Welcome to the "What If?" Wrestling podcast, where we explore the hypothetical scenarios that could have changed the course of professional wrestling history.
Join our knowledgeable and passionate hosts as they take a deep dive into the most intriguing "what if" questions in the world of wrestling. What if the Montreal Screwjob never happened? What if CM Punk never left WWE?
Each episode, we'll examine a different scenario and provide insightful analysis and speculation on how the wrestling landscape may have been altered if things had gone differently.
SummerSlam 2025 Shocks & Surprises! Full Recap of Night 1, Night 2 & Raw Fallout | What If Wrestling
In this episode of What If Wrestling Podcast, we cover every jaw-dropping moment from WWE SummerSlam 2025 Night 1 & 2, and analyze the Raw after SummerSlam including returns, title changes, controversial finishes, and what it all means moving forwar
11 Jan 2025
"Roman Reigns & CM Punk Dominate WWE Raw's Netflix Era Debut!"
Roman Reigns and CM Punk deliver a thrilling performance in WWE Raw's Netflix debut, redefining the future of professional wrestling with unforgettable drama and historic moments.
29 May 2024
"What If CM Punk and Cody Rhodes Never Left AEW?"
What if CM Punk and Cody Rhodes never left AEW? In this episode of "What If Wrestling," we dive into the alternate reality where these two iconic stars stayed with All Elite Wrestling. How would their continued presence shape AEW's future? What dream matches and storylines might we have seen? Join us as we explore the possibilities and speculate on the incredible scenarios that could have unfolded!
#AEW #CMPunk #CodyRhodes #WhatIfWrestling #WrestlingSpeculation #ProWrestling
15 May 2024
Exploring Triple H's WWE Takeover What if
Triple H taking control of WWE earlier would have led to significant changes in the company, including the retention of talent, more creative freedom for wrestlers, and a different landscape in the wrestling industry. The influence of Stephanie McMahon and the creative vision of Triple H would have shaped the direction of the company, potentially resulting in the return of CM Punk and the emergence of new stars like La Knight and Gunther. #wwe #tripleh #whatifwrestling00:00 -01:09 🎵 Introduction and setting the stage for the "what if" scenario of Triple H taking over WWE earlier
01:10 -03:35 🤔 Discussing the potential time frame for Triple H's takeover and its impact on the company
03:36 -07:24 🌟 Speculating on the rehiring of talent and the potential return of wrestlers like Braun Strowman and Bray Wyatt
07:25 -11:44 ✨ Highlighting the positive influence of Triple H's creative vision and Stephanie McMahon's leadership
11:45 -14:32 💔 Analyzing the potential wrestlers who may have suffered due to Triple H not taking over earlier, such as Keith Lee and Sasha Banks
14:33 -18:22 🎯 Recognizing the emergence of new stars under Triple H's leadership, including Dominic Mysterio and Sami Zayn
18:23 -19:54 🔑 Highlighting the importance of Shawn Michaels in bridging the past and future of WWE and NXT
17 May 2023
What if ... Stone Cold Steve Austin had not retired in 2003
Join us as we dive into the electrifying 'What If' scenario of Stone Cold Steve Austin's career. Explore the untapped potential and alternate paths that could have unfolded if Austin never retired in 2003. Brace yourself for thrilling discussions and imaginative possibilities in the world of professional wrestling. Tune in for a captivating journey through the hypothetical realm of Stone Cold's legacy!"
(0:00:15) - Steve Austin's Retirement What-If
(0:06:46) - Hypothetical WWE Storylines
(0:14:49) - Stone Cold's Retirement and Dream Matches
(0:22:56) - Pro Wrestling Matches and Feuds
(0:37:02) - Stone Cold's Healthy Future
(0:48:16) - Fantasy Booking WrestleMania Matches
10 May 2023
What If... WrestleMania 1 had Failed
In this episode of the "What If Wrestling Podcast", we explore a scenario that could have changed the course of pro wrestling history forever.
"What would have happened if WrestleMania had failed?" is a question that many wrestling fans have asked themselves over the years. In this episode, our hosts dive into this hypothetical scenario and imagine a world where WrestleMania, the biggest event in sports entertainment, was a total flop.
Join us as we explore the potential outcomes of this alternate reality. Would Vince McMahon have gone bankrupt and sold the company? Would Hulk Hogan have left the wrestling business for good? And what would have happened to the careers of iconic wrestlers like The Undertaker, Stone Cold Steve Austin, and The Rock?
We analyze the possible ramifications of WrestleMania's failure and speculate on how it could have changed the landscape of pro wrestling as we know it. Whether you're a longtime wrestling fan or just love to imagine alternate realities, this episode is a must-watch for any fan of the sport.
So sit back, grab some popcorn, and let's dive into this fascinating "what if" scenario together on the "What If Wrestling Podcast"! #Whatifwrestling #Whatifwednesday
3 May 2023
"What if... CM Punk Not Left WWE in 2014?
"What if... CM Punk Not Left in 2014?" is an episode of the "What if Wrestling Podcast" that explores a scenario that had a major impact on the world of professional wrestling. In this episode, our hosts imagine a reality where CM Punk did not leave WWE in 2014 and instead continued to be an active wrestler in the company.
Join us as we delve into the potential outcomes of this alternate reality. Would CM Punk have become a multiple-time WWE Champion? Would he have had epic matches with the likes of AJ Styles and Seth Rollins? And what would have happened to the infamous "Pipebomb" promo that launched him into stardom?
We analyze the possible ramifications of CM Punk staying in WWE and speculate on how it could have changed the landscape of pro wrestling as we know it. Whether you're a die-hard CM Punk fan or just love to imagine alternate realities, this episode is a must-listen for any wrestling enthusiast. So tune in and let's explore this "what if" scenario together!
10 Apr 2023
Introduction to The What If Wrestling Podcast.
Welcome to the "What If?" Wrestling podcast, where we explore the hypothetical scenarios that could have changed the course of professional wrestling history.
Join our knowledgeable and passionate hosts as they take a deep dive into the most intriguing "what if" questions in the world of wrestling. What if the Montreal Screwjob never happened? What if CM Punk never left WWE?
Each episode, we'll examine a different scenario and provide insightful analysis and speculation on how the wrestling landscape may have been altered if things had gone differently.
21 Mar 2023
"What If... Bret Hart didn't go to WCW
"If Bret Hart Never Left WWE?" is an intriguing episode of the "What If Wrestling Podcast" that delves into a captivating hypothetical scenario. In this episode, our Glen, Nephew Corey and Champ Creed explore the alternate reality where legendary wrestler Bret "The Hitman" Hart never left WWE.
Join us as we imagine the potential outcomes and consequences of Bret Hart staying with the company. Would he have continued to be a main event player? What rivalries and storylines would have unfolded differently? And how would his presence have impacted WWE's Attitude Era and beyond?
We analyze the possibilities, speculate on how wrestling history could have been altered, and discuss the legacy of one of the most iconic figures in pro wrestling. Whether you're a longtime fan of Bret Hart or simply intrigued by "what if" scenarios, this episode is a must-listen for any wrestling enthusiast.
Tune in to the "What If Wrestling Podcast" as we unravel the fascinating tale of "What If Bret Hart Never Left WWE?" and explore the unpredictable twists and turns of this alternate wrestling universe.
21 Mar 2023
"What If... Kurt Angle Went to ECW not WWE?
"What If... Kurt Angle Went to ECW, not WWE?" is a thought-provoking podcast that explores an alternative history of professional wrestling. Hosted by knowledgeable wrestling fans, the show imagines a scenario where Olympic gold medalist Kurt Angle decided to sign with Extreme Championship Wrestling (ECW) instead of World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) in 1998.
Through in-depth analysis and commentary, the podcast explores what might have happened if Angle had joined the renegade promotion known for its hardcore style, edgy content, and rabid fanbase. Listeners will be taken on a journey that explores the potential impact of Angle's presence in ECW, including the feuds he may have had, the championships he may have won, and the influence he may have had on the future of the wrestling industry.
Drawing on extensive research and insider knowledge, the podcast delves into the nuances of the wrestling business and paints a vivid picture of what could have been. With lively debates and insightful commentary, "What If... Kurt Angle Went to ECW, not WWE?" is a must-listen for any wrestling fan interested in exploring the twists and turns of wrestling history.
21 Mar 2023
"What If...Kevin Nash and Scott Hall Never Signed with WCW?
In this video, we're discussing what would have happened if Kevin Nash and Scott Hall never went to WCW. Without their influence, the Attitude Era likely never would have started. So what would have happened? Who would have been the biggest stars in the industry? We'll try to answer all of these questions in this video!
21 Mar 2023
"What If... Sting Hogan and Goldberg, came over when Vince purchased WCW?
In this second episode of The What If Wrestling Podcast. "What if Sting Hogan and Goldberg, came over when Vince purchased WCW?" we explore the consequences of this unlikely event. In this episode, we explore the possible consequences of Sting and Goldberg coming to WWE when Vince purchased the company. We look at how history would have changed, and discuss the possible impacts on the business, the wrestlers, and the fans.
21 Mar 2023
"What If...Ron Simmons wasn't the first African American Champion?
In this video, we'll be discussing the hypothetical situation where Ron Simmons had not won the WCW world title in 1992. As the first African American World Champion, Simmons has had a large impact on the history of wrestling and the wrestling industry as a whole. Would the industry be different if Simmons hadn't won the title? Let's find out in this episode of What if Ron Simmons wasn't the first African American Champion?
What If Wrestling discusses what if Ron Simmons hadn't won the WCW world title in 1992? And the other possible African American wrestlers who could have been the first.
21 Mar 2023
"What If... R Truth became Champion at Capital Punishment in 2011
In this episode of "What if..?", we explore the possible WWE storylines that would have changed if R Truth had won the WWE Championship at Capital Punishment in 2011. From John Cena's heel turn to CM Punk's career, there would have been a lot of dramatic changes!
If you're a wrestling fan, then you need to watch this episode! It will also give you a better understanding of the WWE timeline and how important Capital Punishment was in 2011.
Who has been a guest on What If Wrestling Podcast
Names identified in recent episode analyses. Showing up to five guests.
Roman Reigns
CM Punk
Seth Rollins
The Rock
John Cena
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
10,740
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
2 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 31 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
20
Social presence
0
YouTube
72
Engagement
32
Contact What If Wrestling Podcast
Guest appearances
Does not typically book guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of What If Wrestling Podcast ?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
