The podcast for everything you’re still not over—stories that stick, scenes that linger, and fandoms that never fade. Join us as we unpack the books, shows, and films that refuse to leave our hearts (or group chats).
This week on Still Not Over It, we’re skating into Heated Rivalry — enemies-to-lovers tension, aggressive eye contact, Daddy issues, and men with feelings. We unpack NHL fallout, questionable IRL romances, and the love story that hit way too close to home.
6 Dec 2025
Still Not Over The Perfect Neighbor
This week we’re covering The Perfect Neighbor, an intense documentary that drops us straight into escalating tension between Susan Lorincz and her neighborhood. Through unfiltered body-cam footage, 911 calls, and surveillance video, we unravel the story of Ajike ‘AJ’ Owens, a Black mother of four.
& you’re gonna need some tissues for this one.
16 Nov 2025
Still Not Over Bodies Bodies Bodies
We’re back in action this week with Bodies Bodies Bodies, an uber fun comedy/thriller that’s more ‘what HAPPENED’ than whodunnit.
If there’s one thing to take away from this one, it’s that sometimes the real danger is a group of friends who should’ve broken up years ago—but sure, blame the storm.
11 Oct 2025
Still Not Over Scream
Fall is in the air & we're taking a stab at the Scream franchise.
Neve Campbell’s trauma bangs? Iconic.
Tatum’s garage door death? Drag performance.
Ghostface? Mask4Mask with boundary issues.
It’s part whodunnit, part bloodbath, and somehow still a rom-com if you squint hard enough. Grab your voice changers and emotionally unavailable boyfriends—it's time to scream (literally).
22 Sept 2025
Still Not Over Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
Thought ‘The Incident’ at your high school was unbelievable? Listen to this:
It started as a classic high school catfish story — until the unknown number wouldn’t stop. Friends? Strangers? The whole town of Beal City? Or… was it coming from inside the home?
12 Sept 2025
Still Not Over High School Musical 2
Troy’s tan is fake, Sharpay’s wrath is real, and we’re emotionally sunburned from rewatching High School Musical 2. From kitchen labor drama to golf course breakdowns, we unpack the glittery fever dream that confused us all about capitalism, karaoke, and crushes.
& don't even get us started on the tariffs!
1 Aug 2025
Still Not Over High School Musical
Cliques are crumbling, Sharpay’s spiraling, and Troy Bolton shatters the mold with one question: "Did you ever think that maybe I could be both?"
Sing along while we examine the karaoke duet that dismantled an entire high school’s social structure.
25 Jul 2025
Still Not Over John Tucker Must Die
Hot, buff, and capable of inciting an all-girl smackdown?
This week, we’re talking John Tucker Must Die—the unholy lovechild of Abercrombie-era hormones and comically misguided feminist revenge.
Kate’s boob cam…testing…testing.
18 Jul 2025
Still Not Over Sweet Bobby
We promised stalkers—and Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare delivers a whole new frontier of creepy. This man will have you questioning everything. And Bobby's side of the story? Buckle up.
This one’s a doozy.
17 Jul 2025
Still Not Over Sierra Burgess Is a Loser
The year is 2018. You're over the endless parade of catfish getting exposed and dumped, so you greenlight a movie where the catfish actually wins the hot guy. Enter Sierra Burgess Is a Loser—the Netflix rom-com that asked, “What if catfishing was…totally fine?”
In this episode, we break down all the bad decisions, moral confusion, and plot twists that somehow got approved.
Spoiler: it’s a trainwreck, and we have thoughts.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8s33v0KbshI (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8s33v0KbshI) - Chicks in the Office Podcast with Noah Centineo
16 Jul 2025
Still Not Over Heathers
It’s 1989 at Westerberg High, and if you wanna fuck with the eagles, you better be ready to blow up the whole damn aviary. This week, we’re talking Heathers—the pitch-black cult classic that made murder fashionable.
Corn nuts, croquet, and a body count you wouldn’t believe—strap in, it’s gonna get very red scrunchie.
TW: This episode contains discussion of teen suicide, violence, eating disorders, and murder—as depicted in Heathers (1989). It’s a dark comedy, but the themes are real. Listener discretion advised.
4 Jul 2025
Still Not Over Tall Girl/Tall Girl 2
Tall Girl has the height, but not the depth. This week, we're unpacking how a body-positive narrative lost its footing in clunky dialogue, one-dimensional character arcs, and a tonal identity crisis.
We’re diving into the structure, the character logic (or lack thereof), and the streaming-era trend of surface-level empowerment. And no — we’re still not over it.
27 Jun 2025
Still Not Over OceanGate
Two years later and OceanGate is still living rent-free in our heads. This week, we watch Netflix’s Titan: The OceanGate Submersible Disaster and spiral right down with it. From questionable bolts to berserk billionaires playing DIY deep-sea explorer, we break down the breakdown—literally.
TW: Anglerfish Gate (yes, that moment is back).
14 Jun 2025
Still Not Over Pretty Little Liars
This week on Still Not Over It, we’re rewinding to the days of black hoodies, burner phones, and way too many secrets — yep, we’re talking Pretty Little Liars.
We discuss plot holes big enough to drive the Rosewood High bus through, 25-year-olds playing teens, and the fandom showdowns that lit up the internet. Come along as we revisit the twisty, over-the-top ride that defined a generation of teen TV.
Lindsay Shaw PLL Podcast with Tamin Sursok: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pretty-little-liars-true-crime/id1742652882Shaw Ned's Declassified Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/neds-declassified-podcast-survival-guide/id1669588163
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
2 ratings
Contact Still Not Over It
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Still Not Over It?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
