Love a good scream, but crave a fun theme? Join Katie and Tori as they talk about their favorite things: horror and themed parties. Come for the horror movie talk - stay for the party must haves. Whatever your subgenre, it's always a Scary Good Time.
Up Next: Season 2 kicks off in October!
After almost a full year with a varied roster of horror flicks and shenanigans abound, Katie and Tori are closing the chapter on Season 1 of Scary Good Time!
Gather 'round the bonfire with all the classic summer camp staples: s'mores, cozy sweatshirts, and murderous doctors! Jury's still out on that last one, but we can guarantee if you haven't seen this 2025 feature yet - you'll want to watch it BEFORE the episode to avoid being spoiled.
Bid farewell to summer with us in this season finale episode.
4 Aug 2026
In the Mouth of Madness
In honor of the late great Sir Sam Neill, Katie and Tori revisit one of his most iconic turns in cosmic horror.
On the way, they'll discover so many things! Auto-spawning dobermans, an incredibly sassy protagonist, and a healthy fear of the color blue. Get down with Sutter Cane for a party that'll make you go mad with excitement.
13 Jul 2026
I Know What You Did Last Summer
It's summer and you know what that means! Drinking, partying, running people over, getting away with murder... All the staples of a productive Fourth of July holiday.
For this festive and celebratory episode (happy birthday to Katie!), she and Tori dive into one of her favorite holiday horror movies. Get your Croaker crown and scepter, we're in for some rough waters and party planning.
30 Jun 2026
The Hunger
Night clubs! Sunglasses at night! Rapid aging! ...excitement?
For the first time in Scary Good Time history, we're watching a movie that's completely unknown to Katie and Tori! And boy, are the curtains fluttering and the David Bowies screaming.
Join us in 1980s New York City, where we learn to party the sexy vampire way. There may be some rare steak involved.
8 Jun 2026
Bone Lake
After some much-needed TLC, Katie and Tori are back from some "best friend counseling on hard mode..." Otherwise known as a viewing of Bone Lake. Will their friendship survive how aggravating some of these characters can be?
For that answer and some party shenanigans down at the lake, let's dive in and meet quite possibly Katie and Tori's favorite horror movie villains to date. And yes, you will probably judge them for that.
16 Mar 2026
Willy's Wonderland
Have you heard the good word of our lord and savior (and ultimate party reptile) Nicolas Cage?
For the first time on the podcast, Katie and Tori cover one of their favorite actors for an animatronic-walloping good time. Meet them in the Super Happy Fun Room as they plan a birthday party Hayesville, Nevada style.
2 Mar 2026
Cemetery Man
What goes better with zombies than existential dread and spaghetti? Scary Good Time's first guest host!
Join Katie and Tori and their wonderful friend Rachel as they stalk some Italian graveyards for some good ole fashion drapery kissin' and figure out the best way to party the Buffalora way.
3 Feb 2026
Nope
Who's ready for a rip-snortin' good time at Jupiter's Claim? Just make sure you don't look up...
Katie and Tori mosey back over to California to discuss Jordan Peele's "great American UFO movie" Nope and which horse games they'll be bringing to the party after.
17 Jan 2026
Unwelcome
Ring around the fairy ring, silly billies! Let's kick off the new year in style with your best trinkets and a plate full of liver.
This time, Katie and Tori go globe trotting with a trip to lush green Ireland in Unwelcome.
28 Dec 2025
Krampus
It's the most horrifying time of the year! The Scary Good Time holiday extravaganza is upon us - albeit fashionably late.
Join Katie and Tori in their customary fetal position under the tree in Mucho Mart as they celebrate the horror movie that gets them in the holiday spirit and ready for the Krampusnacht party.
13 Dec 2025
Ravenous
Beware, listener. Here, there be wendigos. And Robert Carlyle.
Get your pack and bourbon sippy cup ready. Katie and Tori are heading out to Fort Spencer to try out the local cuisine and groove to some funky music in this review of Ravenous!
29 Nov 2025
Thanksgiving
Carve up the step mom! It's time to get festive with everyone's favorite murderous viral sensation John Carver.
Katie and Tori dive into a comfort movie that Katie is super "thankful" for. Bring your side of choice, and let's discuss those party trimmings.
14 Nov 2025
The Faculty
School's in session. Party school, that is!
Katie and Tori enjoy a full course load of Meta Humor 201, Kick-Ass Soundtracks 103, and electives galore in Ew and Ow. Let's party with The Faculty.
31 Oct 2025
Trick 'r Treat
Season's greetings from your local Sam fan club chapter! We're ringing in Halloween with a viewing of one of Katie's favorite movies.
Get ready to party with the cutest little demon around. Just... don't blow out the jack-o'-lantern too early.
25 Oct 2025
Stay Alive
Get ready for an old school LAN party! And by old school LAN party... we actually just mean talking about deadly video games and vengeful spirits.
Plug in your controller and journey with Katie and Tori back to the early 2000s. It's time to... STAY ALIVE.
17 Oct 2025
The Mortuary Collection
Morticians, tentacles, and exploding weenies? Oh my!
Settle in with Katie and Tori as they recount the atoms, I mean... stories in this anthology. And stick around for a party that could wake the dead.
11 Oct 2025
Weapons
Let's throw caution to the wind and run with those "whee" arms free!
In this pilot episode, Katie and Tori talk about how the podcast works and how they'd throw a party even Gladys would have to crash.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Spotify
5.0 / 5
6 ratings
Host of Scary Good Time?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
