Relatively Insane Podcast

About Relatively Insane Podcast

Relatively Insane Podcast is what happens when two siblings hand each other microphones and just enough confidence to be dangerous. Join Natalie and Matthew as they dive headfirst into their latest obsessions, unpack current events with zero shortage of opinions, explore the strange and fascinating world of true crime, and occasionally derail the conversation with some top-tier sibling bickering. From deep dives and hot takes to random tangents and questionable life advice, no topic is safe and no disagreement stays settled for long.

Publisher

Relatively Insane Podcast

Category

society & culture

Language

en

Explicit

No

First episode

24 Jun 2026

Latest episode

30 Oct 2026

Latest episodes

20 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   30 Oct 2026

   The Most Unhinged Bucket List You Will Hear This Week

   Halloween costumes, sibling chaos, and a brutally honest round of “how well do you actually know me?” collide in this wildly funny Relatively Insane episode. If you love family roasting, ridiculous arguments, and the kind of oversharing only siblings can get away with, this one is for you.Natalie and Matt kick things off in full Halloween mode before veering into an argument over apologies, family favoritism, and who gets called the black sheep. From there, the conversation barrels through embarrassing childhood memories, hiking disasters, body-image jokes, and the debate over whether one sibling is actually outdoorsy—or just pretending to be.You’ll hear them break down: A brutal hike at Arches, complete with fear of heights, huffing and puffing, and a $30 national park reality check Why one sibling thinks every disability should come with free park access The Netflix remake of The Stanford Prison Experiment and why it missed the mark Halloween horror, The Strangers, Marvel movies, and excitement around Sunrise on the Reaping A hilarious sister-versus-brother trivia challenge that reveals who really listens, remembers the details, and can’t get away with lying Along the way, they reveal favorite foods, first cars, favorite seasons, unusual bucket-list dreams, and family grudges that are more fun to revisit when they’re being teased on a podcast. There are also strong opinions on Diet Coke, Pizza Hut, jury duty, mountain lions, and whether rollerblades belong near a school field.This episode is a lighthearted Halloween hangout full of real sibling chemistry, fast-paced banter, and enough inside jokes to feel like you’ve crashed the family group chat. Press play for laughs, nostalgia, and a reminder that no one in a sibling relationship is ever truly safe.

2. 

   23 Oct 2026

   The Utah Internet Mystery That Had Reddit Convinced It Was a Hit Site

   A bizarre Reddit rabbit hole, a courtroom meltdown, and a horoscope that may or may not be running your life. If you love true crime, internet mysteries, and sibling banter that spirals in the best way, this episode is your next listen.Natalie and Matt start with the usual chaos—hunting updates, Trunk or Treat, and the kind of sibling back-and-forth that somehow turns into a full-blown theory session. But things get more interesting fast when Natalie dives into a wild case of internet lore and hidden HTML comments that led people to believe a Utah web page was connected to real-world assassinations and contract killings.You’ll discover: Why the Lake City Quiet Pills mystery had Reddit and 4chan spiraling for years How a simple website, a vanished user, and cryptic page-source comments created an entire conspiracy What the Wayback Machine and digital forensics actually revealed Why Natalie thinks she would absolutely go down a rabbit hole trying to solve a crime How horoscopes, confirmation bias, and “the phone is listening” paranoia accidentally become part of the debate Along the way, the siblings argue over who talks more, who listens more, and whether Matt is actually paying attention to anything Natalie says. It’s funny, weirdly specific, and exactly the kind of conversation that makes this show feel like eavesdropping on your favorite family.Perfect for listeners who love off-the-rails storytelling, true crime-adjacent internet mysteries, and podcasts that can go from fart jokes to black-ops conspiracy theories without missing a beat.

3. 

   16 Oct 2026

   How a Family Tree Led to an Unexpected Polygamy Discovery and Halloween Movie Rankings

   Join us as we explore a wide range of topics from court cases and family history to favorite Halloween movies and personal anecdotes, all delivered with humor and curiosity. This episode offers insights into family connections, mental health, and seasonal traditions, making it a must-listen for fans of diverse conversations.

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

Spotify

5.0 / 5

4 ratings

Contact Relatively Insane Podcast

Guest appearances

Does not typically book guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.