We Probably Shouldn't

About We Probably Shouldn't

Welcome to We Probably Shouldn't- a podcast where two friends talk about books, life, culture, relationships, the things that make us laugh, the things that make us think, and whatever else probably should've stayed off the record. From the stories we can't stop talking about to the real-life conversations that somehow go completely off the rails, we keep things honest, unfiltered, and unapologetically ourselves. We'll sit down with authors, narrators, creators, book besties, and other interesting people, while also having plenty of conversations that have absolutely nothing to do with books. No scripts. No filter. Just good conversations, questionable opinions, unexpected tangents, and the occasional moment where we look at each other and think, "ok...maybe we shouldn't have said that." So grab your drink, settle in, and come hang out with us. Because we probably shouldn't...but we definitely will.

Publisher

Lori Butler & Sam Talbot

Category

arts · society & culture

Language

en

Explicit

Yes

First episode

12 Sept 2026

Latest episode

9 Nov 2026

Latest episodes

8 episodes in the feed.

1. 

   9 Nov 2026

   Sip and Spill with Belmont

   Come hang out with us and the ever popular Belmont

2. 

   26 Oct 2026

   Episode 7: Bree Mina

   In this episode of We Probably Shouldn't, we sat down with Bree Mina to talk about her books, "Wrecked" and "Revived," and dive into the deeper emotions that make stories stay with us. This is more than a conversation about books. It's a mental health-aware episode where we open up about grief, loss, healing, and the complicated emotions that come with navigating life when everything feels a little too heavy. Some conversations are about the stories we read, and others remind us that we're all living through stories of our own. This one is a little bit of both. So grab your favorite drink, get comfortable, and join us for an honest, heartfelt conversation with Bree Mina. You might laugh, you might cry, and you might walk away feeling a little less alone. A GENTLE REMINDER: This episode touches on suicide, grief, loss, and mental health. Please take care of yourself while listening and give yourself permission to step away if you need to.

3. 

   18 Oct 2026

   Fallen for the voice, Feral for the man

   EXPLICIT CONTENT WARNING: 18+ ONLY! Things are about to get HOT behind the mic.We're sitting down with Fallen Scynclair, the spicy narrator bringing our favorite book fantasies to life, and let's just say this conversation is not for the innocent. From spicy stories to the man behind the voice, we're diving into the fun, the heat, and the conversations we probably shouldn't be having… but absolutely are. Listener discretion is advised. Headphones recommended. Innocence not guaranteed. Welcome to We Probably Shouldn't. Don't say we didn't warn you.

4. 

   11 Oct 2026

   Episode 5: Sara Furlong Burr

   This weekend on "We Probably Shouldn't," we're joined by the amazing author Sara Furlong Burr! We're talking books, writing, characters, inspiration, and what it's really like behind the scenes of creating the stories that readers can't put down. Come hang out with us for a fun, honest conversation full of bookish chaos, laughs, and a little bit of everything in between.

5. 

   6 Oct 2026

   Episode 4: Sir Chaos

   In this episode of "We Probably Shouldn't", we sit down with the one and only Sir Chaos for a conversation about embracing your true self, breaking the mold, and owning exactly who you are. We talk content creation, authenticity, and SO much spice. It's fun, honest,chaotic, and definitely spicy...just the way we like it.

6. 

   1 Oct 2026

   Beyond The Pages: Lucie Hagley

   In this episode, we're joined by Lucie Hagley, author of Condemned by Wrath, for a conversation about dark romance, writing, books and the women behind the story.

7. 

   18 Sept 2026

   Episode 2- Interview With Caiodi

   For episdoe 2, we're joined by the talented CAIODI for a conversation that goes beyond books. We're talking voice acting, behind the scenes stories, books, life, and all the random things that somehow come up when you put three people behind a microphone with absolutely no script. It's relaxed, unfiltered, and full of the kind of conversation that makes you forget you're recording a podcast. So grab your drink, settle in, and come hang out with us. Because, as always...we probably shouldn't.

8. 

   12 Sept 2026

   So...We're doing this?!

   We're finally doing this thing! Two friends. No filter. Questionable opinions. What could possibly go wrong? For our very first episode, we're talking about how We Probably Shouldn't came to be, diving into books, life, chaos, and conversations that brought us here. Welcome to the beginning.

Reach and audience

Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.

Apple Podcasts (US)

5.0 / 5

1 ratings

Contact We Probably Shouldn't

Guest appearances

Books guests

Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.