11 Aug 2026
Ep. 23. It's Not Defiance. It's a Forecast.
It’s 7:40 in the morning. You’ve got twenty minutes to get out the door. One shoe is on. The other one just got thrown across the room, along with a flat, furious “I’m not going.” Maybe there’s yelling. Maybe there’s silence that feels worse than yelling. Either way, you’re standing in the hallway trying to figure out how a normal Tuesday turned into this.
Here’s the reframe I want you to have before tomorrow morning shows up.
“I don’t want to go to school” is not an opinion. It’s not an argument for you to win. It’s a forecast. Your kid’s nervous system has already run the numbers on what today is going to cost, and it’s handing you the result before the day has even started.
For a lot of neurodivergent kids, autistic kids, ADHD kids, PDA kids, sensory-different kids, anxious kids, that sentence isn’t defiance wearing a disguise. It’s data.
Think about what summer actually was for a kid like this. Not “less structure.” That’s the label adults reach for, and it misses the real thing. Summer was less unpredictability. Fewer transitions crammed into an hour. Fewer sounds and social rules and masking demands stacked on top of each other with no space to recover in between.
Then September arrives, and we ask that same nervous system to walk back into a building full of unknowns. New teacher, maybe. New room, new peers, definitely new expectations. Nobody hands that nervous system a syllabus. It just gets told to go perform a kind of regulation it hasn’t practiced in ten weeks.
So when the meltdown lands on the shoes, or the lunchbox, or something you can’t even name, here’s what’s worth remembering. It’s almost never actually about the shoes. The shoes are just the nearest exit ramp for a system that was already flooded, sometimes days before the first bell rang.
Once you can see it this way, the question changes. It stops being “how do I get my kid to comply” and starts being “how do I lower what this day is asking their body to pay.”
You won’t lower it to zero. That’s not the goal, and chasing it will wear you out. But you can change what happens in the moment the meltdown actually hits, and that’s worth more than it sounds like.
When it lands, you don’t need the perfect sentence. You need one move: co-regulation before conversation.
Something like this.
“Your body is telling me this is really hard right now. I’m not going anywhere. We don’t have to solve it this second.”
Say it low. Say it slow. And actually mean the last part, because here’s where most of us get it backwards. We try to reason with a kid before their body has settled, and it doesn’t work. Not because they’re being difficult, but because logic doesn’t land in a flooded nervous system. Yours or theirs. Connection lands first. The talking-it-through can happen after, not instead of.
Once things do settle, try not to jump straight into fixing it. Ask instead what part of today felt like too much. Even one word back is useful. You’re not just calming a moment down and moving on. You’re telling them that their own read on their own day actually counts for something, which is a different message than “I’ll handle it” repeated every morning for a year.
That’s the whole shift. It’s small on purpose. Small enough to actually use at 7:40 in the morning, when you have nothing left in reserve either.
If this is the kind of thing that helps, I go deeper on it, out loud, in this week’s episode of The Rewired Collective, including what this same script sounds like with a much younger kid versus a shut-down teenager, and what to do when you’re the flooded one instead of them. There’s also a fuller five-part practice for the week ahead in this week’s Sunday Shift, if you want more than one tool in your pocket before Monday.
And if you’re local to the Palm Desert area, I’m running an in-person class called Roots Before Results starting September 8th, built for parents who are ready for something that starts with the nervous system instead of ending there.
You can register at drdavidapalmer.com/roots. (https://drdavidapalmer.com/roots)
If a class isn’t the right fit for where you are right now, I also offer a free twenty-minute consult (https://store.drdavidapalmer.com/booking-calendar/rewire-strategy-call?utm_medium=page_links), no pitch, just a real conversation about what’s going on in your house and whether the resources I have could actually help.
Either way, you’re not doing this wrong. Their body is doing exactly what an overwhelmed nervous system does. You’re just learning how to meet it.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rewiredcollective.substack.com/subscribe (https://rewiredcollective.substack.com/subscribe?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_2)
