Three Improv Duos. Two Lines. Endless Possibilities.
What happens when three pairs of improvisers are given the exact same opening lines, but have no idea what they, or their partners, are about to say?
In every episode of Mutterfly, host Don Fanelli throws three improv duos immediately into the deep end. Starting with the same two scripted lines, each pair must improvise their way to a conclusion. The result? Three "Mutters" with wildly different, hilarious, and unpredictable outcomes.
It’s a high-wire improv comedy experiment where the only thing guaranteed is that no two scenes will ever be the same.
Follow the Mutters on Instagram: @mutterflythepod
SEASON 1 FINALE!
In our Season 1 Finale, we explore a porno scenario that does not meet expectations, a friend-to-friend confession, and a disturbing family funeral.
Mutter 1: Jeff Hiller + Lauren Lapkus
Mutter 2: Craig Cackowski + Ben Rodgers
Mutter 3: Paul Scheer + Rob Huebel
Want to submit your own First Two Lines?
Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com (mailto:mutterflythepod@gmail.com) or
DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod
Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly!
Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!
6 Aug 2026
Yo, How Many Pushups Can You Do?
In this episode, we explore the complicated relationships of two best friends, two lovers, and three weird-ass neighbors.
Mutter 1: Benjamin Apple + James Dwyer
Mutter 2: Johnny McNulty + Katie Marovitch
Mutter 3: Billy Merritt + Shannon O'Neill
Want to submit your own First Two Lines?
Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com (mailto:mutterflythepod@gmail.com) or
DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod
Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly!
Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!
30 Jul 2026
I'm 355 Years Old, Today
In this episode, we explore the absolute worst "friend," a prankster grandma, and an old zombie mummy who can't eat or drink.
Mutter 1: Tao Yang + Jake Cornell
Mutter 2: Greg Tuculescu + Hillary Anne Matthews
Mutter 3: Sarah Claspell + Beth Appel
Want to submit your own First Two Lines?
Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com (mailto:mutterflythepod@gmail.com) or
DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod
Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly!
Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
14 ratings
Spotify
5.0 / 5
4 ratings
Contact Mutterfly
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Mutterfly?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
