Grab a flashlight, keep your tinfoil hat optional, and join us as we prove once and for all that the truth isn’t just out there; It's UNBELIEVABLY BELIEVABLE! It's the podcast that explores hairy humanoids, lake monsters, moth-men, mysteries, and conspiracy theories. No sacred cows, no gatekeepers -- just curiosity and critical thinking. Part campfire tale, part honest investigative research, all ridiculous fun. The truth isn't just out there; it's UNBELIEVABLY BELIEVABLE!
(Explicit Content) What started as a terrifying, spiny, reptilian monster sucking goats dry in 1990s Puerto Rico quickly became one of the world’s most infamous cryptids… only to morph into something far less glamorous. Join host Daniel Peck on Unbelievably Believable as he unpacks the bloody origins of El Chupacabra (yes, the “Goat Sucker”), the viral sightings that sparked panic, wild theories from aliens and escaped experiments to mangy coyotes, and why this legend refuses to stay buried.
From vampiric livestock deaths and armed hunts to shifting descriptions that turned nightmare fuel into disappointing diseased dogs—was it mass hysteria, nature’s desperation, or something still lurking? Daniel dives into the rabbit hole with humor, skepticism, and an open mind, asking the big question: Is the “cool” Chupacabra gone for good, or just hiding?
New website: www.UnbelievablyBelievable.com (www.UnbelievablyBelievable.com)
Subscribe for more cryptids, mysteries, and the unbelievably believable truth.
#ElChupacabra #Cryptid #GoatSucker #PuertoRico #Paranormal
2 Jan 2026
HUMAN SIGHTINGS!: A Rare Glimpse into the Habitat of Your host!
In this special sub-episode of Unbelievably Believable, host Daniel Peck pulls back the curtain on his own life with “Human Sightings” – a raw, personal look at the experiences that shaped his fascination with the unknown.
Join Daniel as he takes you back to his childhood on a secluded 7-acre property in the Texas Hill Country of the 1980s. Armed with nothing but a BB gun and boundless curiosity, young Daniel ventures into the thick cedar brush and comes face-to-face with a towering, filthy, long-necked creature covered in matted hair. Frozen in terror, he flees and later tells his mom he thinks he just saw. Years later, a jaw-dropping sighting from the safety of the family car provides stunning validation.
Through this deeply personal story, Daniel reveals why he approaches cryptid and unexplained-phenomena reports with empathy and open-minded skepticism. He shares the lingering fear of ridicule that kept him quiet for years, the relief of eventual answers, and the profound realization that honest eyewitness accounts deserve respect – even when the truth turns out to be stranger (or more mundane) than fiction.
This intimate episode isn’t about debunking; it’s about understanding the human side of mystery. Daniel urges listeners who’ve had their own encounters to stick to the facts, resist embellishment, and let the truth stand on its own. Human Sightings reminds us all why we keep looking into the shadows.
“The truth isn’t just out there… it’s Unbelievably Believable!”
Subscribe now and join Daniel as he continues exploring the mysteries that shape our world – and the people who experience them.
28 Dec 2025
Episode 4: Ape Canyon
What would you do if you and just 4 others found yourself in the middle of the wilderness under attack from 7 to 8 foot tall behemoths hurling boulders at you and your friends as you were forced to hunker down in a small log cabin and fight for your lives? During the summer of 1924, the lives of five miners would change forever when they faced this exact situation. In this episode we discuss the infamous, unbelievably believable Ape Canyon Incident/Battle of Ape Canyon; one of the most famous hairy biped encounters there is!
Episode note: This is the third version of this episode published due to some technical issues.
11 Dec 2025
Episode 3: Squatches Love Attention
Episode 3: Squatches Love Attention?
Today we talk about the legend of Bigfoot/Sasquatch/Skookums and the modern state of researching it. We also talk about some of the problems facing the research that's caused by those that researching them. Believers vs. Skeptics...
Either way, it's Unbelievably Believable!
9 Dec 2025
Episode 1: Introduction/Reptillians
(Explicit Content) Here's where it all begins. Episode one is more of a test of concept, but it may give you a disturbing look in to the future to come if you continue down the path of madness that might happen if it were to perhaps continue? Daniel Peck introduces himself and gives a brief take on a topic he adores. It's also a test of equipment... and maybe your patience? Who knows?
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
2 ratings
Host of Unbelievably Believable?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
