23 Sept 2026
The New Censorship
WHEN JOURNALISTS CENSOR THEMSELVES
When we picture censorship, we imagine a heavy hand. A banned book, a redacted headline, a state official stamping out the truth. But what happens when the censor is a journalist's own hesitant hand over the keyboard?
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODEMedia scholar and former Haaretz editor Dr. Ayala Panievsky terms it strategic bias. Journalists facing populist attacks soften their tone, avoid specific words, and drop certain topics, all to prove they are not what their attackers claim. No one issues an order. No one needs to. And entire realities quietly disappear from the screen.
📚 In this conversation, we walk through her book The New Censorship, published with a foreword by Emily Maitlis. From Israeli newsrooms where the word occupation vanished from the vocabulary, to the BBC, to doxing campaigns forcing journalists to weigh a scoop against threats to their families, to what readers and listeners can actively do. Her most hopeful statement: "We haven't even started fighting."
⏱️ CHAPTERS(00:00) Introduction to Dr. Ayala Panievsky and the central argument of The New Censorship(02:43) From reality TV recaps to the newsroom: entering journalism without a master plan(06:15) Working across the Knesset, refugee aid efforts, and the Molad think tank(10:50) The erosion of public resistance: what became of the peace movement(15:28) The targeting of critical voices: Ilan Pappé, Francesca Albanese, Shlomo Sand(20:22) How far-right organizations deploy student recordings and smear tactics against academics(23:23) Military service as an alibi: how journalists defend against treason accusations, and who that excludes(30:10) Why the focus on Netanyahu misses the broader structural shift(32:07) Being targeted: transitioning from journalist and think-tank worker to researcher(36:56) Strategic bias defined: intentional self-censorship to signal neutrality(44:45) How the word "occupation" vanished from Israeli journalism(50:39) Why leaning right fails to appease populist critics(54:00) Ethical codes and the retreat into balanced panel formats(57:39) A global anti-media network: the UK, Hungary, India, and the US(01:01:56) Analyzing your home country while living in London(01:04:01) Emily Maitlis and structural parallels at the BBC(01:10:08) Why ratings alone cannot explain the asymmetrical platforming of the far right(01:16:02) Doxing, digital intimidation, and safety threats facing journalists' families(01:21:56) Billionaire media ownership, and why audiences must actively support journalists(01:27:18) Bot networks, impersonation, and holding fake accounts legally accountable(01:29:53) Treating our information environment with the urgency of environmental protection(01:33:45) Newsroom CPR: Covering Populism Responsibly(01:38:00) What AI can and cannot accomplish in journalism(01:41:48) Using the freedoms we still have before they vanish(01:46:10) Why individual action is not enough: the case for journalistic solidarity
🔗 RESOURCES & LINKS• The New Censorship by Dr. Ayala Panievsky, foreword by Emily Maitlis: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-New-Censorship/Ayala-Panievsky/9781804441114 (https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-New-Censorship/Ayala-Panievsky/9781804441114?utm_source=gemini)• Emily Maitlis interviews Prince Andrew (BBC Newsnight): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5VenaSmaNXQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5VenaSmaNXQ&utm_source=gemini)• Molad (Center for the Renewal of Israeli Democracy): https://www.molad.org/en/ (https://www.molad.org/en/?utm_source=gemini)• Peace Now (Shalom Achshav): https://peacenow.org.il/en/ (https://peacenow.org.il/en/?utm_source=gemini)