Your Pick, My Nightmare 🎃
Every week, Jade and a different guest dive into a scary movie—especially the ones one of them has never seen before. We talk horror, bad decisions, unexpected favorites, WTF moments, and everything that makes a movie stick with you long after the credits roll.
And because sometimes the soundtrack deserves its own nightmare, we’ll also have mini episodes where we listen to songs one of us has never heard before and see what happens.
Grab your snacks, pick your poison, and get ready for a little movie talk, a little music, and a whole lot of horror.
Episode 5: Music, Murder & Body Bags 🔪 | Nick Karcher
🖤 Your Pick, My Nightmare — Nick Karcher: Music, Murder & Body Bags 🔪🎶
What happens when horror movies and killer music collide?
This week on Your Pick, My Nightmare, we're trading screams on the screen for screams through the speakers!
Jade welcomes horror-loving musician Nick Karcher, while guest co-hosts Peaches and Helga experience his music for the very first time!
We're diving into the twisted inspiration behind “Body Bag,” the stories behind his lyrics, his love of horror movies, and the journey of finding his own sound. From slasher films and Stephen King to unforgettable first impressions, nothing is off-limits!
Can Nick turn two first-time listeners into lifelong fans? Or is this musical nightmare just getting started?
🎧 Featuring music by Nick Karcher.
🔪 Turn up the volume, grab your snacks, and welcome to the nightmare!
Follow Nick Karcher and stream his music on your favorite music platform.
Your Pick. My Nightmare. 🖤
3 Oct 2026
Episode 4 Fright Night (1985)
What do you do when you’re convinced your new neighbor is a vampire…and absolutely no one believes you? 🧛♂️
This week on Your Pick, My Nightmare, Jade and her guest sink their teeth into the 1985 horror-comedy classic Fright Night. We’re talking first-time reactions, ’80s vampire chaos, creepy neighbors, unforgettable characters, practical effects, and all the WTF moments that make this movie such a cult favorite.
Was it scary? Campy? Surprisingly good? Or an absolute nightmare?
Grab your snacks and join us for Fright Night (1985)! 🍿🩸
25 Sept 2026
Episode 3 Evil Dead 2 (1987)
Jade is heading into the cabin for the first time! 🩸🌲
This week on Your Pick, My Nightmare, Jade watches Evil Dead II (1987) for the very first time while her guest comes in as the seasoned survivor. We’re talking Ash, possessed hands, chainsaws, Sam Raimi’s wild camera work, ridiculous amounts of blood, and all the WTF moments that make this horror classic completely unhinged.
Was it terrifying, hilarious, or just pure chaos? Grab your snacks and find out. 🎬🔪
Your Pick, My Nightmare — where somebody’s first watch might just become their new nightmare.
11 Sept 2026
Episode 2-Misery (1990)
Jade and her guest take on Misery—because apparently being a famous writer and getting kidnapped by your biggest fan is just another day at the office. They break down the crazy characters, questionable decisions, WTF moments, and everything that makes this movie nightmare fuel. Grab your snacks and try not to get too attached to your ankles.
2 Sept 2026
Episode 1 - Sleepaway Camp (1983)
Episode 1: Sleepaway Camp
Jade and her guest dive into the 1983 horror classic Sleepaway Camp. One of them has seen it before, while the other is experiencing this infamous camp nightmare for the first time. We talk about the characters, the kills, the weirdness, the twists, and whether Sleepaway Camp still holds up decades later. Grab your snacks… and whatever you do, stay out of the woods.
2 Sept 2026
Episode 0
Every week, Jade and a different guest dive into a scary movie—the ones one of them has never seen before. We talk horror, bad decisions, unexpected favorites, WTF moments, and everything that makes a movie stick with you long after the credits roll.
And because sometimes the soundtrack deserves its own nightmare, we’ll also have mini episodes where we listen to songs one of us has never heard before and see what happens.
Reach and audience
Public platform figures. Ratings count people who left a rating, not total listeners.
Apple Podcasts (US)
5.0 / 5
2 ratings
Contact Your Pick, My Nightmare
Guest appearances
Books guests
Based on episode analysis; this does not confirm that the show is currently accepting guests.
Host of Your Pick, My Nightmare?
Claim your podcast to manage its listing and keep your show details accurate.
Pod Engine is an independent podcast discovery and analytics service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by this podcast. Artwork and show content belong to their owners. Full legal notice.
Explore this show Podcast research with Pod Engine
