About Sorry For What I Said When I Was An Evangelical Teenager
Three ex-vangelical women finding humor in their trauma.
Margot, Alexa and Tuesday discuss deconstructing, cults, purity culture, religious trauma, and growing up in (and leaving) the evangelical church while finding ways to laugh about the horrors.
Tune in every Sunday for a new episode!
Please email us with your comments, stories, "prayer requests and praise reports" at: sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com (mailto:sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com)
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
Publisher
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen
Category
comedy · religion & spirituality · society & culture
Trick or Treat? Lucky number 13 is hitting the streets early so it makes it in time for Halloween!
Our final episode in the paranormal series is here!!! Though we’re so sad to see spooky season go- we’re ending it with possibly the craziest stories yet! Hosts Margo Rita, Tuesday Addams, and Alexa Pro discuss more paranormal encounters in the evangelical church that can’t be explained! We hope this series helps you feel seen and validated in any similar experiences and continues to open the conversation around the paranormal. HAPPY HALLOWEEN!
26 Oct 2026
Sorry Halloween's Just ACOTAR and Demons
Ready for more paranormal stories? In this spooky Halloween episode, hosts Margo Rita, Tuesday Addams & Alexa Pro discuss more experiences with the supernatural while still a part of the evangelical church. More church camp trauma, seeing unexplained entities, and "that really happened!" coming your way!
Let us know your thoughts on our experiences, and share any of your personal stories with us, too! Be sure to follow us on Instagram and TikTok for more fun content.
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
19 Oct 2026
Sorry For Telling You About Our Literal Demons (Take 2)
In this week’s spooky episode, hosts Margo Rita, Tuesday Addams, & Alexa Pro share stories of paranormal experiences during their time in the evangelical church. Each story opens a conversation around what can/cannot be explained & how the paranormal is viewed in the church. It also opens discussion around what we believe now & how our relationships with the supernatural might be different if not influenced by the church. We invite you to share your stories with us! Email us or dm us on instagram!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
17 Oct 2026
Sorry For Telling You About Our Literal Demons
In this week’s spooky episode, hosts Margo Rita, Tuesday Addams, & Alexa Pro share stories of paranormal experiences during their time in the evangelical church. Each story opens a conversation around what can/cannot be explained & how the paranormal is viewed in the church. It also opens discussion around what we believe now & how our relationships with the supernatural might be different if not influenced by the church. We invite you to share your stories with us! Email us or dm us on instagram!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
11 Oct 2026
Sorry For Dragging You To Hell On Halloween
In this episode, we talk about Christian Halloween alternatives that get progressively worse until they're significantly scarier than Halloween itself. Next week, we'll begin our paranormal episodes, so please send us your stories and become a part of the conversation!
We sincerely apologize for the audio issues in this episode. We did our best to fix them, but we weren't aware of them until post-production. We're actively working on fixing the input so that this doesn't happen again! We hope you'll join us for our first Halloween episode anyway.
Trigger Warnings: This episode discusses terrifying depictions of hell which we feel could be considered abusive to force children to go to, emotional abuse and religious coercion. Please listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, PARANORMAL RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCES this month, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*! You can also join us on instagram and tiktok for more fun throughout the week.
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
4 Oct 2026
Sorry For Trusting The Pastor pt2
This week’s episode is part 2 of our Predatory Pastors series. We received many listener stories about experiences with predatory pastors, so we thought it only right to read some on the pod and open up the conversation around this important topic. We hope hearing these stories helps you find connection, solace, and healing in your own journey and empowers you to continue to speak your truth.
As promised, here is a link to Jenna Dewan's Pony performance: Jenna Dewan-Tatum's "Pony"| Lip Sync Battle - YouTube
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
This episode includes depictions of sexual assault, sexual abuse, mental health being ignored and preyed upon, and traumatic experiences with church leadership. Listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, PARANORMAL RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCES this month, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
20 Sept 2026
Sorry For Trusting The Pastor pt1
This week’s episode starts and ends with our silly shenanigans and laughing about more hilarious evangelical church culture impacts. However, the main topic of this episode (and part 1 of a 2-3 part series) is predatory pastors. We received many listener stories about experiences with predatory pastors, so we thought it only right to read some on the pod and open up the conversation around this important topic. We hope hearing these stories helps you find connection, solace, and healing in your own journey and empowers you to continue to speak your truth. The reel played/shared on this episode is from Instagram user: @jubileedawns.
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
This episode includes depictions of sexual assault, sexual abuse, demonic possession, exorcism, mental health being ignored and preyed upon, suicidal thoughts, and traumatic experiences with church leadership. Listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
13 Sept 2026
Sorry For Praying Over Belly Rings At Hot Topic
This episode started with us watching and dissecting movies we were banned from watching and somehow quickly turned into embarrassing stories and discussion about mental health struggles in the evangelical church. Sorry it's a little all over the place! We hope you laugh along with us.
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
This episode discusses mental health and suicide. Listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
6 Sept 2026
Sorry For Kissing Dating Goodbye Pt2
In this episode, hosts Margo Rita, Tuesday Addams, and Alexa Pro share how purity culture impacted our lives while inside the church and after deconstructing. Laugh with us as we work to heal our trauma through sharing how the purity culture movement impacted our mental, physical, and emotional wellbeing, as well as our relationships. We hope you can relate, feel seen, know that you’re not alone, and/or laugh with us in our trauma. This episode is part 2 of a two-part series on purity culture.
TW: This episode discusses mental, physical, and emotional abuse. Listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
30 Aug 2026
Sorry This Cult Minisode Turned Out to Be a Maxisode
Well, we planned to keep you fed with another cult minisode until part 2 of the Purity Culture episode releases…but it accidentally became a MAXIsode! Sorry for talking too much about cults!
This week, host Tuesday Addams discusses the horrific but lesser-known cult, “Followers of Yahweh,” and host Alexa Pro joins to be the listener and learner about the group as well. Hang on to your trucker hats- this one is truly wild!
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
This episode discusses abuse, sexual assault, sexual assault on minors, & abuse of children and minors. Listen with discretion.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
23 Aug 2026
Sorry For Kissing Dating Goodbye
This week, we dive into one of the most culturally impactful movements in the Evangelical church- Purity Culture. This movement impacted us, our families and friends, and our whole lives while in the church and after leaving.
This topic is so vast, we felt it needed 2 episodes. In this episode (part 1), we aim to establish and define the purity culture movement and its impact on the young people in the church. And yep, we included contracts, True Love Waits, and purity rings.
In part 2, we’ll get more personal and share how it impacted each of us personally, but for now- we hope listening to us talk about it helps you feel seen and know that you’re not alone.
Please excuse our few audio issues in this episode. Either Tuesday needs a new mic, or we have a ghost. We don't really know.
As always, please email us with your thoughts, concerns, topic ideas, personal stories, *prayer requests and praise reports (hallelu--hallelu--halleluuuuuuujah)*!
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
16 Aug 2026
Sorry For Talking Too Much About Cults: Heaven's Gate (Minisode)
In this episode, we begin our minisode series that's all about cults! Alexa takes us on a journey into the Heaven's Gate cult that found its end in the late 1990s. God's Will, Bo Peep and UFOs? Count us in!
Tune in every Sunday for a new episode of Sorry For What I Said When I Was An Evangelical Teenager, where we discuss deconstructing, religious trauma, and growing up in (and ultimately leaving) the evangelical church.
Please email us with your comments and stories at: sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
10 Aug 2026
Sorry For Asking Too Many Questions
In our second episode, we attempt to play 20 Questions. We discuss our history as evangelical teens and experiences with magic, music, style, holidays and childhood amidst religion and religious trauma. During this, we give some insight into our stories and pieces of what led to us deconstructing and becaming ex-vangelical adults.
sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
3 Aug 2026
Sorry We Can't Stop Laughing
In this introductory episode, three Millennial women talk about some of our wildest experiences when we were involved in churches and some key reasons we began to deconstruct and become ex-vangelical.
We laugh, we cry (from laughing), we share our crazy stories, and we invite you to join the conversation.
Chat with us at sorry4beinganevangelicalteen@gmail.com
instagram.com/sorryiwasevangelicalpod
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
1 ratings
Spotify
5.0 / 5
3 ratings
Contact Sorry For What I Said When I Was An Evangelical Teenager
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Sorry For What I Said When I Was An Evangelical Teenager?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
