Every day, The BIG What If? takes one unforgettable moment, decision, injury, trade, rule change, or turning point in baseball history and asks the question fans can never resist: what if it had gone differently?
Hosted by BNN broadcaster Michael Grant, each episode begins with what really happened, changes one key event, and then follows the most plausible ripple effects through the rest of baseball history.
What if the Red Sox never sold Babe Ruth? What if Sandy Koufax had pitched five more seasons? What if Bo Jackson had chosen only baseball? What if the 1994 season had been completed? What if the Yankees had traded Mariano Rivera?
This isn't random fantasy. Every episode is grounded in the players, teams, circumstances, and realities of the time to explore the baseball history that genuinely could have happened.
In about 12 to 15 minutes, Michael takes listeners through the real story, the turning point, the alternate path, the consequences, and finally the BNN Verdict on how history most likely would have changed.
Michael Grant is a fictional broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly presented as possibility, not fact.
New episodes every Friday at 4 AM ET. One moment changes. Baseball history changes with it.
What If Ken Griffey Jr. Had Never Been Injured in Cincinnati? — Friday, October 16, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Ken Griffey Jr. Had Never Been Injured in Cincinnati?
What really happened: Injuries cost him most of 2001-2004
The one thing we change: The 2001 hamstring tear
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
9 Oct 2026
What If the Yankees Had Signed Greg Maddux in 1992? — Friday, October 9, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Yankees Had Signed Greg Maddux in 1992?
What really happened: He chose Atlanta instead
The one thing we change: The 1992 free agent winter
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
2 Oct 2026
What If Steve Bartman Had Never Reached for That Ball? — Friday, October 2, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Steve Bartman Had Never Reached for That Ball?
What really happened: The Cubs collapsed in the 2003 NLCS
The one thing we change: Game 6, eighth inning
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
25 Sept 2026
What If Josh Gibson Had Been Allowed to Play in the Majors? — Friday, September 25, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Josh Gibson Had Been Allowed to Play in the Majors?
What really happened: He starred in the Negro Leagues until 1946
The one thing we change: Baseball's color line before 1947
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
18 Sept 2026
What If the Expos Had Never Left Montreal? — Friday, September 18, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Expos Had Never Left Montreal?
What really happened: The franchise moved to Washington in 2005
The one thing we change: The 2002 contraction vote
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
11 Sept 2026
What If Michael Jordan Had Stayed in Baseball? — Friday, September 11, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Michael Jordan Had Stayed in Baseball?
What really happened: He hit .202 for Double-A Birmingham in 1994
The one thing we change: His 1995 return to the Bulls
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
6 Sept 2026
What If the Curse of the Bambino Had Broken in 1986? — Sunday, September 6, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Curse of the Bambino Had Broken in 1986?
What really happened: The Red Sox lost Game 6 to the Mets
The one thing we change: The ground ball through Buckner
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
5 Sept 2026
What If the Mariners Had Kept Alex Rodriguez, Randy Johnson and Ken Griffey Jr.? — Saturday, September 5, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Mariners Had Kept Alex Rodriguez, Randy Johnson and Ken Griffey Jr.?
What really happened: All three left Seattle within four years
The one thing we change: The 2000 free agency winter
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
4 Sept 2026
What If the Dodgers Had Stayed in Brooklyn? — Friday, September 4, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Dodgers Had Stayed in Brooklyn?
What really happened: Walter O'Malley moved the Dodgers to Los Angeles after 1957.
The one thing we change: A new Brooklyn ballpark gets approved.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
3 Sept 2026
What If Roberto Clemente Had Not Boarded That Plane? — Thursday, September 3, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Roberto Clemente Had Not Boarded That Plane?
What really happened: Clemente died in a relief-flight crash on December 31, 1972.
The one thing we change: The flight is delayed a day.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
2 Sept 2026
What If the Cubs Had Won the 1969 Pennant? — Wednesday, September 2, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Cubs Had Won the 1969 Pennant?
What really happened: Chicago led the NL East into September before the Mets ran them down.
The one thing we change: The Cubs hold on.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
1 Sept 2026
What If the Yankees Had Traded Mariano Rivera? — Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Yankees Had Traded Mariano Rivera?
What really happened: New York nearly moved Rivera in the mid-1990s before he became a closer.
The one thing we change: The trade goes through.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
31 Aug 2026
What If the 1994 Season Had Been Completed? — Monday, August 31, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the 1994 Season Had Been Completed?
What really happened: The players' strike wiped out the last seven weeks and the World Series.
The one thing we change: Labor peace holds and the season is played out.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
30 Aug 2026
What If Bo Jackson Had Chosen Only Baseball? — Sunday, August 30, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Bo Jackson Had Chosen Only Baseball?
What really happened: Jackson played both pro football and baseball before a 1991 hip injury.
The one thing we change: He never plays a down of pro football.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
29 Aug 2026
What If Sandy Koufax Had Pitched Five More Seasons? — Saturday, August 29, 2026
Today's what-if: What If Sandy Koufax Had Pitched Five More Seasons?
What really happened: Koufax retired after 1966 at 30 because of arthritis in his pitching elbow.
The one thing we change: Modern treatment lets him pitch through 1971.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
28 Aug 2026
What If the Red Sox Never Sold Babe Ruth? — Friday, August 28, 2026
Today's what-if: What If the Red Sox Never Sold Babe Ruth?
What really happened: Boston owner Harry Frazee sold Ruth to the Yankees after the 1919 season.
The one thing we change: Frazee finds the money elsewhere and keeps Ruth in Boston.
Michael Grant is a fictional BNN broadcaster created and voiced by Baseball Nation Network. The history is real; the alternate path is clearly labeled as possibility, not fact.
Everything Baseball. Every Day. Every Era. — Baseball Nation Network
Contact The BIG What If?
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of The BIG What If??
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
