Shea It Ain’t So is the ultimate Mets fan therapy session—equal parts passion, pain, and pure Amazin’. Whether it’s a walk-off win, a bullpen meltdown, or just another bizarre chapter in Mets history, we’re here to laugh, rant, and ride it out with you. Hosted by die-hard fans who bleed blue and orange, each episode dives into the latest drama from Flushing, classic moments from Shea to Citi, and the eternal hope that this might finally be the year. Buckle up, Mets fans—it’s never boring, and it’s never easy.
🎙 Episode 17: Deadline Delivered: The Mets Are All In
David Stearns didn’t just make moves — he built a bullpen, upgraded center field, and kept the core untouched. In this episode, Jesse breaks down how Gregory Soto, Tyler Rogers, Ryan Helsley, and Cedric Mullins are the puzzle pieces that could push the Mets into October.
We break down the fit, the fallout from the Giants series, and what has to happen next for the Mets to make a serious run. The pieces are here — now it’s time to put the puzzle together.
30 Jul 2025
🎙️ Episode 16: Back in Business: Trade Deadline or Bust
🎙️ We’re back — and just in time.
After a 2-week hiatus (sorry for the silence — studio move took longer than expected), we’re jumping back in with Episode 16 at the most critical moment of the season:
⏳ 24 hours until the MLB Trade Deadline.
This episode is raw, honest, and all Mets:
➤ Who could be gone tomorrow?
➤ What should the front office actually do?
➤ Will the Mets make a move that means something — or play it safe again?
This deadline isn’t just about this year… it’s about setting the tone for everything that comes next.
Let’s break it all down — and thank you for riding with us during the break.
🎧 Episode 16: “Back in Business: Trade Deadline or Bust”
Now streaming everywhere.
18 Jul 2025
🎙️ Episode 15: David Wright Forever – The Captain & The Second Half Begins FEA
In this emotional and electric episode of Shea It Ain’t So, we kick off the second half of the season with a tribute like no other — it’s David Wright weekend, and we’re going all in. From his enshrinement into the Mets Hall of Fame to his iconic No. 5 being immortalized at Citi Field, we share a never-before-told story about The Captain that’ll hit you right in the heart.
But that’s not all…
The second half starts now — and it’s Mets vs. Everybody. The league’s sleeping. The media’s doubting. The noise is loud. But this team’s not backing down.
It’s FEA — F*ck Em All.
9 Jul 2025
🎙️ Episode 14: Soto Snubbed, Core 4 Ignites, and the Mets Take the Subway
The league lit a fire under Juan Soto by snubbing him from the All-Star Game — and he’s already making them regret it. We break down how this snub could fuel a historic second half. Plus, the Mets win the Subway Series, taking 2 of 3 from the Yankees, and we dive into last night’s electric extra-inning win led by the Core 4: Nimmo, Alonso, Lindor, and Soto.
We’ve got energy, fire, and a full preview of tonight’s matchup. Queens is heating up — don’t miss this one.
1 Jul 2025
🎙️Episode 13: June Swoon & Trade Tune – Time to Panic?
The hosts of Shea It Ain't So analyze the Mets' June struggles, rotation issues, and bullpen concerns, determining if it's time to panic and if David Stearns should make trade moves.
23 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 12: In Stearns & Cohen We Trust!
The hosts discuss the New York Mets' recent struggles and express faith in Steve Cohen and David Stearns to improve the team before the trade deadline.
21 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 11 : The Turning Point? Why the Mets' Losing Streak Could Be a Blessing in Disguise!
The hosts of "Shea It Ain't So" analyze the Mets' recent losing streak, suggesting it may catalyze necessary changes and influence David Stearns' trade deadline strategy, potentially revitalizing the team.
18 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 10: Cracks in the Foundation: Mets Swept, Pitching Slips, Time for bats to carry!
The hosts of "Shea It Ain't So" analyze the New York Mets' recent struggles, including pitching regression and underperforming bats, while considering potential impacts of returning players and trade rumors.
13 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 9: Uncle Steve’s Birthday Bash — Mets Stay Hot & CTC in Full Effect
The hosts discuss the New York Mets' winning streak, Steve Cohen's leadership, and key players' performance, highlighting the team's cultural transformation and rising expectations.
9 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 8: Road Warriors: Mets Go 8-2 Out West
The hosts discuss the New York Mets' successful 8-2 road trip, highlighting clutch performances and bullpen surprises, while previewing the upcoming series and debating team contracts.
6 Jun 2025
🎙️Episode 7: Michael Kay vs. Mets Fans: Defending the Orange & Blue + Dodgers Recap & Rockies Preview
Host discusses Michael Kay's comments about Mets fans, defends their passion, analyzes the Mets' series against the Dodgers, and previews the upcoming series against the Rockies.
4 Jun 2025
🎙️ Episode 6: Extra Innings & Even Stakes in L.A. + Mauricio Return
The hosts discuss the Mets' extra-innings games against the Dodgers and Ronny Mauricio's return, analyzing the implications for the team's roster and future performance in this interview episode.
2 Jun 2025
🎙️Episode 5: Sweep Relief, Hollywood Heat & a Soto Rant
The hosts discuss the Mets' recent series sweep against the Rockies, preview their upcoming challenge against the Dodgers, and rant about Juan Soto.
29 May 2025
🎙️ Episode 4: Sox Down, Rockies Up, and 10 Games No Rest
The hosts discuss the Mets' offensive struggles, analyze potential causes, and preview a challenging ten-game stretch against the Rockies and Dodgers.
27 May 2025
🎙️Episode 3: Walk-Off Drama, White Sox Series & the 2-Hole Debate
The hosts discuss the New York Mets' recent walk-off win against the Chicago White Sox, preview their upcoming 10-game stretch, and debate the ideal player for the second spot in the batting order.
26 May 2025
🎙️Episode 2: Mets Get Back on the Horse: Taking Two from the Dodgers
The hosts analyze the New York Mets' recent series victory against the Los Angeles Dodgers, focusing on pivotal plays and the team's strategy for maintaining momentum against the Chicago White Sox.
24 May 2025
🎙 Episode 1: Juan Soto's Living Rent-Free
The host discusses Juan Soto's impact on Mets fans and analyzes the upcoming Dodgers series, offering insights into key players and potential turning points.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
4 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 39 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
65
Social presence
0
YouTube
0
Engagement
32
Contact Shea It Ain't So
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Shea It Ain't So?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
