Your weekly dose of hot takes, unfiltered opinions, and culture commentary. Ali and Alex are funny, messy, and brutally honest. Welcome to MomTalk After Dark.
pproblematic.substack.com (https://pproblematic.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast)
Mom Talk After Dark Recaps Secret Lives of Mormon Wives S5E2: Casting Drama, Taylor’s Split, and the Go-Kart Birthday Blowup
Alex and Ali recap Secret Lives of Mormon Wives season 5 episode 2 (“The Book of Dead Roses”) and discuss off-screen drama around the season’s release, including Mikayla Matthews announcing she’ll stop filming after the current season to protect her kids, and TMZ alleging Taylor Frankie Paul failed multiple drug tests and may lose parenting time. In the episode, Taylor says she called off her engagement to Doug after sleeping with Dakota and tells friends she’s in love with Ben, prompting advice that she should be single. Jesse’s storyline dominates as she gets angry that Chase plans to go to Sundance with Marciano, then the women crash Dakota’s go-kart birthday party to confront Chase, escalating into a chaotic group argument when the husbands arrive. They also cover Jesse regretting facial cosmetic work and getting an intervention, Layla telling Jesse that Chase called her hot, and a tangent on Connor being first voted off Dancing With the Stars.
00:00 Show Intro and Setup
00:12 Mikayla Quits and Season Drama
01:51 TMZ Claims and Taylor Concerns
03:12 Episode Two Begins Dead Roses
03:31 Taylor Calls Off Engagement
04:57 Reality TV vs Real Life
06:47 Jesse vs Chase Sundance Fight
07:33 Crashing Dakota Birthday Chaos
12:28 Marciano Relationship Updates
13:57 Jesse Plastic Surgery Regrets
15:32 Surgery Pressure Talk
17:15 Chase Needs A Spinoff
18:48 Connor On DWTS
23:17 Layla Tells Jessie Tea
25:25 Season Cast Uncertainty
26:04 Taylor Ben Bachelorette Fallout
28:07 Wrapping Up Episode
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit pproblematic.substack.com (https://pproblematic.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
13 Sept 2026
Wives Return with Stove- Touching Chronicles
Mom Talk After Dark: Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season Recap, Episode 1
Hosts Ali and Alex introduce their late-night podcast Mom Talk After Dark and explain they’ll recap favorite shows and mom-related topics, starting with the new season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives (released September 10) and covering one episode weekly for five weeks due to a shortened five-episode season they say was impacted by legal issues involving Taylor. They recap Episode 1 highlights: visible recent plastic surgery on Jessi and Layla; Miranda confronting Chase over hooking up with Shania while Shania stayed with Miranda, plus concerns about Chase’s DUI and co-parenting boundaries; Taylor’s chaotic relationship timeline, including getting engaged on The Bachelorette, sleeping with Dakota after returning, and discussing feelings for other men; Mikayla getting a medical marijuana card for chronic illness and noting shifting church attitudes; Jen’s ongoing conflicts with her controlling husband over her ambitions; minimal Whitney focus; and Taylor missing a foster care charity event before reconnecting with Miranda.
00:00 Welcome and Podcast Premise
00:47 Season Recap Plans
02:23 Episode One Setup
02:58 Plastic Surgery Talk
05:12 Play Place Drama Begins
06:21 Shania Hookup Bombshell
08:04 Chase Confrontation and DUI
10:13 Taylor and Dakota Chaos
10:37 Engaged to Doug Reveal
12:15 Cheating Admission Fallout
12:50 Taylor’s Messy Love Triangle
13:46 Mom Life Reality Check
14:38 Taylor’s Confession Fallout
15:32 Mikayla’s Med Card Trip
16:11 Church Rules Keep Shifting
18:16 Jen’s Big Dreams vs Husband
20:19 Whitney’s Quiet Episode
21:14 Taylor and Miranda Reconnect
22:10 Hypocrisy and Shania Drama
23:37 Next Episode Tease and Wrap
MomTalk After Dark is hosted by Ali and Alex find us at :
Instagram: @momtalk_afterdark
TikTok: @momtalk_afterdark
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit pproblematic.substack.com (https://pproblematic.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
2 Sept 2026
Mom Talk After Dark
Pretty Problematic Preps for Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 5: Utah Culture, Season 4 Recap, and Trailer Drama
Hosts Ali and Alex announce that The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 5 returns September 10 and say they’ll recap episodes weekly, answer viewer questions about Utah/Mormon culture, and potentially host local events and watch parties. They share their background as former LDS members in Utah who served missions and relate to the show’s themes and online “MomTok” drama. They recap Season 4: Taylor Frankie Paul’s on-and-off toxic relationship with Dakota, her conflict with her mom and church-based shame, the swinging scandal origins involving Taylor and Miranda, and other storylines including Whitney and Jen’s feud, Jesse and Jordan’s deteriorating marriage and rumored relationship with Marciano, and Mikayla and Jayce’s separation after a relationship that began when she was 16 and he was 21. They discuss the Season 5 trailer (more Taylor/Dakota legal drama, Jesse/Jordan tensions, Whitney in New York/Broadway, Miranda confronting Chase over a kiss with Jesse) and mention recent social-media drama about Layla and Mason’s breakup and comments from Mason’s sister, Chase, and Indy Blue.00:00 Welcome to Pretty Problematic00:23 Season Five Announcement00:51 Why We Relate01:35 Recap Vision and Plans04:01 What the Show Is05:22 Weekly Recaps and Events06:06 Season Four Setup06:42 Taylor and Dakota Drama09:39 Church Culture and Toxicity13:33 Other Couples and Side Plots16:32 Season Four Finale Cliffhanger18:45 Utah Is Too Small21:24 Season Five Trailer Tease22:01 Season Preview Breakdown22:46 Whitney Goes Broadway24:23 Friend Group Drama Rules26:19 Chase Kiss Fallout27:36 Chase Self Expression28:59 Utah Culture Pressure32:59 Layla Mason Drama35:18 Influencer Blocking Culture38:11 Haters And Boundaries39:18 Wrap Up And Next RecapsDon't miss out on anything Pretty!. Intstagram: @prettyproblematic.ana. TikTok: @prettyproblematic.anaPretty Problematic is hosted by Ali Askew and Alex Johnson. Instagram: @aliblaser / @alexandramariska. TikTok: @aliblaser / @alexandramariskaPlease write in your most Problematic stories/ confessions to:. ngl.link/prettyproblematic.ana. Or visit our Instagram and click the link in the Highlighted Story
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit pproblematic.substack.com (https://pproblematic.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
4.8 / 5
8 ratings
Spotify
4.6 / 5
9 ratings
Host of Pretty Problematic with Ali and Alex?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
