Welcome to “WTF Is That Podcast” – your wild ride through the weirdest and wackiest stories of the paranormal, urban legends, and true crime! Join Jen and Jess, best friends for 15 years, as they dive into the bizarre, the unexplained, and the downright hilarious.
Get ready for spine-tingling tales, mind-bending mysteries, and more laughs than you can handle. With their unique blend of curiosity, humor, and a pinch of skepticism, Jen and Jess explore the unknown in a way that’s both entertaining and enlightening.
From haunted hotspots and creepy urban legends to true crime cases you’ve never heard of, this dynamic duo brings you a mix of scares and laughs that will keep you coming back for more. Whether you’re a seasoned paranormal enthusiast or just love a good chuckle, “WTF Is That Podcast” is your ultimate guide to all things strange and spooky.
Prepare to question reality, challenge your beliefs, and join the hunt for the most WTF moments out there. Tune in every Wednesday and let the fun begin!
💀 A Stay That Got… Uncomfortable 💀
This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we packed our bags, grabbed our EMF readers, and checked into the Groveland Hotel—because we were invited to stay overnight and investigate one of California’s most haunted hotspots. Very chill. Extremely normal behavior.
From Gold Rush–era tragedy to whispered hallways and lights that absolutely did not need to turn on by themselves, this place has STORIES. And maybe a personal issue with us being there.
👻 A historic hotel with a body count and bad vibes
🕯️ Guest rooms that refuse to stay quiet
🧳 Personal experiences we genuinely cannot explain (and yes, we tried)
⚠️ Quick heads-up: the audio isn’t perfect this week. The Groveland is pushing 200 years old, with thick walls, creaky floors, and acoustics from a time before microphones were a thing. We did our best—but the ghosts and the architecture were not sound engineers.
If you think haunted hotels are just creaky floors and overactive imaginations… this episode would like a word.
🎧 Go hit play now! And be honest—would you spend the night here? 👇
🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast (https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast)
Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia
Producer: Jessica Mosely
11 Mar 2025
Episode 44: Remembering Caylee Anthony: The Casey Anthony Case
💀 The Trial That Shook the Nation 💀
This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we’re diving into the Caylee Anthony case—one of the most infamous true crime stories of all time. From Caylee’s mysterious disappearance to Casey Anthony’s shocking trial and acquittal, this case had the world watching in disbelief.
🕵️♀️ A missing child with a bizarre timeline
🛑 The 911 call that started it all
⚖️ A courtroom battle that left the nation outraged
If you haven’t listened yet… why not?! This is true crime at its wildest, and you do NOT want to miss it.
🎧 Go hit play now! And tell us—do you think the jury got it right? 👇
🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast
Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia
Producer: Jessica Mosely
3 Mar 2025
Episode 43: Elmer McCurdy
💀 The Wildest Post-Mortem Journey EVER 💀
This week on WTF Is That Podcast, we’re talking about Elmer McCurdy—the outlaw who was way more famous dead than alive. Seriously, this man went from failed train robber to carnival attraction, and his body was passed around for DECADES like some kind of creepy keepsake. 😳
🔪 A crime career that flopped HARD
🎭 A mummified corpse that became a sideshow act
🤯 The unreal way he was finally discovered
If you haven’t listened yet… why not?! This is prime WTF history, and you do not want to miss it.
🎧 Go hit play now, and tell us—what’s the wildest post-mortem story you’ve ever heard? 👇
🔗 Listen here: https://linktr.ee/wtfisthatpodcast
Hosts: Jessica Mosely & Jenny Garcia
Producer: Jessica Mosely
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
YouTube views
787
Score snapshot 15 Sept 2025
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
5 ratings
Podcast Authority Score: 57 / 100
A composite of feed quality, social presence, YouTube performance and engagement. Read the methodology.
Quality
59
Social presence
0
YouTube
66
Engagement
71
Contact WTF Is That Podcast
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of WTF Is That Podcast?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
