What broke you made you beautiful. The cracks let the light in—but what if those cracks define your why? I believe what broke us is exactly what drives us to create, to keep going when everything feels impossible. I spent years searching for my why. When I found it, I realized it needed reinventing. This podcast is real conversations with writers, musicians, directors, actors, and creators about the fire that drives us, the fear that shapes us, and how both evolve. So what's your why? And are you brave enough to let it evolve?
Writing What You See: Pittsburgh Novelist on Craft & Persistence | Patrick McGinty
Patrick McGinty is a novelist, professor, and Pittsburgh writer who spent 13 years revising his second novel from a 1,000-page manuscript to a published book.
His journey is the opposite of overnight success. He got an agent young, sent out a massive manuscript, faced rejection after rejection. His response? "Great, I get to keep working on it."
We talk about the 13-year revision, his grandfather's advice to "draw what you see, not what you think you see," why he learns about places through art instead of guidebooks, the observational approach to writing, and what it means to be a regional writer in Western Pennsylvania.
We also dive into:
The best editorial note he ever got ("move everything up in your story")
Writing about driverless cars and tech in Pittsburgh
Being married to another writer
Teaching creative writing while being a working novelist
Why time is what he fears losing most
CONNECT WITH PATRICK:
Website: https://www.patrick-mcginty.com/ (https://www.patrick-mcginty.com/)
Purchase "Town College City Road": https://amzn.to/46MiA6P (https://amzn.to/46MiA6P)
This is What's Your Why, a podcast where creatives talk about imposter syndrome, fear, and what sets our souls on fire.
Remember, what broke you made you beautiful. Your story matters because you matter.
18 Jan 2026
All Your F*cks Disappear at 40 (And Other Truths) | Screenwriter Lauren Greenwood on Rejection
Lauren Greenwood spent over a decade as "just a screenwriter." No paid work. No qualifier. Just writing sample after sample, getting rejection after rejection.
Then she became a working screenwriter—three TV thrillers on Lifetime, awards, representation, commissions.
But here's what got me: imposter syndrome didn't leave her body until her fourth commissioned movie. Not the first. Not the second. Not the third. The fourth.
We talk about what it actually takes to make it as a writer. Not the overnight success story—the real one. The ten-year slog. The sample script she's worked on for over a decade that's been optioned twice, won awards, got her an agent, and landed all four TV movies... but will probably never be produced. And she's made peace with that.
This is a conversation about persistence, craft, and why loving the process is the only thing that keeps you going.
This is What's Your Why—where creatives and dreamers from all walks of life talk about imposter syndrome, fear, and what sets our souls on fire.
Connect with Lauren on Substack: https://lsgreenwood.substack.com (https://lsgreenwood.substack.com)
What broke you made you beautiful. Your story matters because you matter.
16 Nov 2025
Pastor JP Robles: When the Church Breaks You
Pastor JP Robles: When the Church Breaks You
"Christians are exhausting," says Pastor JP Robles' wife. He agrees.
This isn't your typical faith conversation. JP grew up in a Pentecostal church where his father was a pastor—until a public divorce shattered everything. He jumped off a roof at 16, lived in an old Holiday Inn, and discovered that music and creativity were his lifelines.
Now he's a pastor, priest, music producer, and filmmaker who believes God looks up at us from the bottom, not down from above. He has more in common with atheists and agnostics than religious fundamentalists.
We dive deep into:
How "third culture" shaped his identity
Surviving church trauma and his parents' divorce
Why creativity is the ultimate human freedom
How your words literally create your worlds
The intersection of God and the universe
Imposter syndrome as a creative and a pastor
Pain, addiction, fear, and running from yourself
What Jesus would say if he came back today
His "why": Finding joy in creating a new world
This conversation went places I didn't expect. Two hours of raw honesty about faith, creativity, and being human.
Connect with Pastor JP Robles: jonpaulrobles.com (http://jonpaulrobles.com) | @jonpaul.robles (Instagram) | Sacred Commons on YouTube | Companion Audio on Bandcamp
About What's Your Why: Real conversations with creators about the fire that drives us, the fear that shapes us, and how being broken makes us beautiful.
Hosted by J. Penberth (@jpenberthauthor)
And remember... What broke you made you beautiful. Your story matters because you matter.
8 Nov 2025
The Story That Drives Him: Donavan Clark on Passion, Perseverance, and Purpose
Donovan Clark left union grip work on Westworld and American Horror Story to make the films he actually cares about.
We talk about leaving stability for uncertainty, losing his father in 2020, and whether pain actually makes better art.
CONNECT WITH DONOVAN:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/donavanclarkdirector (https://www.instagram.com/donavanclarkdirector)
Website: https://www.donavanclarkdirector.com/ (https://www.donavanclarkdirector.com/)
Full Notion Media: https://www.fullnotionmedia.com/ (https://www.fullnotionmedia.com/)
TOPICS: Filmmaking | Leaving Your Job | Grief | Creativity | Finding Your Why | Independent Film | Career Change
FOLLOW:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jpenberthauthor (https://www.instagram.com/jpenberthauthor)
Substack: jpenberth.substack.com (http://jpenberth.substack.com)
What broke you made you beautiful.
#WhatsYourWhy #DonavanClark #Filmmaker #Podcast
12 Oct 2025
The Song That Saved His Life: Jacob Luttrell on Pain, Purpose, and Being a Superhero
Jacob Luttrell has written songs you know by heart—"Wild Ones," "Tonight (I'm Lovin' You)," "I Can Only Imagine." But the song that matters most? The one that saved his own life. In this raw, honest conversation, Jacob opens up about standing at the edge, the piano that brought him back, and why his real purpose is to help others feel less alone. We talk about pain as a creative valve, the danger of ego, killing your old self to evolve, and why everyone has the chance to be someone's superhero. This is what happens when broken becomes beautiful.
Contact What's Your Why?
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of What's Your Why??
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
