Overreaction Buffalo

About Overreaction Buffalo

Overreaction Sports is the premier Buffalo Bills-based podcast, bringing fans closer to the game than ever before. Featuring two former Buffalo Bills players, John Fina and Jerry Ostroski, the show delivers unmatched insider knowledge, expert analysis, and behind-the-scenes stories straight from the trenches. Hosted by long-time Bills season ticket holder and passionate fan Joe Miller, Overreaction Sports blends professional insight with authentic fan perspective, creating a one-of-a-kind experience for the Bills Mafia. Whether breaking down game strategy, sharing locker room tales, or debating hot-button topics, John, Jerry, and Joe deliver content you won’t find anywhere else. From pre-game previews and post-game reactions to weekly Beat Reporter interviews, Overreaction Sports isn’t just a podcast—it’s a community for diehard Buffalo Bills fans who crave depth, honesty, and the ultimate connection to their team.

Publisher

Bleav, www.overreactionbuffalo.com

Category

sports

Language

en

Explicit

No

First episode

10 Oct 2019

Latest episode

23 Oct 2026

Latest episodes

617 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   23 Oct 2026

   BILLS BYE WEEK |Mafia BPA

   Jim and Owen discuss the opening of the season for Josh Allen and James Cook. Randall Slifer and Jerry Ostroski join the conversation. #BILLS #BillsMafia #BuffaloBills #BillsNation #BillsNews #JoshAllen #dailynews ______________________________________________ https://overreactionbuffalo.com Follow us on Twitter: https:// twitter.com/OverreactionBuf Follow us on IG: https://Instagram.com/OverreactionBuf Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@OverreactionBuf Follow Joe Miller on Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/@joemillerwired Watch Joe on the Overreaction Postgame Show, Off Tackle with John Fina and Hump Day Hotline (Homage affiliate link https://homage.sjv.io/AWLzQo) Follow Jerry Ostroski on Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/@Ostroski_BigO Watch Jerry on the BIG O Show, Overreaction Postgame Show, and On the Beat Follow John Fina on Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/@JohnFina Watch John on the Off Tackle with John Fina Show and the Overreaction Postgame Show Find all the Overreaction Buffalo Sports web content at https://overreactionbuffalo.com and https://linktr.ee/OverreactionBuffalo Overreaction Discord Community- https://discord.gg/mHsCMqf8 Be sure to subscribe to stay up to date on all of the Overreaction Buffalo shows! Follow our entire catalogue: Apple Podcasts- https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/overreaction-buffalo/id1483075570 www.fanduel.com

2. 

   22 Oct 2026

   BILLS ENTER BYE 5-1 BUT ARE THINGS ALL GOOD? | Overreaction Sports Report

   The Buffalo Bills are 5-1 and heading into their BYE WEEK! But are the BILLS as good as their record suggests? On this episode of the Overreaction Buffalo Sports Report, the guys take a deep dive into the Buffalo Bills' first six games of the 2026 NFL season as Josh Allen, Joe Brady, and company get a much-needed break before the second half of the season. Despite sitting at 5-1, the Bills have plenty of questions to answer. Is the offense operating at its full potential under Joe Brady? Has Jim Leonhard's defense shown enough improvement to make Buffalo a legitimate Super Bowl contender? And what weaknesses could come back to haunt the Bills when the competition gets tougher? The Bills have put themselves in a strong position, but 5-1 doesn't mean there isn't room for improvement! Join the conversation as we separate reality from OVERREACTION and debate whether this Buffalo Bills team has what it takes to bring a Lombardi Trophy to Western New York! #BuffaloBills #BillsMafia #JoshAllen #JoeBrady #NFL2026 #BillsByeWeek #GoBills #SuperBowl #BrandonBeane #JimLeonhard #BuffaloBillsNews #NFLFootball #OverreactionSports #BillsFootball #NFLTradeDeadline Follow us on Twitter: https:// twitter.com/OverreactionBuf Follow us on IG: https://Instagram.com/OverreactionBuf Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@OverreactionBuf Find all the Overreaction Buffalo Sports web content at https://overreactionbuffalo.com and https://linktr.ee/OverreactionBuffalo Overreaction Discord Community- https://discord.gg/mHsCMqf8 Be sure to subscribe to stay up to date on all of the Overreaction Buffalo shows! Follow our entire catalogue: Apple Podcasts- https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/overreaction-buffalo/id1483075570 www.fanduel.com

3. 

   21 Oct 2026

   Rivals at the Table Week 7 | OVERREACTION BUFFALO

   #MiamiDolphins #FinsUp #BillsMafia #NewYorkJets #TakeFlight #NewEnglandPatriots #ForeverNE Week 7 (October 22–26, 2026) brings a divisional clash between two struggling East teams, a Thursday Night Football road test for the Patriots, and a bye for the Bills. Records entering the stretch (as of early Week 5) had the Bills at 3-1, Patriots 2-2, Jets 1-3, and Dolphins 0-4; exact standings will shift with Week 5–6 results. The Buffalo Bills are on bye. Sitting atop the division early with a potent offense led by Josh Allen and James Cook under head coach Joe Brady (roughly 31.8 points per game), the break arrives after a busy stretch that included a Week 4 loss to the Patriots and a Monday night game versus the Rams in Week 5, plus a Week 6 road trip to the Raiders. It offers rest, injury recovery, and preparation time before resuming a schedule that includes a Week 8 home date with the Ravens. For Bills fans, the focus is maintaining the early lead and keeping the offense humming after the pause. The New England Patriots travel to face the Chicago Bears on Thursday, October 22, at 8:15 p.m. ET on Prime Video at Soldier Field. The Patriots (under Mike Vrabel, with Drake Maye at quarterback) enter the short week looking to build on recent form, including a Week 4 road win over the Bills. Their offense has been inconsistent (near the bottom of the league in scoring early), while the defense has been a relative strength. The Bears (around 3-1) present a solid home challenge. This is a national spotlight game for New England on a short week—key for keeping pace in the East and testing road resilience. The Miami Dolphins visit the New York Jets on Sunday, October 25, at 1:00 p.m. ET on CBS at MetLife Stadium. This is a critical divisional matchup between the two bottom teams. The Dolphins (0-4 under Jeff Hafley and Malik Willis) have been historically bad offensively (dead last in scoring at about 11.5 PPG) and use the game as their first after a Week 6 bye. The Jets (1-3 under Aaron Glenn, with Geno Smith, Breece Hall, and Garrett Wilson) have shown flashes but struggled for consistency after an early win over the Titans. Jets are slight favorites. Both sides need a win for relevance and momentum; a loss further entrenches either in the basement of the East. In short, the Dolphins-Jets game is the clear East centerpiece for ranking and positioning, the Patriots face a primetime road test, and the Bills rest while monitoring the division. The bottom of the East remains wide open for a spark.

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

YouTube views

292,245

Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025

Apple Podcasts (US)

5.0 / 5

2 ratings

Podcast Authority Score: 44 / 100

A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.

Quality

54

Social presence

0

YouTube

86

Engagement

0

Contact Overreaction Buffalo

Guest appearances

Does not typically book guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.

Shows with a similar audience

• 

  Shout! A football podcast on the Buffalo Bills with Matt Parrino and Ryan Talbot

• 

  Buffalo Plus: A Buffalo Bills podcast

• 

  It’s Always Gameday In Buffalo

• 

  Centered on Buffalo - for Buffalo Bills fans

• 

  Locked On Bills - Daily Podcast On The Buffalo Bills

• 

  One Bills Live

Questions about Overreaction Buffalo