube for extra clips and visuals, and follow us on socials to keep up with new episodes, behind-the-scenes chaos, and all things Buffy. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 3: Witch to get ready for next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays) Clips from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (© 20th Century Fox Television) are used under fair use for commentary, criticism, and educational discussion. All rights belong to their respective owners.
14 Oct 2025
Welcome to the Hellmouth – and Our Podcast
In our very first episode, hosts Mike & Manny step into Sunnydale to kick off our Buffy the Vampire Slayer rewatch! We’ll introduce ourselves, share why Buffy still slays decades later, and give you a taste of what’s to come — from campy chaos and heartfelt moments to deep dives into demons, destiny, and drama. Then we dive into “Welcome to the Hellmouth” — where Buffy’s fresh start in Sunnydale High takes a deadly turn, and the Scooby Gang’s story begins. Slay along with us every Tuesday! Watch Episode 2: The Harvest to get ready for next week — and until next Tuesday, if the apocalypse comes, beep us! Website: BuffyTuesdays.com (http://BuffyTuesdays.com) YouTube: youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast (https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTuesdayPodcast?sub_confirmation=1) TikTok: tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays (http://tiktok.com/@buffytuesdays) Instagram: instagram.com/buffytuesdays (http://instagram.com/buffytuesdays)
Contact Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast
- Guest appearances
- Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Must Be Tuesday: A Buffy Podcast?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show
Podcast research with Pod Engine