Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner, co-owners and co-hosts of the Gerstner Adam Law podcast, discuss their backgrounds and the formation of their law firm. Both grew up in Billings, Montana, and attended the University of Montana Law School. Colin, inspired by a history professor, pursued law to help people, focusing on personal injury. Paul, with a background in criminal prosecution, specializes in workers’ compensation. They formed their firm in 2020, initially operating from a small office, and now offer comprehensive legal services under one roof. The podcast aims to address common legal misconceptions and community questions
Trial by Social Media: Lindsay Clancy, the McDonald’s Coffee Case & What the Public Misses
In this episode of Off the Record, Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner examine how high-profile court cases can take on a very different life once they move from the courtroom to television, social media, and public commentary. Using the Lindsay Clancy murder trial and the famous McDonald's hot coffee case as examples, they discuss the gap between the evidence jurors actually hear and the short clips, headlines, and narratives the public often sees.
The conversation covers the burden of proof in criminal cases, hung juries and mistrials, motions in limine, mental-health defenses, compensatory and punitive damages, and comparative negligence. Paul and Colin also revisit the facts behind Stella Liebeck's McDonald's lawsuit, including the severity of her burns and the jury's finding that she shared some responsibility for the accident. Their larger point is that a viral clip or simplified headline rarely captures the legal issues, admissible evidence, and hours of testimony that shape an actual trial—and that understanding the legal process requires more than reacting to the most shareable moment.
18 Sept 2026
From Loss to Legacy: The Story of the Ramsey Keller Memorial
In this episode of Off the Record, Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner sit down with Jeff and Cory Keller to share the story behind the Ramsey Keller Memorial.
Jeff and Cory begin with the story of how they met, their marriage, their three sons, and the decision to grow their family again. In November 2011, their daughter Ramsey was born with hydrops fetalis and spent two days in the NICU before passing away.
As Jeff and Cory worked through their grief, one experience stayed with them: Cory's father had paid for Ramsey's funeral, allowing them to make decisions about honoring their daughter without worrying about the cost. Realizing that many grieving families don't have that same financial freedom led them to create the Ramsey Keller Memorial.
Today, the memorial helps Montana families with funeral expenses following the loss of a baby and provides support to parents navigating an unimaginable time. Jeff and Cory discuss the families they've met, the role their faith has played in their journey, and the community that has helped the organization grow.
They also share the stories behind fundraising events including Run for Heaven's Sake, the Pink Tie Affair, the annual $23 November campaign honoring Ramsey's November 23 birthday, and the memorial's golf tournament.
The episode closes on a lighter note as Jeff and Cory face off in a competitive round of Taylor Swift, baseball, and golf trivia—with Cory ultimately taking the win.
17 Aug 2026
Answering Your Legal Questions: Workers’ Comp, Car Accidents & Montana Law
In this special Q&A episode of Off the Record, attorneys Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner answer legal questions submitted by their Facebook community. The discussion covers what employers should know about Montana workers' compensation, common myths about representing yourself in injury claims, and what to do immediately after a car accident to protect your legal rights. They also dive into Montana's ongoing debate over corner crossing and public land access, discuss First Amendment rights, and share resources available for people who need legal assistance but can't afford an attorney. Along the way, the episode includes a few lighthearted stories, audience interactions, and a reminder that no question is too small when it comes to understanding your legal rights.
16 Jul 2026
How Family Service Is Fighting Hunger & Homelessness in Yellowstone County
In this episode of Off the Record, Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner welcome Ryan Creamer, Executive Director of Family Service, to discuss the growing need for food assistance, housing support, and poverty relief throughout Yellowstone County. Ryan shares how Family Service provides far more than a traditional food pantry, offering grocery-style food shopping, rent and utility assistance, educational scholarships, clothing, and other critical resources that help families regain stability. The conversation also addresses common misconceptions about those seeking assistance, highlights the challenges facing working families and seniors, and explores how community volunteers, donations, and local partnerships make Family Service's mission possible. Ryan also shares his passion for Billings, nonprofit leadership, local restaurants, and community involvement in a fun rapid-fire segment.
22 Jun 2026
Teen Drivers, Child Injury Claims & What Every Parent Should Know
In this episode of Off The Record, attorneys Paul Adam and v discuss two important topics that many parents don't think about until it's too late: insuring teenage drivers and handling injury claims involving children. They explain why parents must add teen drivers to their insurance policies, the risks of household exclusions, and when parents may be held liable for a child's actions behind the wheel. The conversation also explores how injury claims work when a minor is hurt in a car accident, including settlement approval requirements, conservatorships, structured settlements, and the legal protections designed to ensure compensation is managed in the child's best interest. The episode provides practical guidance for families navigating the legal and financial complexities that can arise when children are involved in motor vehicle accidents.
15 Jun 2026
Meet Billings’ Most Valuable Pupil: Rory Whisenhunt
In this special episode of Off The Record Podcast, Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner welcome Rory Whisenhunt, the recipient of the Billings Most Valuable Pupil (MVP) award. Selected from a group of outstanding students recognized for their achievements in academics, athletics, and community involvement, Rory shares his experiences as a student at Billings Senior High, a Legion baseball player, and a dedicated learner with aspirations for the future. The conversation highlights the value of hard work, discipline, education, and youth sports, while also offering a fun look at Rory’s personality through rapid-fire questions about baseball, fishing, favorite foods, and life as a high-achieving student.
14 May 2026
Hurt at Work? Understanding Workers’ Comp, Occupational Disease & Employee Rights
Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner discuss unforeseen issues in work-related injuries, emphasizing the importance of reporting occupational diseases promptly. They explain the distinction between acute injuries and occupational diseases, noting that the latter often lack a specific date of injury. Paul highlights the significance of the MRI date as the injury date and the 30-day notice period. They also address employer retaliation, noting that employees can file claims directly with the Department of Labor if employers are uncooperative. The conversation includes strategies for mitigating damages and handling wrongful termination cases, as well as their personal summer plans.
16 Apr 2026
Inside Montana’s Courts with Judge Amy Eddy
In this episode of Off The Record with Gerstner Adam Law, hosts Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner interview Montana Supreme Court candidate Amy Eddy, a current district court judge in Flathead County. Eddy shares her background, including her upbringing in Stanley, Idaho, and her legal career, which includes 15 years of private practice and over 10,000 cases as a district court judge. She discusses the responsibilities of district court judges, the rarity of jury trials in civil cases, and the importance of lawyers preparing clients for court. Eddy emphasizes her commitment to nonpartisan judicial elections and her extensive experience, which she believes qualifies her for the Supreme Court. She also addresses the role of the Supreme Court in reviewing trial court decisions and the importance of public participation in government decisions.
30 Mar 2026
AI vs. Lawyers: Personal Injury Cases
In this episode of Off the Record with Gerstner Adam Law, host Paul Adam and co-host Colin Gerstner break down how AI tools like ChatGPT are changing the legal landscape—especially for personal injury cases. They discuss where AI can be helpful, where it falls short, and why having an experienced attorney still matters when dealing with insurance companies and complex claims. If you’ve ever wondered whether you can rely on AI for legal advice, this episode gives you the real answer.
24 Feb 2026
Pre-Litigation vs. Mediation: How Injury Cases Really Get Resolved
In this episode of Off The Record with Gerstner Adam Law, Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner talk about how injury cases can settle in very different ways—sometimes before a lawsuit is ever filed, and sometimes only after formal litigation and mediation. They explain why insurance companies often lowball injured people who try to handle claims on their own, why early legal guidance matters, and how personal injury and workers’ compensation claims differ in Montana. The episode also includes some lighter moments with stories about dancing, karaoke, and one unforgettable Michael Jackson dance contest.
2 Feb 2026
How Gerstner Adam Law Came to Be
Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner, co-owners and co-hosts of the Gerstner Adam Law podcast, discuss their backgrounds and the formation of their law firm. Both grew up in Billings, Montana, and attended the University of Montana Law School. Colin, inspired by a history professor, pursued law to help people, focusing on personal injury. Paul, with a background in criminal prosecution, specializes in workers' compensation. They formed their firm in 2020, initially operating from a small office, and now offer comprehensive legal services under one roof. The podcast aims to address common legal misconceptions and community questions.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
3 ratings
Contact Off the Record
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Off the Record?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
